After his party's resounding defeat in the US midterm elections this week, President Donald Trump conceded that the war with Iran had likely played a part.
asserted
war → concede → part
"I think a part of it was Iran, but, at the same time, people understood the importance of what I've done with Iran," Trump told Fox News, conceding that US voters were unwilling to accept the impact of the war on gas prices.
asserted
voters → think → prices
Observers say the United States and Israel had been holding off on major attacks on Iran until after both had held elections.
asserted
both → say → elections
At the end of October, the Wall Street Journal reported that the Trump administration was already warning Gulf state governments to brace for a short, intense military campaign after the midterms.
asserted
administration → report → midterms
Could conflict escalate again?
uncertain
conflict → escalate → ?
While foreign policy is a US president's purview, analysts have pointed out that a Congress controlled by the Democratic party could ostensibly withhold funding for Trump's military expeditions.
uncertain
Congress → point → expeditions
However newly-elected Democratic politicians won't take their seats until early next year.
asserted
politicians → elect → year
As two US professors of political science wrote for Foreign Affairs magazine this week, past American presidents, like Trump, who become "lame ducks" — that is, a president who loses control of Congress and can't run for another term — have often ramped up international interventions.
asserted
who → write → interventions
"As they think about their legacy, lame ducks often turn to foreign policy, where the power of the presidency allows them to act unfettered by pesky domestic politics," they explained.
asserted
they → think → politics
And one of the places where Trump is most likely to act is Iran, the professors argued.
asserted
professors → act → places
On the other hand, Trump also told several media outlets that he was in "no rush" to start bombing Iran again.
asserted
he → tell → Iran
Opinions on Iran's next moves are also divided.
asserted
Opinions → divide → moves
The Iranians have said they're ready for any attack and rhetoric from senior leaders indicates they may be willing to strike a wider range of targets than previously.
uncertain
they → say → targets
That could include regional energy and economic infrastructure and even undersea telecommunications cabling or data centers.
uncertain
That → include → infrastructure
If Iran thinks there is an existential threat to its leadership, then "all bets are off," Ross Harrison, a senior fellow at the Washington-based Middle East Institute, or MEI, and an expert on Iran, said during a virtual briefing hosted by MEI this week.
asserted
Harrison → think → MEI
"I think they will target differently in the Gulf states [this time] … so it really depends on how all this unfolds.
asserted
this → think → states
But other experts believe Iran was deliberately holding out to pressure Trump before the midterms.
asserted
Iran → believe → midterms
Now the election is over, the Iranians may be more willing to negotiate a peace deal.
uncertain
Iranians → negotiate → deal
All this leaves the Gulf states, who have been the main targets of Iranian attacks since the conflict began, in a difficult position.
asserted
conflict → leave → position
"We find ourselves drawn within a crisis that we worked diplomatically very hard to try to avert," Anwar Gargash, a foreign policy adviser to United Arab Emirates leadership, said at a security conference in Bahrain last weekend, the Manama Dialogue hosted by the International Institute for Strategic Studies, or IISS.
asserted
Gargash → find → Studies
"We are clearly seeking a political off-ramp."
asserted
We → seek → ramp
Qatar has been trying to negotiate between the US and Iran but has also been conducting emergency drills at its airport.
asserted
Qatar → try → airport
The Emiratis have been doing similar drills.
asserted
Emiratis → do → drills
And Saudi Arabia is looking at a war on two fronts: The oil-rich state is already under attack from the Houthi militia in neighboring Yemen.
asserted
state → look → Yemen
Even Egypt has reacted, reportedly strengthening air defenses around the Suez Canal.
uncertain
Egypt → react → Canal
Still, no matter what happens next, the US-Israel-Iran war has already made Gulf states evaluate defense partnerships with the US.
asserted
states → happen → US
Rather than making them safe, US bases have made them a target.
asserted
them → make → ?
"There is widespread disappointment across the region with the US over the folly of the war, the erratic nature of Washington's military and diplomatic conduct, and its decision to prioritize Israel's defense over that of its Gulf partners," Hasan Alhasan, a senior fellow at the IISS, told news agency Bloomberg this week.
asserted
Alhasan → be → Bloomberg
"If the US liberation of Kuwait in 1991 was the moment that established America's role in the region, the 2026 war may be remembered as the moment that undid it.
uncertain
that → establish → it
Gulf states are widening their outreach with, for example, the UAE getting closer to Israel and the Saudis entering the Mecca defense pact with Pakistan and Turkey.
asserted
Saudis → widen → Pakistan
"The Gulf states have already moved toward strategic autonomy and self-reliance," Andreas Krieg, a senior lecturer at the School of Security Studies at King's College London, wrote for online outlet Middle East Eye this week.
asserted
Krieg → move → Eye
"A lame-duck Trump will speed that process.
asserted
Trump → speed → process
"
That's even though a Democrat-led Congress might make the US a slightly more reliable partner again.
uncertain
US → lead → ?
Krieg argues that Gulf states should come together to pressure the US not to attack Iran and then negotiate a non-aggression pact with Iran — without US involvement.
asserted
states → argue → involvement
Whether that kind of unity is possible in the Gulf is dubious, Ryan Crocker, a former US ambassador to the region and distinguished fellow with MEI, replied to a question from DW during the MEI's online briefing.
"I'm afraid that meaningful Gulf unity is not coming to a theater near us anytime soon," Crocker said.
asserted
Crocker → reply → us
The Qataris remain untrusting because of how other Gulf states acted against them in 2017.
asserted
states → remain → 2017
And, he added, "there are well known differences between Saudi Arabia and the UAE we see in Sudan [and] in Yemen, and, of course, the profound differences … on relations with Israel.
asserted
we → add → Israel
So I would not expect any meaningful moves toward [Gulf] security cooperation.
asserted
I → expect → cooperation
"
What's more likely in the long term is Gulf states eventually coming to some kind of understanding with Iran.
asserted
states → come → Iran
"The Gulf states understand that they probably can't buy their security only from Washington, and that they're going to have to buy it, to some degree, by some kind of a relationship with Tehran," the MEI's Harrison added.
asserted
Harrison → understand → Tehran
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
