At a crowded rally in Dayton, Ohio Monday night, celebrity singer John Legend characterized Vivek Ramaswamy as “desperate” and morally depraved.
asserted
Legend → characterize → Ramaswamy
“He will stoop lower than you thought possible,” Legend said of Ramaswamy, the billionaire biotech entrepreneur and Ohio’s Republican candidate for governor.
asserted
Legend → stoop → governor
Legend was, of course, referencing Ramaswamy’s controversial advertisement against Democratic opponent Dr. Amy Acton.
asserted
Legend → reference → Acton
It features Acton’s 82-year-old mother, who lost custody of her children after her husband was indicted in 1978 for raping Acton at the age of 12.
asserted
husband → feature → 12
Despite warrants for his arrest, the stepfather and Acton’s mother fled Ohio together and Acton never saw them again.
asserted
Acton → flee → them
But in Ramaswamy’s ad, Acton’s mom, Donna Arthur, calls her estranged daughter a “liar” who isn’t fit to be governor.
“When Vivek Ramaswamy hears of an indicted child abuser who fled the state rather than face charges, instead of siding with the victim, he takes the side of the abuser.
asserted
he → call → abuser
Dayton, do we want Vivek Ramaswamy to be in charge of protecting Ohio’s children?
asserted
Ramaswamy → want → children
Do we want a man with this sort of depraved moral compass to lead our state?” asked Legend, an Ohio native.
asserted
Legend → want → state
A few Ohio Republicans have offered tepid criticism of Ramaswamy.
asserted
Republicans → offer → Ramaswamy
Outgoing Ohio Governor Mike DeWine said the media spot was “deeply, deeply troubling.”
asserted
spot → say → ?
And incumbent Sen. Jon Husted, who faces a tight Senate race against Democrat Sherrod Brown next week, said he “would not have run that ad.”
asserted
he → face → ad
But nationally, party leaders doubled down: Vice President JD Vance told Republicans to “stop whining” about the ad.
asserted
Vance → double → ad
President Donald Trump rebuked DeWine, accusing him of being, “as usual, disloyal to the Republican Party.”
“He probably wants a Dumocrat to win,” Trump wrote on social media about DeWine.
asserted
Trump → rebuke → DeWine
Waiting in line for Monday’s rally, several Democratic voters said they believe Ramaswamy’s advertisement indeed may have that effect, helping Ohio Democrats like Acton best their Republican opponents in already-tight races.
uncertain
Democrats → wait → races
A Dayton-area history teacher (who asked me not to publish her name because it could get her in trouble with her school) said the advertisement was “slimy.”
uncertain
advertisement → ask → school
But in a way, she was also grateful that Ramaswamy was airing it publicly.
asserted
Ramaswamy → air → it
“It’s making people pull away seeing that half the Republican Party is like that.
asserted
Party → make → that
You have a president who was found liable for sexual crimes, and Vivek, who is exploiting victims of sexual crimes,” she said.
asserted
she → have → crimes
“I hate that she had to relive that, but there’s no better way for them to show people who they really are,” added Jennifer Voudris, another rally-goer.
asserted
Voudris → hate → people
Democrats at the rally told me about anecdotal signs giving them hope that Ohio may elect its first Democrat to statewide office since 2018:
uncertain
Ohio → tell → 2018
One man told me he saw a lontime Republican neighbor post on Facebook that he could no longer vote for Ramaswamy in good conscience after seeing the advertisement.
uncertain
he → tell → advertisement
Multiple people flagged that there had been strong turnout this week for early voting, which statistically favors Democrats.
asserted
which → flag → Democrats
Theresa Gasper, a former Republican turned Democrat precinct captain for Beaver Creek, Ohio, said that after the ad came out she quickly ran out of her anti-Ramaswamy yard signs.
asserted
she → turn → signs
She had been offering them for a suggested donation of $15, with all proceeds going to her local Democratic Party.
uncertain
proceeds → offer → Party
When the 250 signs she made weren’t selling, she instead listed them for free.
asserted
she → make → them
“They became really popular when I offered them for free, but after THE ad last week, the rest went really fast,” Gasper explained.
asserted
Gasper → become → ad
She emailed me later to let me know she didn’t ultimately make it inside the event.
asserted
she → email → event
The venue—a former industrial coal depot that is now a popular spot for concerts and weddings—had exceeded its fire capacity.
asserted
that → exceed → capacity
Perhaps slightly more scientific than yard sign litmus tests and one-off Facebook posts, recent polls have also shown Acton ahead.
asserted
Acton → show → tests
A large-sample Marist survey conducted from October 15 to 18 showed Acton ahead of Ramaswamy by seven points.
asserted
Acton → conduct → points
An October 15 to 19 poll by Fox showed Acton ahead by two.
asserted
Acton → show → two
Those were both before the advertisement, which began circulating October 20.
asserted
which → begin → advertisement
But a Redbox Research poll conducted October 20 to 23 saw Acton up by four points.
asserted
Acton → conduct → points
David Niven, a political science professor at the University of Cincinnati, said he thinks Ramaswamy’s attack advertisement may drag him down even more.
uncertain
advertisement → say → him
He also mentioned Husted could be collateral damage amid the GOP fallout.
uncertain
Husted → mention → fallout
“There is a reason so many Republican candidates distanced themselves from this ad—which is an extraordinary step to take in a party that for years has perfected the right to remain silent and look away from the outrageous
asserted
that → be → outrageous
,” said Niven.
asserted
Niven → say → ?
When Acton took the stage toward the end of the rally, she didn’t want anyone to “look away.”
asserted
anyone → take → rally
“You probably have been hearing by now that I had a pretty rough childhood growing up.
asserted
I → hear → childhood
My brother and I experienced a lot of abuse and neglect,” she said, before pointing out that she likely wasn’t the only person in the room who had experienced something similar.
asserted
who → experience → something
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
