Months after placing restrictions on many social media platforms for children under the age of 16, Australia is discovering that it's one thing to write a law, and another to make sure it's obeyed.
asserted
it → place → law
Australia is trying to control something that has transformed the lives of young people: the way they communicate, the information they're exposed to, even their entire experience of childhood.
asserted
they → try → childhood
Australia's social media ban has roots in a plan announced by Peter Malinauskas, the premier of the state of South Australia.
asserted
ban → have → Australia
He first announced plans for restrictions on social media platforms in his small home state of South Australia two years ago.
asserted
He → announce → Australia
"[Social media companies] are dictating who sees what, when in a way that is unregulated, unchecked, and ultimately driven by the profit motive," Malinauskas said.
asserted
Malinauskas → dictate → motive
"When a corporate operator is engaging in social engineering, then I think the government's got a role to play to stop it."
asserted
government → engage → it
Why some lawmakers and parents want the ban
Malinauskas was urged into action by his wife, Annabel West, and felt that he'd have the backing of "the overwhelming majority of Australian parents" to take on Big Tech companies.
asserted
he → want → companies
And, according to polls, the vast majority of Australians are on his side.
uncertain
majority → accord → side
When Malinauskas announced that his state would legislate, the Australian national government quickly followed suit, with bipartisan support.
asserted
government → announce → support
Malinauskas said he knows the ban isn't a perfect solution, and that kids will find ways around it.
asserted
kids → say → it
"But they're doing it less than what they otherwise would if you didn't have a community standard in place," he said.
asserted
he → do → place
Malinauskas also feels it's important to stop kids from getting hooked on social media in the first place.
asserted
it → feel → place
"Trying to get in early to stop it before the rot sets in was part of the objective," he said.
asserted
he → try → objective
Parent Wayne Holdsworth has visited more than 100 Australian schools to talk about the hazards of social media.
asserted
Holdsworth → visit → media
In 2022, his teenage son, Mac, was manipulated into sharing an intimate photo of himself on social media.
asserted
son → manipulate → media
Mac thought he was communicating with a fellow teen, but it was a criminal in his 40s who threatened to share the photo publicly if Mac didn't pay.
asserted
Mac → think → photo
The criminal followed through, sending the photo to Mac's friends and family members.
asserted
criminal → follow → friends
Mac took his own life the following year.
asserted
Mac → take → life
"We elect the government to ensure that we're safe, and that includes children.
asserted
that → elect → children
And they have not been safe, because there's been organizations that have come into Australia that have damaged them," Holdsworth said.
asserted
Holdsworth → be → them
"And finally, Australia, first country in the world, introduced legislation to prevent those tech giants damaging our children."
asserted
giants → introduce → children
In the first three months of the ban, the number of 10- to 15-year-olds holding at least one account on age-restricted social media fell by around 20%, according to research from Australia's online safety watchdog.
uncertain
number → hold → watchdog
Fights against the law
Not all Australians support the ban.
asserted
Australians → support → ban
Noah Jones, a teen who's become the face of the fight against the legislation, was 15 when the ban went into effect.
asserted
ban → become → effect
Now, he's a witness in a legal challenge in Australia's high court, made on the grounds that the ban violates the right to political communication.
asserted
ban → make → communication
"It's just unfair," Jones said.
asserted
Jones → say → ?
"I understand drinking laws, consent, all stuff like that, but why should we be blocked from information?"
asserted
we → understand → information
He feels social media is a necessity in this day and age.
asserted
media → feel → day
"Social media is the modern town square," Jones said.
asserted
Jones → say → ?
"It's where information's being passed around, and everyone uses it."
asserted
everyone → pass → it
He has a message for the other countries thinking about implementing social media bans of their own: Don't do it.
asserted
He → have → it
"There's a lot of better ways to fix the content and problems on social media, and one of those ways is not silencing free speech," he said.
Is Australia's ban actually keeping teens off social media?
There are also questions about how effective the restrictions are. Jones demonstrated how one social media platform scanned his face with artificial intelligence and decided he was old enough to keep his account.
asserted
he → be → account
Others made it even easier — all he had to do was lie about his age.
asserted
he → make → age
Three months after the social media ban came into effect, 50% of children under 16 who still held accounts said they hadn't even been asked to confirm their age by social media platforms, according to Australia's independent eSafety commissioner.
uncertain
they → come → commissioner
What the tech companies say
In the U.S., tech titans have been brought in front of Congress to face families who said their young relatives had been exploited, abused or killed through social media.
asserted
relatives → say → media
This year, Meta and YouTube were
for creating products that led to harmful and addictive behavior by young users in a landmark social media addiction trial.
asserted
that → create → trial
Both companies have appealed the ruling.
asserted
companies → appeal → ruling
Meta, the company behind Facebook and Instagram, told 60 Minutes it's complying with the Australian law but said "blanket social media bans are ineffective because they push teens to unregulated corners of the internet."
asserted
they → tell → internet
The company said it's working to protect child safety with measures built into its social media platforms.
asserted
it → say → platforms
Snap, which developed Snapchat, said it's taking the Australian law seriously.
asserted
it → develop → law
…and 18 more, not listed.
The Aporia
