In September, California became the second state in America to certify a statewide rideshare workers union.
asserted
California → become → union
Under a recently passed law, this new union—the California Gig Workers Union—will negotiate directly with Uber and Lyft on behalf of all rideshare drivers in the state.
asserted
union → pass → state
The ultimate agreement will set industry-wide standards for rideshare in the Golden State.
asserted
agreement → set → State
California is one of a handful of deep-blue states that have passed what are known as sectoral bargaining laws for the gig economy.
asserted
what → pass → economy
In 2024, Massachusetts became the first state to pass a sectoral bargaining law for rideshare drivers.
asserted
Massachusetts → become → drivers
California passed its version in 2025, followed by Illinois joining the parade in 2026.
asserted
Illinois → pass → 2026
Rather than requiring unions to negotiate with individual companies, these laws allow sector-wide negotiations, which could lead to one-size-fits-all outcomes that limit flexibility for both companies and workers.
uncertain
that → require → companies
Most concerning of all, this sectoral approach is unlikely to stop with the gig economy.
asserted
approach → concern → economy
Progressive labor lawyers and policy wonks are now pushing for sectoral bargaining to become the new normal in modern-day America.
asserted
bargaining → push → America
Under California's law, a prospective union merely needs to demonstrate that it has 10 percent support among active gig drivers in order to receive a list with the contact information of all remaining active drivers in the state.
asserted
it → need → state
(The gig companies are compelled to hand over this information to California's Public Employment Relations Board on a quarterly basis.)
asserted
companies → compel → basis
Once a union increases its support to at least 30 percent of active drivers, it becomes certified unless a competing union demonstrates its own 30 percent support.
asserted
union → increase → support
Notably, the statute defines "active drivers" as those who have provided the median number of rides (or more) over a six-month period.
asserted
who → define → period
Further, drivers with fewer than 20 rides are excluded.
asserted
drivers → exclude → rides
Put another way, this means that the support thresholds—10 percent and 30 percent—are functionally a much smaller percentage of total drivers than the statutory thresholds might suggest.
uncertain
thresholds → put → drivers
The California Gig Workers Union recently achieved recognition and now will commence bargaining with Lyft and Uber.
asserted
Union → achieve → Lyft
In Massachusetts, the statewide drivers union has already been negotiating with the rideshare companies for several months.
asserted
union → negotiate → months
So far, these sectoral models have been confined to the gig economy.
asserted
models → confine → economy
The legal reason for this is that, as independent contractors, gig workers are not "covered" employees under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA).
asserted
workers → cover → Act
This means that sectoral laws in the gig context are arguably not preempted by federal law.
asserted
laws → mean → law
Under this theory, these sectoral models would not be able to expand to more traditional "covered" employees in other industries.
asserted
models → expand → industries
But there's evidence that some progressive law professors and policy wonks would still like to expand the approach.
asserted
professors → be → approach
Harvard's Center for Labor and a Just Economy (HCLJE) recently received coverage for releasing a model sectoral bargaining law that could be applied to various other non-covered industries under the NLRA, such as agriculture and domestic service.
uncertain
that → receive → agriculture
While this seems limited only to areas the NLRA does not presently reach, Benjamin Sachs, the faculty co-director of HCLJE and a law professor at Harvard, has been pushing novel legal theories to circumvent NLRA preemption.
asserted
Sachs → seem → preemption
One idea advanced by Sachs is that a union-friendly National Labor Relations Board in a future presidential administration could "decline to assert jurisdiction" over certain categories of employers under the NLRA, which theoretically could empower states to extend sectoral bargaining to any number of industries.
uncertain
which → advance → industries
For one, they undermine worker choice and will likely lead to the imposition of more one-size-fits-all standards for industries.
asserted
size → undermine → industries
In the gig context, this could mean more rigid scheduling arrangements, which erode the very flexibility that gig workers most desire.
uncertain
workers → mean → that
In Germany, which has long operated under a sectoral bargaining model, there's also evidence that the system has reduced market dynamism.
asserted
system → operate → dynamism
German workers are generally less productive than American workers, and while not all of the country's economic issues can be attributed to sectoral bargaining alone, the German economy has struggled under a broad set of labor rules that have contributed to its sclerosis.
asserted
that → attribute → sclerosis
This helps explain some recent changes.
asserted
This → help → changes
Flexibility reforms to the German sectoral system have helped its economy rebound to a degree.
asserted
economy → help → degree
Under President Emmanuel Macron, France has similarly sought to reform its sectoral bargaining system and devolve more decision making to the company-wide, rather than sector-wide, level.
asserted
France → seek → level
As the California Gig Workers Union's recent certification shows, sectoral bargaining is spreading in the gig economy.
asserted
bargaining → show → economy
And the endgame doesn't stop with gig.
asserted
endgame → stop → gig
America could go the way of Germany before we realize it.
uncertain
we → go → it
The Aporia
