Spain was once regarded as a world leader in rail systems, but after suffering two of its deadliest train incidents in over a decade this year alone, questions have emerged.
asserted
questions → regard → decade
The country has commenced three days of mourning after at least 69 people died, and dozens more were injured, after two high-speed trains collided just south of the capital Madrid on Wednesday.
asserted
trains → commence → Wednesday
A computer system failure saw six trains stopped on just over 60km of track between Madrid and Seville, while another was manually given clearance to move, according to Spain's Transport Minister Óscar Puente.
uncertain
another → see → Puente
Spain's high-speed rail network, operated by state-owned RENFE, is among the largest in the world, second only to China.
asserted
network → operate → China
In January, 46 people died on the same rail network after two high-speed trains carrying around 400 passengers collided.
asserted
trains → die → passengers
According to European Union data, rail fatality rates in Europe have decreased over the last decade, and last year recorded no fatalities or major accidents.
uncertain
rates → accord → fatalities
However, a series of accidents in 2023 saw a spike in those numbers.
asserted
series → see → numbers
Between 2022 and 2024, Spain had some of the fewest fatalities per million train kilometres in Europe.
asserted
Spain → have → Europe
University of Sydney's Rico Merkert, who specialises in European transport systems, said isolated incidents shifted people's perception around safety.
asserted
incidents → specialise → safety
There are millions of people travelling on those trains," Professor Merkert said.
asserted
Merkert → be → trains
"But statistically speaking, it's still safe due to the large volumes of passengers using trains and high-speed trains every single day in Europe."
asserted
it → speak → Europe
He added that the European Train Control System (ETCS) prevented trains from reaching excessive speeds and could recognise when there was potential for a collision.
uncertain
System → add → collision
"The problem with the accident that happened [this week] is that there was a signalling sort of failure,"he said.
asserted
that → happen → failure,"he
"There was a system issue, so it broke down, and it's not quite clear whether that ETCS system was actually operating at all or partially unavailable.
asserted
system → be → ?
It looks like that system failure caused manual operations or signalling.
asserted
failure → look → operations
"
How does train safety in Europe compare?
asserted
safety → compare → Europe
A report into railway safety from the European Union found Australia, South Korea and the EU were among the safest railway systems between 2022 and 2024.
asserted
Australia → find → 2022
It also looked into passenger fatalities and found Japan was the safest, with no fatalities recorded.
asserted
fatalities → look → fatalities
Professor Merkert said it was difficult to compare Australia's rail system to Europe, because it does not have high-speed trains.
"
asserted
it → say → trains
[It] is not comparing apples with apples … high-speed trains are between 250 and 300 kilometres an hour, and you simply don't have those trains operating here in Australia," he said.
asserted
he → compare → Australia
The report into railway safety said the gap in passenger fatality rates between Europe and Japan would be difficult to close in the medium term.
asserted
gap → say → term
Professor Merkert said that was due to Japan's long tradition of running high-speed rail safely and efficiently.
asserted
that → say → rail
"Similarly, China, they had a few incidents themselves, but overall again, the number of trains that they're operating and the number of people using those trains without having any accidents is quite remarkable," he said.
asserted
he → have → accidents
He said overall railway systems were safe, but once automated, additional safety procedures were required.
asserted
procedures → say → ?
"There needs to be manual safeguards and governance structure in place that prevent things like what has happened [this week], and that simply seems to not have occurred,"he said.
asserted
that → need → things
The Aporia
