The leader of Alberta’s Opposition says the United Conservative Party government is rigging riding boundaries for its own advantage ahead of next year’s election, while Premier Danielle Smith argues the NDP is getting ready to deny voting results.
asserted
NDP → say → results
NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi said Wednesday that a report put before an all-party committee gerrymanders ridings in Lethbridge and Calgary, diluting NDP support in favour of the UCP.
asserted
report → say → UCP
Smith, faced in the legislature with allegations of cheating, shot back.
asserted
Smith → face → cheating
She questioned why Nenshi was talking about a report that hasn’t yet been delivered to legislature members.
asserted
that → question → members
“He’s already pre-positioning another election denialism, trying to pre-frame the results as if it’s going to have an impact on the next election,” said Smith, who also demanded an apology.
asserted
who → pre → apology
Nenshi said the report suggests the panel in charge of drafting new boundaries appeared to receive instructions from the government and wasn’t independent.
uncertain
panel → say → government
“Everything about it violates every democratic norm in Alberta.
asserted
Everything → violate → Alberta
Why is the government so scared of fair elections?” he asked.
asserted
he → ask → elections
Smith accused Nenshi of questioning the integrity of judges, including Brian O’Ferrall, a former judge and the chair of the panel responsible for the redraw.
asserted
Smith → accuse → redraw
“What a disgrace!” she said.
asserted
she → say → ?
Nenshi said the real disgrace is “the people of Lethbridge being wiped off the map.”
asserted
people → say → map
“How can the premier think this is legal, acceptable, moral or constitutional?” he asked.
asserted
he → think → ?
Smith retorted that Nenshi should “put on his big boy pants,” quit complaining and start campaigning instead.
asserted
Nenshi → retort → complaining
The next provincial election is set for Oct. 18, 2027.
asserted
election → set → Oct.
Gerrymandering is a tactic that sees voting districts designed not to reflect geography or population patterns but to concentrate or fragment voters to benefit a particular political party.
asserted
districts → see → party
Nenshi said if the proposed Alberta boundary map passes a legislature vote, the NDP would take it to court on constitutional grounds.
asserted
NDP → say → grounds
The Constitution protects voters’ rights to effective representation.
asserted
Constitution → protect → representation
“What we’re seeing today is an unprecedented attack on Canadian democracy,” he said.
asserted
he → see → democracy
“If we go forward with this, this will be the legacy of this government: that they cared about power so much that they didn’t want fair elections; that they wanted to cheat to win.”
asserted
they → go → elections
The report, presented only to committee members, has not been made public.
asserted
report → present → members
It’s expected to be tabled in the legislature next week.
asserted
It → expect → legislature
The NDP members on the committee, Christina Gray and Kathleen Ganley, said they briefed Nenshi and that the report includes proposals to split the city of Lethbridge from the two urban ridings into four that take in surrounding rural areas.
asserted
that → say → areas
Lethbridge is currently split between the UCP and NDP.
asserted
Lethbridge → split → UCP
They also told the committee the same is happening in three northwest Calgary ridings.
asserted
same → tell → ridings
Recent provincial elections have seen the UCP dominate in rural areas and smaller cities, while the NDP has controlled Edmonton.
asserted
NDP → see → Edmonton
The two have battled for advantage in Calgary.
asserted
two → battle → Calgary
The UCP holds a majority of votes on the committee.
asserted
UCP → hold → committee
Chair Brandon Lunty, a UCP backbencher, wouldn’t comment on the contents of the report and declined to respond to accusations of gerrymandering.
asserted
Lunty → comment → gerrymandering
“I think it’s important that we respect the process,” he told reporters.
asserted
he → think → reporters
He said legislature members are allowed to discuss such reports with each other but that he believes the NDP abused the process by discussing the report publicly.
asserted
NDP → say → report
The boundary review and report come after a previous bipartisan boundary commission was split in its recommendations after months of public consultations.
asserted
commission → come → consultations
Dallas Miller, the chair of that commission, tried to avoid the minority report’s alternative boundaries that would blend many urban and rural ridings.
asserted
that → try → ridings
He suggested a compromise.
uncertain
He → suggest → compromise
Miller said the legislature could revisit the process with an eye to boosting the number of ridings to 91 from 87.
uncertain
legislature → say → 87
Smith said at the time that her government was following Miller’s recommendation when it formed the committee of legislature members to oversee the work of a new panel.
asserted
it → say → panel
She denied accusations from the NDP that her government was pulling strings behind the process or that it would be directing the new panel to come up with proposals based on the minority’s recommendations.
asserted
it → deny → recommendations
Gray said during Wednesday’s meeting that the new report implies the government wanted to adopt the minority recommendations.
asserted
government → say → recommendations
Gray, quoting from a page of the report, said the panel was “assisted by the recommendations of the much-maligned minority commissioners.”
asserted
panel → quote → commissioners
“Within the report, we also see the UCP majority appointees continue to praise the minority commissioners,” Gray said.
asserted
Gray → see → commissioners
The Aporia
