Mary McAleese faced heavy criticism yesterday after declaring that baptising infants soon after birth was a breach of their human rights because they can’t give their consent.
asserted
they → face → consent
The former president claimed Christenings are carried out without an infant’s permission, forcing them to join a faith before they understand the implications of doing so.
asserted
they → claim → implications
Her view was described as ‘nonsense’ last night by Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín.
asserted
view → describe → Tóibín
Ms McAleese challenges the Catholic Church’s viewpoint on infant Baptism in her upcoming book, claiming it deprives children of autonomy.
asserted
it → challenge → autonomy
She states: ‘No one is born a Catholic.
asserted
one → state → ?
One becomes a Catholic by Baptism.
asserted
One → become → Baptism
Most Catholics are baptised as babies.’
asserted
Catholics → baptise → babies
A brief of her book, The Baptism Bluff: Human Rights and the Canon Law of Baptism, outlines: ‘Man-made Church canon law deems them to have made baptismal promises which bind them to forever membership and which oblige them to be obedient to Church teaching in their public civic and private religious lives.’
asserted
which → outline → lives
The brief adds: ‘The sacrament of Confirmation, also usually undertaken as minors, requires them to “renew their baptismal promises,” a glaring and largely unchallenged part of the baptism bluff.’
asserted
sacrament → add → bluff
Ms McAleese, a former barrister with a doctorate in canon law from the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome, claims that the purpose of infant baptism is to reinforce the authority of the clergy.
uncertain
purpose → claim → clergy
The book’s synopsis, published on the website of Dubray Books, describes baptism as ‘foundational, existential building block of the magisterial control infrastructure’, which is caught in the middle of a historic crisis of trust.
asserted
which → publish → trust
Former president Mary McAleese has delivered strong views on Baptism in her new book
It states: ‘The Church is structured on the presumption that the Pope and bishops, collectively known as the authors of the teaching magisterium of the Church, have the right to regulate and control, including through penal sanctions, much of the life and especially the thinking of members of the Catholic Church.
asserted
Pope → deliver → Church
‘That presumption requires the magisterium to ignore contemporary understanding of the inalienable human rights of the individual to freedom of conscience, opinion, expression, religion and freedom to change religion.’
asserted
presumption → require → religion
While still a practising Catholic, Ms McAleese, 75, is an outspoken critic and reformer within the Church and frequently challenges the hierarchy on issues.
asserted
McAleese → practise → issues
The new book argues that Church teaching has promoted baptism as part of a ‘lazy’ doctrine of obligation rather than a ‘dynamic’ approach that recognises the importance of invitation and free participation.
asserted
that → argue → invitation
The brief continues: ‘It requires all Catholics to overlook the fact that babies cannot give informed consent to promises at baptism and no one can consent on their behalf thus robbing them forever of such a vital realm of choice.’
asserted
one → continue → choice
Ms McAleese said in a statement that the book’s message did not oppose ‘the divine sacramental’ elements of infant baptism.
asserted
message → say → baptism
She stated: ‘It challenges man-made imposition of canon law rules which assert serious limits on human rights and fundamental freedoms of Church members for all of their lifetime.’
asserted
which → state → lifetime
The subject was also tackled in her 2019 book, Children’s Rights and Obligations in Canon Law: The Christening Contract.
asserted
subject → tackle → Law
Ms McAleese has also clashed with the Church over its exclusion of women from the priesthood.
asserted
McAleese → clash → priesthood
In 2018, the Vatican prevented her from speaking at a panel organised by Voices of Faith, a Catholic women’s advocacy group, in Rome to discuss Church governance.
asserted
Vatican → prevent → governance
The group responded by moving the event off Vatican grounds to the headquarters of the Jesuit Refugee Services, where Ms McAleese, who has written several other books in the past, claimed the Church was an ‘empire of misogyny’.
asserted
Church → respond → misogyny
The Catholic Communications Office has been contacted for comment.
asserted
Office → contact → comment
Independent senator Rónán Mullen, former head of communications with the Catholic Church office in Maynooth, said Ms McAleese appears to have made a wrong call.
asserted
McAleese → say → call
He said: ‘I think Christian baptism is about something more important than Mary McAleese’s concepts of “human rights”, “autonomy“ and “choice“.
asserted
baptism → say → rights
These are important ideas for politics but pretty meaningless when it comes to sharing the gift of faith with an infant.
asserted
it → come → infant
‘Baptism is about starting a child’s life well, bringing them into God’s family, bringing them up in the love of God and opening up the hope and possibility of eternal life.
asserted
Baptism → start → life
‘If God exists, that would seem like the best start a child can get from their parents.
asserted
child → exist → parents
‘As each person matures into adulthood they grow in the ability to exercise freedom and it will be important for them to make a personal decision as they go through life about their relationship with God.’
asserted
they → mature → God
He continued: ‘I am assuming that Mary doesn’t think teaching children the difference between right and wrong at a young age, or discouraging them from exercising their freedom to put their hand in a fire, is a breach of their human rights.
asserted
teaching → continue → rights
You don’t need a baby’s consent to change their nappy either.’
asserted
You → need → nappy
Pope Leo at recent event during which infants are Baptised the Sistine Chapel in the Vatican
Mr Tóibín described her remarks as ‘nonsense’.
asserted
Tóibín → baptise → nonsense
He said: ‘I think Mary is wrong on this.
asserted
Mary → say → this
I think there should be freedom of religion.
asserted
I → think → religion
‘She is entitled to her view, but equally, parents should be able to raise their children as they see fit.
asserted
they → raise → children
‘They should have a right to impart their values to their children.
asserted
They → have → children
It’s nonsense to think they can’t pass it on to their children.
asserted
they → ’ → children
Families have enough to be concerned with, what with cost of living pressures and rising bills.’
asserted
Families → have → pressures
He added: ‘Most people are doing their best and should be let to make such families decisions as they choose.’
asserted
they → add → decisions
He said: ‘I wouldn’t go as far as Mary McAleese on ending baptism.
asserted
I → say → baptism
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
