In short:
Case law cited in the Supreme Court in Hobart, which was found to be hallucinated by AI, has sparked calls for the resignation of members of the parole board by a justice advocate.
asserted
which → cite → advocate
The use of AI by the board in its argument against a gag order on convicted murderer Susan Neill-Fraser being lifted has led to a demand for an explanation by the state's attorney-general.
What's next?
A prominent legal advocate has questioned how widespread the board's use of AI is and has called for an audit.
asserted
use → convict → audit
Tasmania's attorney-general has sought an explanation from the state's parole board about its professional standards after it was revealed that AI-generated case law was used to justify a parole condition for convicted murderer Susan Neill-Fraser.
asserted
law → seek → Fraser
Neill-Fraser served 13 years in jail for the murder of her partner Bob Chappell aboard their yacht in 2009.
asserted
Fraser → serve → 2009
She was released on parole in 2022, with the parole board later adding a condition that prevented her from speaking to the media about her alleged innocence or claimed wrongful conviction.
asserted
that → release → conviction
In the Supreme Court in Hobart on Tuesday, Justice Stephen Escourt ruled the condition was invalid because it denied Neill-Fraser procedural fairness, was legally unreasonable, and created uncertainty.
asserted
it → rule → uncertainty
Justice Escourt also found that when the parole board made the decision to impose this condition, it had relied on a document that cited case law that was "fictitious" and likely "AI hallucinations".
asserted
that → find → law
The court heard that the document "argued forcefully" in favour of keeping the parole condition.
It took Neill-Fraser's legal team to bring it to the court's attention that the case law referred to didn't exist.
asserted
law → hear → attention
Speaking outside the court, legal director at the Human Rights Law Centre Sarah Schwartz said the case had revealed "serious deficiencies" within the state's parole system.
"It's really concerning that the Parole Board of Tasmania, a public authority, used AI in generating this document that so severely has restricted our client's fundamental freedoms, her freedom to speak in regard to her matter," Ms Schwartz said.
asserted
Schwartz → speak → matter
In his response to the findings, Tasmanian Attorney-General Guy Barnett noted the parole board was independent and the government had "no role in its decision-making".
"However, I will be writing to the chair of the Parole Board seeking an explanation about its professional standards after inaccurate information was produced in this case, which is not acceptable," Mr Barnett said.
asserted
Barnett → note → case
"I will be seeking assurances around how the Board will ensure this doesn't happen again."
asserted
this → seek → assurances
Mr Barnett also asked the head of the justice department to remind employees that they "must comply with the AI use policy".
asserted
they → ask → policy
Calls for parole board resignations
Speaking to 936 ABC Hobart, barrister and chair of Prisoners Legal Service, Greg Barns SC, questioned how widespread the parole board's use of AI was and called for an audit to be undertaken.
asserted
audit → speak → AI
"It's extraordinary,"Mr Barns said.
"
asserted
Barns → say → ?
"Our view is [the Parol Board] have no choice but to resign, but there should be an audit, and we're certainly going to be talking to our clients and checking whether there are written decisions in their cases.
asserted
we → have → cases
"If case law is used, we're going to check it."
Community Legal Centres Tasmania president Ryan Gilmour said he and other lawyers had seen an increasing number of cases of AI causing issues in the legal system.
"We've started to see probably over the last six months in particular … clients drafting their instructions to us in advance of an appointment with the assistance of AI," Mr Gilmour said.
asserted
Gilmour → use → AI
He said it was normally obvious when a client had used AI, because the instructions would be much longer than they needed to be and often drifted into unnecessary territory.
asserted
they → say → territory
"The challenge for us in that respect is that we then have to unpack some of what they've been told and so we can explain to them what their issue really is and give them proper advice.
asserted
issue → have → advice
"Clients then question the advice you're providing them because it may differ from what they've been told from AI."
uncertain
they → question → AI
Mr Gilmour said he had also encountered AI hallucinations or AI-made case law, something he said other members of Community Legal Centres around the state were seeing too.
asserted
members → say → state
AI usage creeps into legal field
Earlier this year, a self-represented litigant cited case law that had been entirely made up, with the presiding judge, Chief Justice Chris Shanahan, writing that it "proved to be an 'hallucination' generated by artificial intelligence".
asserted
it → creep → intelligence
In his judgement, Chief Justice Shanahan dedicated a section to the "hallucination", writing that the applicant's reliance on the AI citation was of "considerable concern" and some "considerable effort" was put into identifying whether it was real.
asserted
it → dedicate → concern
Acting president of the Law Society Luke Taylor said the use of AI by a statutory authority "serves as a timely and significant reminder about the dangers and pitfalls of using AI in court proceedings and legal processes".
asserted
use → act → proceedings
"It raises a critical access-to-justice issue in relation to the use of AI in legal and administrative decision-making," he said.
"
asserted
he → raise → making
This is fundamental to procedural fairness and maintaining public confidence in the administration of justice.
asserted
This → maintain → justice
Ultimately, the use of AI does not displace the responsibility of the human decision-maker and the circumstances of this case demonstrate the very real dangers where appropriate safeguards are absent or not followed."
asserted
safeguards → displace → dangers
Last year, the Tenants Union of Tasmania also put up social media post urging people to be cautious when using AI.
asserted
Union → put → AI
"We have seen an increase in people using AI for legal advice before contacting us," it said.
asserted
it → see → us
"While we think it's great that renters research information themselves before calling us, screenshots we have seen of AI advice most of the time did not hit the mark.
asserted
we → think → mark
"AI will get better over time, but at this stage we strongly recommend searching reputable and local sources directly."
asserted
we → get → sources
The Parole Board of Tasmania has been contacted for comment.
asserted
Board → contact → comment
The Aporia
