On Wednesday this week, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Guerrero, Director of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice v. Dexter Johnson.
asserted
Court → hear → Johnson
It is a capital case involving the kidnapping, rape, and murder of Maria Aparece that Johnson committed in 2006.
asserted
Johnson → involve → 2006
The case does not involve any claim Johnson is innocent of these heinous crimes, but rather how to interpret provisions in the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996 (AEDPA).
uncertain
Johnson → involve → 1996
AEDPA prohibits successive habeas applications by state prisoners with only two narrow exceptions, including for claims that "rel[y] on a new rule of constitutional law, made retroactive to cases on collateral review by the Supreme Court, that was previously unavailable."
uncertain
that → prohibit → Court
The question presented seems to answer itself.
asserted
question → present → itself
The Supreme Court has granted cert to decide whether a claim relies on a "new rule of constitutional law, made retroactive to cases on collateral review by the Supreme Court, that was previously unavailable" when the Court announced the rule before the filing of the prisoner's prior federal habeas petition.
uncertain
Court → grant → petition
As Texas persuasively argues in its merits brief, Johnson's Atkins claim (that he should not be executed because, he claims, he is borderline intellectually disabled) does not rely on any new rule of constitutional law.
uncertain
he → argue → law
The Court decided Atkins v. Virginia in 2002—long before Johnson filed his initial federal habeas application, before his conviction became final on direct review—and even before he committed the capital murder for which he was sentenced to death.
asserted
he → decide → death
Instead of a change in law, Johnson's claim relies on a new factual predicate: the publication of a new diagnostic manual by the American Psychiatric Association (the DSM-5), under which he was diagnosed with an intellectual disability.
uncertain
he → rely → disability
But a claim in a successive application based on a new factual predicate must satisfy § 2244(b)(2)(B), which Johnson's Atkins claim does not, because his new evidence has no bearing on whether the jury would have found him "guilty of the underlying offense."
uncertain
him → base → offense
Surprisingly, a Fifth Circuit panel accepted Johnson's argument that he could pursue relief on this "new" claim.
uncertain
he → accept → claim
And the Fifth Circuit en banc denied further review by a vote of 9-7.
asserted
Circuit → deny → 9
Judge Ho (joined by Judges Jones, Smith, and Engelhardt) wrote a dissent from this denial, pointing out that "[e]xtraordinary delays like this are, alas, extraordinarily commonplace in our criminal justice system.
asserted
delays → join → system
Such delays also force the family and friends of victims like Maria Aparece to wait for justice—for over two decades, in this case."
asserted
delays → force → case
I have filed an amicus brief in the case, along with counsel of record Allyson Ho and her colleagues at Gibson Dunn, Brad Hubbard, Matt Scorcio, Brandon Wolf, and Marquan Robertson.
asserted
I → file → Dunn
Our brief provides a fuller account of the cost to victims' families—such as the Aparece family—who must wait for justice in capital cases like this one.
asserted
who → provide → one
Here's the introduction to our brief:
Twenty years ago, in the early-morning hours of Father's Day 2006, Dexter Johnson abducted 23-year-old Maria Chrisalee Lopez Aparece—"Sally" to her family and friends—and her boyfriend, Huy Ngo, at gunpoint.
asserted
Johnson → abduct → gunpoint
After terrorizing them, Johnson raped Sally in the back seat of her car while his accomplice taunted Ngo.
asserted
accomplice → terrorize → Ngo
Johnson then marched Sally and Ngo into the woods, shot each of them in the head, and left them for dead.
asserted
Johnson → march → them
Johnson and his accomplices then took Sally's car joyriding and used her credit cards to fund a shopping spree.
asserted
Johnson → take → spree
Earlier that evening, Sally had been at home making a card for her father, Protasio Aparece, while he worked a sixteen-hour shift as a registered nurse.
asserted
he → make → nurse
After her murder, Sally's family found the unfinished card.
asserted
family → find → card
They placed it in their living room, in front of the fireplace, alongside Sally's ashes—where it remains today.
asserted
it → place → ashes
Johnson's vicious crimes inflicted unbearable pain on his victims and their families.
asserted
crimes → inflict → victims
Johnson's serial litigation has robbed the families of even a modicum of peace or closure.
asserted
litigation → rob → peace
It has been two decades since Johnson brutally murdered Sally, and nineteen years since a Harris County jury sentenced him to death—but justice still has not been served.
asserted
justice → murder → death
This Court should vindicate crime victims' "important interest in the timely enforcement of a sentence," Bucklew v. Precythe, 587 U.S. 119, 149 (2019), and "powerful and legitimate interest" in "real finality," Calderon v. Thompson, 523 U.S. 538, 556 (1998),
asserted
Court → vindicate → Thompson
by reversing the judgment below and ending an ordeal that has compounded the suffering of Sally's family for over two decades
asserted
that → reverse → decades
You can read the full brief for the Aparece family here, which discusses how excessive delays (like the one in this case) break AEDPA's promise of finality in capital cases and how research confirms that excessive delays in criminal cases harm victims' families.
asserted
delays → read → families
I hope the Court reverses the Fifth Circuit's decision and brings the Aparece family one step closer to justice.
asserted
Court → hope → justice
The Aporia