A Montreal couple says a surrogacy journey they hoped would finally help them become parents instead ended in heartbreak, financial disputes and a lawsuit against the agency they hired.
asserted
they → say → agency
Kristina Kasparian and Jeremy Cohen say they spent 11 years trying to have a child.
asserted
they → say → child
After years of fertility struggles and repeated miscarriages, they turned to surrogacy and signed on with Ontario-based Canadian Fertility Consulting (CFC).
asserted
they → repeat → Consulting
The couple was matched with a surrogate who became pregnant with their embryo in 2023.
asserted
who → match → 2023
“Everything was developing normally and we were extremely excited, but also we felt very fragile because we had never gotten that far in a pregnancy on our own,” Kasparian said.
asserted
Kasparian → develop → own
“I always miscarried around six to eight weeks.”
asserted
I → miscarry → weeks
Their hopes were shattered in December 2023 when they learned the baby’s heartbeat had stopped.
asserted
heartbeat → shatter → December
Their child was delivered stillborn days later.
asserted
child → deliver → ?
“Getting the news from the surrogate, it was almost unbelievable,” Cohen said.
asserted
Cohen → get → surrogate
I wasn’t really sure how to react, but I was trying to be as supportive as possible for herself having to go through this and for ourselves thinking, OK, this is really the end of the line.”
asserted
this → react → line
Get daily National news
Earlier this year, the couple filed a lawsuit against Canadian Fertility Consulting seeking nearly $200,000.
asserted
couple → get → 200,000
The lawsuit alleges the company breached its contract and failed to properly oversee expense reimbursements submitted by the surrogate.
asserted
company → allege → surrogate
The couple is also seeking damages, alleging the experience caused them significant psychological harm.
asserted
experience → seek → harm
In its statement of defence, CFC denies breaching its contracts and argues the lawsuit was filed outside the applicable limitation period.
asserted
lawsuit → deny → period
The allegations have not been proven in court.
asserted
allegations → prove → court
The dispute centres on expense claims the couple says they reimbursed during the pregnancy.
uncertain
they → centre → pregnancy
Under Canadian law, surrogates cannot be paid for carrying a child but can be reimbursed for certain pregnancy-related expenses.
asserted
surrogates → pay → expenses
Kasparian and Cohen allege that among 575 receipts provided through CFC, some were duplicates, some were unrelated to the pregnancy and others were dated months before the pregnancy began.
asserted
pregnancy → allege → pregnancy
“After all these expenses that were just so unnecessary, if the CFC had taken better care of these receipts in the first place, then we wouldn’t be in this position,” Cohen said.
asserted
Cohen → take → position
It just makes you feel taken advantage of.”
asserted
you → make → advantage
A lawyer representing CFC declined to comment beyond the company’s court filings.
asserted
lawyer → represent → filings
In an emailed statement, Health Canada said it could not comment on specific cases because of privacy concerns.
uncertain
it → email → concerns
A spokesperson said complaints are reviewed and prioritized, and that if a contravention of the law is identified, the department has several enforcement options available.
asserted
options → say → law
Despite the loss, the couple attempted surrogacy again in 2024 through a different agency and with another surrogate.
asserted
couple → attempt → surrogate
That pregnancy also ended with a loss.
asserted
pregnancy → end → loss
Now, they say they are coming to terms with the possibility they may never have a child.
uncertain
they → say → child
“My hope is that if we can’t have this dream, then I really would like surrogacy to be safer and more ethical and transparent for others in Canada and abroad,” Kasparian said.
asserted
Kasparian → have → Canada
“If I could help with that, then it would have been worthwhile.”
uncertain
it → help → that
The Aporia
