Poring over the 62 pages of the Independent Review into the Conduct of the Department of Children and Families report and its 45 recommendations, a multitude of systemic issues for the Northern Territory are made clear.
asserted
multitude → pore → Territory
Underneath all of these complex challenges remains a key issue: accountability.
asserted
issue → remain → challenges
It's a question that threads through a growing mountain of reports and their hundreds of recommendations made over many decades, detailing failures in reducing harm for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians.
asserted
that → grow → Australians
The NT government has committed to acting on all recommendations as a first step.
But the question remains: who has responsibility for making the changes to ensure children are kept safe?
asserted
children → commit → changes
Which leads to a further question.
asserted
Which → lead → question
What are the consequences if change does not happen?
asserted
change → happen → ?
Without an answer to these questions, communities are stuck with the status quo, or worse, having the wrong response applied without adequate means to correct course.
asserted
response → stick → course
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner Katie Kiss has acknowledged the NT government's response, emphasising the need for "implementation that delivers lasting change".
asserted
that → acknowledge → change
Commissioner Kiss also remarked that "the NT government still has not implemented the recommendations of the 2017 Royal Commission into child protection".
asserted
government → remark → protection
Currently, the consequences of inaction and inappropriate responses are evident in the Closing the Gap measures that remain locked in place, or widening on many counts.
asserted
that → close → counts
Youth crime, child removal, family and domestic violence patterns across Australia point to significant, systemic flaws in the way those with authority exercise their power.
asserted
those → point → power
This was made heartbreakingly clear in the alleged murder of Kumanjayi Little Baby.
asserted
This → make → Baby
WARNING: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander readers are advised that this article contains the image of an Indigenous person who has died, used with the permission of her family.
asserted
who → advise → family
Tackling the problem at the root
The review's co-authors singled out the immediate need for an audit into current safety plans.
asserted
authors → tackle → plans
This will ensure the appropriate people are given safety roles for the protection of children in the NT.
asserted
people → ensure → NT
In the case of Kumanjayi Little Baby, the review found that one person in her family's safety network had a "long criminal history of violence, including five counts of threaten to kill".
asserted
person → find → counts
Media reports and comments made in NT parliament have named this person as the man now charged with Kumanjayi Little Baby's murder.
asserted
reports → make → murder
Information such as this is of critical importance, so that all steps taken by authorised officers are based on relevant and appropriate processes.
But the co-authors were also determined to say that "the review does not suggest that a prior conviction, of itself, necessarily renders a person unsuitable" for a protective role.
asserted
person → take → role
Developing a clear mechanism for assessing the risk — the nature of which type of conviction represents a relevant threat — will be essential.
asserted
type → develop → threat
For a community with high rates of interaction with police, the justice system and incarceration, understanding the implications of this step is significant.
asserted
understanding → understand → step
These considerations sit within a broader landscape that presents myriad challenges for the most vulnerable.
asserted
that → sit → vulnerable
We see children born into families facing significant disadvantage and dysfunction, where even the most basic needs, such as finding a home or shelter and having a means of getting there, are hard to access and becoming more so.
asserted
children → see → means
This month has seen the 400-bed YiSSA short-stay accommodation centre closed in Darwin, while the Bush Bus service, which operates between remote communities and Alice Springs, has had funding cut.
asserted
funding → see → communities
Dealing with this is hard enough.
asserted
Dealing → deal → this
But, as the review also revealed, "the current practice places significant responsibility on the non-offending parent to protect the child" — a burden the parent carries while their own safety is in jeopardy.
asserted
safety → reveal → jeopardy
National Commissioner for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children and Young People, Sue-Anne Hunter, puts the onus on the Department of Children and Families.
asserted
Commissioner → put → Children
"The question that needed answering was what the department did with what it knew.
asserted
it → need → what
Responsibility for violence sits with the people who use it.
asserted
who → sit → it
Responsibility for the response sits with the department.
asserted
Responsibility → sit → department
It should never sit with a victim."
asserted
It → sit → victim
It's a view echoed by Muriel Bamblett, the chair of SNAICC, the peak body for community-controlled Indigenous children's services.
asserted
It → echo → services
She highlights the work of violence reduction programs in Victoria that tackle the problem at the root.
asserted
that → highlight → root
"You need behaviour change.
asserted
You → need → change
You need to be able to work with those communities around preventing violence,"she said.
asserted
You → need → communities
"In Victoria, we've got violence reduction now […] It has to take a public health approach."
Rushed remedies
There is much to consider around community and child safety and, with lives in the balance, it is worth looking at the record set so far.
asserted
it → get → record
One case stands out: the Northern Territory Emergency Response, or NT Intervention.
asserted
case → stand → ?
When the Howard government suspended Australia's Racial Discrimination Act on June 21, 2007, military units were deployed to discrete Aboriginal communities.
asserted
units → suspend → communities
The decision came after the release of the Ampe Akelyernemane Meke Mekarle "Little Children Are Sacred" report, led by Pat Anderson and Rex Wild QC.
asserted
Children → come → Anderson
Tasked with inquiring into the protection of Aboriginal children from sexual abuse, the co-chairs delivered a comprehensive 316-page report with 97 recommendations.
asserted
chairs → task → recommendations
Clear guidance was provided: "In the first recommendation, we have specifically referred to the critical importance of governments committing to genuine consultation with Aboriginal people in designing initiatives for Aboriginal communities, whether these be remote, regional or urban settings."
asserted
these → provide → communities
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia