State and federal officials have ramped up scrutiny of online sports betting companies in recent weeks, launching inquiries, demanding information and, in one case, proposing a new rule that would limit when companies like DraftKings can pitch their users to bet more.
asserted
companies → ramp → users
The moves — by gaming regulators, government lawyers and federal lawmakers — follow an investigation last month by ProPublica that tested the guardrails DraftKings and other sports betting companies have in place to protect users from spiraling out of control.
asserted
DraftKings → follow → control
That system is called responsible gaming, and executives say it’s integral to their companies’ long-term success.
asserted
it → call → success
The ProPublica article showed how DraftKings bestowed VIP status on a reporter who deliberately bet like a problem gambler.
asserted
who → show → gambler
The report detailed the ways in which the app’s user design and promotions encouraged more betting — even after the reporter opted into responsible gaming tools designed to slow users down.
asserted
reporter → detail → users
A week earlier, The New York Times reported that DraftKings had used machine learning and artificial intelligence to target promotions to losing bettors.
asserted
DraftKings → report → bettors
Those articles were the focus of an Oct. 15 meeting of the Louisiana Gaming Control Board, which, partly in response to the stories, tabled the renewal of DraftKings’ five-year license.
asserted
which → table → license
Instead, the board granted the company a temporary four-month permit while investigators look into the issues raised in the reports as well as other paperwork concerns.
asserted
investigators → grant → reports
The board’s chair, Christopher Hebert, said the Times had raised some “very serious questions” and called ProPublica’s reporting “very troubling.”
asserted
Times → say → reporting
While news stories “are not findings of regulatory violations,” Hebert said, “as regulators we have a responsibility to examine these matters that could affect the integrity of gaming operations and the protections of our citizens here in Louisiana.”
uncertain
that → say → Louisiana
State health officials say the number of Louisianans believed to have a gambling disorder has risen in recent years amid the surge in popularity of online gambling and prediction market sites.
asserted
number → say → gambling
One top official reported this summer that gambling addiction was among the health department’s “top three priorities.”
asserted
addiction → report → priorities
If you’ve bet on sports with FanDuel or DraftKings, you can help ProPublica understand how these apps work.
asserted
apps → bet → FanDuel
Paul Liberman, who co-founded DraftKings and serves as its president of operations, told the regulators: “We do not use artificial intelligence to target losing gamblers by any means.”
asserted
We → co → means
DraftKings previously told ProPublica that it proactively closes the accounts of suspected problem gamblers “all the time” but declined to provide specific figures.
asserted
it → tell → figures
Yet when asked by a Louisiana board member for those same specifics, Lori Kalani, DraftKings’ chief responsible gaming officer, said 175 accounts in the state had been shut down this year.
asserted
accounts → ask → state
She told the board she didn’t know how many total users DraftKings had in the Pelican State.
asserted
DraftKings → tell → State
“We’re not physicians, we’re not clinicians and that’s not our role, but we certainly want to help people enjoy the service, the platform that we’re offering them,” Kalani told the board.
asserted
Kalani → ’re → them
“I know that we’re doing our job and that when we see something, we say something and we engage.
asserted
we → know → something
I just can’t tell you if 175 is the right number.
asserted
175 → tell → you
I wish it was zero.”
asserted
it → wish → ?
In a statement, a DraftKings spokesperson said: “As a legal, regulated operator, DraftKings values an open and ongoing dialogue with regulators and regular conversations and check-ins with regulators are normal course of business.”
asserted
conversations → say → business
In response to ProPublica’s original investigation, Kalani said DraftKings’ responsible gaming system — which consists largely of in-app messages about the company’s tools — “worked the way it was supposed to.”
asserted
it → say → tools
She cautioned against “drawing broad conclusions” from one user’s experience.
asserted
She → caution → experience
The day after the Louisiana meeting, regulators in Ohio proposed an amendment to the state’s sports gaming rule that would bar companies like DraftKings from sending direct ads or marketing to bettors for 48 hours after they’d opted into responsible gaming tools or updated their current settings.
asserted
they → propose → settings
The proposed amendment speaks directly to a finding in ProPublica’s reporting: After blowing nearly $4,500 betting on tennis in 24 hours, the reporter used such tools to limit the amount of time and money he could spend on the app.
uncertain
he → propose → app
Just 30 minutes later, though, he received the first of four push notifications promoting new betting opportunities.
asserted
he → receive → opportunities
It wasn’t until he opted into a far more restrictive tool, called a “cool-off,” that the notifications temporarily stopped.
asserted
notifications → opt → tool
Andromeda Morrison, the interim executive director of the Ohio Casino Control Commission, said that though her office had been working on its proposal for some time, ProPublica’s story illuminated the issue.
asserted
story → say → issue
“Hopefully this is something that is fairly easy for the industry to see as a common sense restriction to make sure those consumers are making good choices without those push notifications,” she said.
asserted
she → see → notifications
But Keith Whyte, a former director of the National Council on Problem Gambling who now consults for industry and nonprofit groups, said the proposed amendment could unintentionally disincentivize users from using tools like deposit limits.
uncertain
amendment → consult → limits
“I think the implication is that using a responsible gaming tool is a sign of a gambling problem,” he said.
asserted
he → think → problem
The measure faces a long rulemaking process, including more rounds of public hearings and comments.
asserted
measure → face → hearings
Sports betting operators are also feeling the heat at the federal level.
asserted
operators → feel → level
Citing ProPublica’s reporting, three Democrats who have long called for industry reforms are now demanding more information from major sports betting and prediction market companies about how the businesses entice their customers.
asserted
businesses → cite → customers
The letters are signed by Connecticut Sen. Richard Blumenthal, New York Rep. Paul Tonko and North Carolina Rep. Valerie Foushee.
asserted
letters → sign → Blumenthal
They asked the companies to answer a series of questions, including how many customers are enrolled in their VIP programs and how much revenue is generated by them.
asserted
revenue → ask → them
“As repeated stories from exploited gamblers and media reports have vividly documented, VIP programs are driving the gambling industry’s most susceptible customers into debt and addiction through rewards tied to waging ever increasing amounts of money,” the lawmakers wrote.
asserted
lawmakers → repeat → money
DraftKings conferred VIP status on a ProPublica reporter after he lost close to $6,000 in three weeks on the app by chasing losses with long-shot bets, playing late into the night and firing risky wagers on fast action, like whether a major league baseball player will take a strike, a ball or connect for a hit — betting behavior that experts say are clear red flags of problem gambling.
asserted
experts → confer → gambling
In a statement, DraftKings said it would “respond accordingly once we have had a chance to review” the letter.
asserted
we → say → letter
…and 10 more, not listed.
The Aporia
