New boundary panel tweaked Lethbridge, Calgary seats after past chair urged them not to
When the judge who led Alberta’s boundaries commission gave politicians a narrow path to revise his panel’s work and rescue two rural ridings from the chopping block, Justice Dallas Miller added a few provisos to protect his electoral map work.
asserted
Miller → tweak → work
The first condition, which the Smith government adopted, stated that “restoration of the two electoral divisions should: have no impact on any electoral division in Airdrie or containing territory south of Airdrie’s southernmost border…”
And lo and behold, where has the new boundary panel done its most controversial redrawing?
asserted
panel → adopt → redrawing
NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi has called it a “Trump-style, MAGA gerrymandered map” that safeguards UCP-held territory in southern Alberta.
asserted
that → call → Alberta
Adopt it, Nenshi has warned, and “we’ll see them in court.”
asserted
we → adopt → court
Premier Danielle Smith has expressed early favour for the new plan, regardless of its apparent overstepping of the conditions her side set on her new boundary advisory group.
asserted
side → express → group
Back in April, when United Conservatives shelved the official commission’s work, she had insisted she was accepting that majority report, just with Justice Dallas Miller’s extra recommendations which proposed modest tweaks.
asserted
which → shelve → tweaks
"You'll see that in his Recommendation Five, he is quite prescriptive about the areas that he thinks are problematic," she told reporters.
asserted
she → see → reporters
The new panel chaired by retired judge Brian O’Ferrall, however, did not feel so fettered about sticking to the confines of what Miller and Alberta’s legislature had set out, stating in its “majority” report that the words in Miller’s fifth recommendation don’t warrant “deification.”
“It was not the ‘Fifth Commandment,’” the report states.
asserted
report → chair → deification
So what did O’Ferrall’s panel give and take?
asserted
panel → give → ?
It took Lethbridge’s two urban seats and split one of them across three rural ridings that variously stretch up to 150 kilometres in each direction to the U.S. border, the TransCanada Highway, Waterton Lakes National Park and the hamlet of Manyberries, due south of Medicine Hat.
asserted
that → take → Hat
It took rural acreage communities from the formerly proposed Cochrane-Springbank riding and dispersed them among three west Calgary districts — which, Nenshi argued, gives thousands of Conservative voters to seats currently held by a trio of UCP cabinet ministers.
asserted
Nenshi → take → ministers
It took the Diamond Valley and Longview areas away from adjoining rural ridings south of Calgary and gave them to the Canmore-Banff riding on the other side of Kananaskis Country and a highway partially closed for six months every year.
asserted
It → take → months
Not only had Miller, the original commission’s chair, recommended against such tinkering in service of restoring a pair of rural ridings in northern and central Alberta; it’s also not clear that these southern Alberta modifications were even necessary to accommodate the un-eliminating of those two districts.
asserted
modifications → recommend → districts
They weren’t knock-on effects caused by bringing back the riding in Rocky Mountain House and Sundre.
asserted
They → knock → House
According to population figures in the new report, Cochrane’s riding shed 9,703 people, and that same amount was split among the three Calgary ridings, without any corresponding adjustments to any other Calgary constituencies.
uncertain
amount → accord → constituencies
It leaves the redesigned Cochrane with 46,785 residents, and 13 per cent below the provincial average riding population.
asserted
It → leave → population
The redrawn Calgary-West-Springbank and Calgary-Bow-Springbank each have more than 58,000 people, nine per cent higher than average.
asserted
Springbank → have → people
“Adding Springbank to Calgary Bow is said to potentially favour the party in power,” O’Ferrall’s report acknowledged.
asserted
report → add → power
“But whether that potential will manifest itself in the next election, not even the pollsters with their voter transpositioning software know for sure.”
asserted
pollsters → manifest → software
Springbank was moved because O’Ferrall and the panel’s UCP appointees felt that rural area had more connection to Calgary than to the small town of Cochrane to its north.
asserted
area → move → north
Similarly, it felt that “Lethbridge is not an isolated urban municipality,” but is the hub of southern Alberta’s agri-business, health and service district.
asserted
Lethbridge → feel → district
Therefore, it partially becomes three hub-and-spoke ridings that nearly stretch from Saskatchewan to British Columbia — and, the NDP argues, erases one of Lethbridge’s politically competitive ridings and dilutes those votes in UCP-friendly zones.
asserted
NDP → become → zones
O’Farrell and his UCP-appointed majority dismiss complaints their work is unconstitutional as “polarizing nonsense.”
asserted
work → appoint → nonsense
They take similar umbrage in their report with the NDP-appointed minority’s protests about the new map work in southern Alberta, saying “it can be summarized quite simply.
asserted
it → take → Alberta
For the record, Smith’s cabinet chose O’Ferrall, a former Court of Appeal judge who has donated thousands of dollars to the UCP and federal conservatives since he retired in 2022, and served in court as lawyer for an Alberta Progressive Conservative riding association two decades ago before he was a judge.
asserted
he → choose → association
The United Conservatives’ two appointees to the panel are Monte Solberg, a former Conservative MP and head of a Calgary-based lobby firm who has donated $2,883 to Smith’s party this year, including some while serving on the panel; and Darwin Durnie, a longtime conservative political donor and municipal public works official who has a lengthy history as a boundary-making hobbyist of sorts, having submitted maps to Alberta’s boundary commissions that propose several rural-urban hybrid ridings.
asserted
that → base → ridings
The NDP’s appointees, constitutional law professor Gerard Kennedy and former Okotoks councillor Brent Robinson, have no record of provincial donations in Elections Alberta’s database.
asserted
appointees → have → database
Kennedy has donated federally, predominantly to Conservatives and some to Liberals.
asserted
Kennedy → donate → Liberals
Regardless of how partisan the boundary panelists are or aren’t, the partisan MLAs are set to debate the contentious report in coming days.
asserted
MLAs → set → days
Smith likes the idea of Lethbridge’s hybrid ridings, similar to how Medicine Hat is divided between her Brooks-Medicine Hat seat and a UCP colleague’s Cypress-Medicine Hat.
asserted
Hat → like → seat
“I represent a hybrid riding, and I think Medicine Hat is well-served by having two representatives.
asserted
Hat → represent → representatives
I think Lethbridge will be very well-served by having four representatives,” she told reporters Tuesday.
asserted
she → think → reporters
Premier Danielle Smith, who represents a rural-urban hybrid riding in Medicine Hat, said Lethbridge would be well-served by having several rural-urban hybrid MLAs instead of two city-only MLAs.
asserted
Lethbridge → represent → MLAs
The NDP cannot launch a lawsuit against this new riding map until the legislature approves it and puts it into effect.
asserted
legislature → launch → effect
A successful challenge would have to argue that the ridings violate the “effective representation” guarantees in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms — such a claim could theoretically come from a political party, or the affected residents in Lethbridge or elsewhere, including the few thousand people in Springbank and Bearspaw who find themselves mixed into 50,000-person-plus seats in Alberta’s biggest city.
uncertain
themselves → have → city
Original commission chair Miller, for his part, wrote in his report that he didn’t find Lethbridge or Springbank hybrids “necessarily unreasonable or procedurally unfair,” noting that some public members proposed them to the commission.
asserted
members → write → commission
But that report blurb wasn’t part of the government motion that created the do-over boundary review, unlike the one urging against any redrawing work south of Airdrie.
asserted
that → create → Airdrie
Smith discussed on Tuesday being ready to “assemble a legal team” ahead of a potential court challenge.
asserted
Smith → discuss → challenge
When asked about Miller’s warning on southern ridings she said: “I'll take a closer look at it and talk to the lawyers about that.”
asserted
I → ask → that
The Aporia
