The teen social media ban has robbed Australia’s youth of a key form of political communication, leaving them to “shout their views on a street corner”, US-based platform Reddit has argued in the nation’s highest court.
asserted
Reddit → rob → court
In the first major test of Labor’s signature social media age restrictions, Reddit and advocacy group Digital Freedom Project are seeking to overturn the ban in the High Court in a case heard on Tuesday and Wednesday in Canberra.
asserted
Reddit → seek → Canberra
Reddit’s counsel, Perry Herzfeld, SC, argued the legislation was “ill thought-out” and did not clearly target the harms the government said it was trying to mitigate.
asserted
it → argue → harms
Herzfeld argued the government’s own eSafety commissioner had not advocated for the teen social media ban, two parliamentary inquiries had not recommended it and the legislation was flawed after it was rushed through parliament.
asserted
it → argue → parliament
He said Reddit was one of the most visited sites in the world, and the social media ban infringed young Australians’ implied freedom of political communication by preventing them from posting, commenting or participating in forums where political figures or institutions directly engaged with users.
asserted
figures → say → users
Communications Minister Anika Wells said outside court that the government was seeking to protect Australians from harm and would defend that goal from “sustained ideological attacks”.
“The question of what we accept from tech platforms who offer us an online world is the most compelling policy question of our time,” she said.
asserted
she → say → time
The full court bench interrogated Reddit’s case, suggesting that children were not sufficiently politically engaged for the ban to have a significant effect, and that teens could use other methods such as WhatsApp or email to communicate.
uncertain
teens → interrogate → WhatsApp
Justice James Edelman, AC, also challenged the assertion that without social media, teens could not engage in political debate.
uncertain
teens → challenge → debate
He said young people had influenced political debate for centuries before social media.
asserted
people → say → media
Herzfeld argued the ban robbed teens of a much wider audience online.
asserted
ban → argue → audience
They could not “shout their views on a street corner” or be interviewed by mainstream media and hope to get the same engagement as they had on social media, he said.
uncertain
he → shout → media
He pointed to the School Strike for Climate movement and the 12-year-old founder of 6 News as examples of underage political engagement, and said it was unrealistic to think a person’s political life began only when they turned 16.
asserted
they → point → engagement
A teen representative for the Digital Freedom Project said outside court that under-16s should have their voices heard.
“If the children aren’t collaborating and sharing their own views, then they’re just spectators in their own world,” Noah Jones said.
asserted
Jones → say → world
The group’s president, NSW Libertarian MP John Ruddick, said the prime minister had established a pattern of censorship with the teen social media ban, the proposed digital duty of care and hate speech reforms.
asserted
minister → say → care
“We’re hoping today that the High Court… begin to reverse this censorship crusade, which has been waged against the Australian people by Mr Albanese,” he said outside court.
asserted
he → hop → court
The High Court is hearing the group’s case at the same time as Reddit because they are making similar arguments about freedom of political communication.
asserted
they → hear → communication
In March, new rules were introduced targeting the features of social media the government deemed addictive or harmful, such as infinite scroll.
asserted
government → introduce → scroll
Herzfeld said Reddit accepted it had some of the targeted features – introduced after the platforms launched its High Court bid – but that the platform differed from others in four key ways: the common use of pseudonyms meant it was not aimed at fostering connection between friends, it was mostly text-based instead of images, it did not have an endless feed, and there was no time-limited automatic deletion feature.
asserted
it → say → feed
Herzfeld said of the 4.7 million accounts the government says have been deactivated since the ban was introduced in December last year, almost 44,000 were on Reddit.
asserted
44,000 → say → Reddit
He said Reddit would argue against the Commonwealth’s defence that the laws aimed to penalise platforms, not teens, and that the ban was justified to protect against online harms.
asserted
ban → say → harms
The case continues.
asserted
case → continue → ?
Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletter.
asserted
Subscribers → sign → newsletter
The Aporia
