Labour risks giving mixed signals on reparations today after Andy Burnham opened the door to a formal apology.
asserted
Burnham → risk → apology
Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has pledged that Britons will not pay a 'penny more' due to the Government's shift in approach.
But the comments, in an interview at the Commonwealth summit in Antigua, contrasted with the PM repeatedly refusing to give the same guarantee.
asserted
PM → pledge → guarantee
Mr Burnham's offer to say sorry as part of a 'structured dialogue' with other nations has caused a storm, with critics pointing out the UK also led the way in smashing the global slave trade.
asserted
UK → say → trade
The King pointedly avoided any suggestion of an apology in his keynote speech at the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (Chogm) yesterday, insisting 'we cannot change the past'.
asserted
we → avoid → past
Charles did however acknowledge that the transatlantic slave trade 'still casts a shadow' and that 'shameful chapter of history is one that fills my heart with horror and my soul with the most profound personal sorrow'.
asserted
that → acknowledge → sorrow
Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has pledged that that Britons will not pay a 'penny more' due to the Government's shift in approach
The offer from Andy Burnham (pictured with Barbados counterpart Gaston Browne) to say sorry as part of a 'structured dialogue' with other nations has caused a storm
asserted
offer → pledge → storm
Asked by the BBC whether the formal apology could be ready by the time of the G20 leaders' summit in Manchester next November, Mr Miliband said: 'Broadly speaking, yes.'
uncertain
Miliband → ask → Manchester
But asked whether the new approach could end up costing UK taxpayers a penny more, Mr Miliband said: 'No.
'
uncertain
Miliband → ask → ?
I mean, not… no.
asserted
I → mean → ?
And that's why it's been important that you know, and I did have this conversation with our partners in advance.
asserted
I → know → advance
I said, 'look, we are going to say we are willing to say that we're open to an apology, but we're not going to shift our position on reparations.'
asserted
we → say → reparations
It's not feasible for us, but there are things we can work on co-operatively.'
asserted
we → be → us
He added: 'And you know there's been a lot of acceptance of that, and I mean people have been honestly a bit bruised by the past, what happened in the past, the sense that we just really just wanted to sweep this issue under the carpet and not confront it.
asserted
we → add → it
My sense is there's a bit of a sigh of relief that OK well at least you know at least there's a sense of we've got a shared interest now in moving the Commonwealth on.'
asserted
we → be → Commonwealth
Mr Miliband said Tony Blair 'did sort of do a kind of sorry not sorry situation', adding: 'He sort of, yeah, he kind of expressed sorrow, but and then said sorry, and then it was walked back by No 10.'
asserted
it → say → No
Pressed in a separate interview whether the slavery dialogue could involve any additional contributions from UK taxpayers, Mr Burnham said merely that was 'getting ahead' of the process.
uncertain
that → press → process
'What we need to have is that meaningful dialogue where we take time to listen,' he said.
asserted
he → need → time
Mr Burnham has been floating debt write-offs and downgrades instead of cash payments to countries affected by the slave trade.
asserted
Burnham → float → trade
The Government is also prepared to fund health, education and Net Zero projects in Commonwealth states, but so far that is from existing aid budgets.
asserted
that → fund → budgets
The UK is allocating £40million over three years to speed up critical infrastructure investment including green energy in the Caribbean.
asserted
UK → allocate → Caribbean
Calls for an apology and reparations have grown in recent years, with St Lucia's Prime Minister Philip J Pierre, chairman of the 15-member Caribbean Community (Caricom) reportedly saying the economic and political bloc was 'ready to engage'.
uncertain
bloc → grow → Community
The King pointedly avoided any suggestion of an apology in his keynote speech at the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (Chogm) yesterday
The PM said the UK wanted to 'work closely with you to make sure we get that right' as he met the president of Ghana for one-to-one talks on the sidelines of the summit yesterday.
asserted
he → avoid → summit
Exchanging warm words at the top of the meeting, John Dramani Mahama in turn said Britain had shown a 'shift in some very strong positions' and is now 'more open to interacting with the rest of the world' and the Commonwealth.
asserted
Britain → exchange → world
After the last Chogm in 2024, when Downing Street was resistant to any discussions about reparations, the Ghanaian leader said the new PM's approach 'creates a first step for us to continue to work to see how we can put this whole issue of transatlantic slave trade and colonialism behind us'.
asserted
we → say → us
The Aporia
