A Colorado woman who offers abortion alternatives outside clinics is battling a state law that prohibits her from approaching someone too closely, warning the rule has turned what she considers a compassionate conversation into a legal risk.
asserted
she → offer → risk
Wendy Faustin, a pro-life sidewalk counselor challenging Colorado's so-called "bubble law," told Fox News Digital the restrictions prevent her from quietly offering women information about pregnancy resource centers, adoption agencies and other alternatives to abortion.
asserted
restrictions → challenge → abortion
"If you're within 100 feet of the entrance to an abortion clinic, I can't approach someone within 8 feet to give them any alternative information," Faustin said.
asserted
Faustin → approach → information
Last July, a federal judge rejected her challenge to the Colorado law.
asserted
judge → reject → law
Colorado state law and a Denver municipal ordinance prohibit individuals from knowingly approaching within eight feet of another person without their consent to distribute literature or engage in protest, education or counseling within 100 feet of a health care facility entrance, including abortion clinics.
asserted
law → prohibit → clinics
Violations are classified as a petty offense, which carries with it a fine or even a possible short jail sentence.
asserted
which → classify → fine
The U.S. Supreme Court upheld Colorado's 1993 law in its 2000 decision in Hill v. Colorado, ruling that the restrictions did not violate the First Amendment.
asserted
restrictions → uphold → Amendment
The restriction, she said, forces her to speak from a distance about an intensely personal subject, potentially allowing others to overhear conversations she would prefer to keep private.
asserted
she → say → conversations
"I would rather be able to just walk up to somebody, offer them alternative information, places where they can get help," she said.
asserted
she → walk → help
"I believe that every woman who is facing this decision deserves to have all the possible information that she might need," Faustin said.
uncertain
Faustin → believe → that
"Sometimes she's feeling kind of backed into a corner by circumstances or maybe by other people, and she may not be aware that there can be help somewhere for her through a crisis pregnancy center, an adoption agency, and so that's all the information that I give is offering her information where she can get help and also information about the development of her baby."
uncertain
she → feel → baby
Her attorney, Roger Byron, senior counsel for First Liberty Institute, argued the dispute extends far beyond abortion and raises fundamental questions about the First Amendment.
asserted
dispute → argue → Amendment
"These laws literally make it a crime for Wendy to approach within 8 feet of a woman," Byron told Fox News Digital, describing restrictions he says would not survive constitutional scrutiny if applied to other forms of protest.
asserted
he → make → protest
"These laws would be struck down immediately if they restricted anti-war protesters or union workers on strike outside of their employer's facility," Byron said.
asserted
Byron → strike → facility
"However, because they restrict pro-life sidewalk counselors, they do not.
asserted
they → restrict → counselors
This decision, Hill versus Colorado from the Supreme Court and the statutes that it protects, make sidewalk counselors, because of their pro-life message, second-class citizens.
asserted
counselors → protect → message
It literally creates two First Amendments.
asserted
It → create → Amendments
"
"What's at stake is the free speech rights of anyone whose message is something other than what the government wants it to be," he said.
asserted
he → want → what
Byron said the ruling at the Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit will determine what happens next.
asserted
what → say → Circuit
"I suspect either way, this case is going to end up in front of the U.S. Supreme Court," Byron said.
asserted
Byron → suspect → Court
Fox News Digital reached out to the office of the Colorado attorney general for comment, and a spokesperson said that the office has no comment beyond its filings.
asserted
office → reach → filings
The Aporia
