Former Israeli military chief Gadi Eisenkot has now been asked to try to form a new coalition government, meeting Israel's President Isaac Herzog in Jerusalem on Sunday to receive his invite to start negotiations.
asserted
Eisenkot → ask → negotiations
But his pathway to power is not entirely easy, and the next few weeks could involve some creative political arithmetic and manoeuvring to get over the line.
uncertain
weeks → involve → line
The starting point
The reason Gadi Eisenkot has been tapped for the first shot at forming a coalition is because of what happened late last week.
asserted
what → tap → coalition
The president sat down with representatives of each of the political parties that won seats at the election, and asked them to endorse either Mr Eisenkot or the incumbent Benjamin Netanyahu — given the two men are the leaders of the two largest parties in the next Knesset.
asserted
men → sit → Knesset
All of the anti-Netanyahu parties from across the political spectrum, including the two Arab-Israeli or Palestinian-Israeli parties, backed Mr Eisenkot:
- Yashar (Eisenkot's own party) — 21 seats
- Together — 12 seats
- The Democrats — 8 seats
- Yisrael Beiteinu — 7 seats
- The United Arab List — 8 seats
- The Joint List — 11 seats
That's a total of 67 seats in the 120-seat Knesset backing the main rival to Benjamin Netanyahu.
asserted
That → include → Netanyahu
The prime minister only secured votes from most of his current coalition:
- Likud (Netanyahu's own party) — 27 seats
- Otzma Yehudit — 7 seats
- Religious Zionism — 6 seats
- Shas — 6 seats
That's a total of 46 seats in the Knesset.
The other ultra-Orthodox Jewish party, United Torah Judaism (UTJ), did not back either candidate with their seven seats — despite spending most of the last four years backing in Mr Netanyahu.
asserted
party → secure → Netanyahu
Here's why that doesn't mean Eisenkot will be the next PM
Getting the endorsements to start negotiations is important, as it puts Mr Eisenkot in the box seat to form a new government and end Mr Netanyahu's time at the top.
asserted
it → mean → top
At the moment, they are united by a common goal of giving the current prime minister the boot.
asserted
they → unite → boot
But convincing them to put aside longstanding grievances and policy differences could be difficult, and loyalty to principle also isn't guaranteed.
uncertain
loyalty → convince → principle
Scenario one: Minority government
Israeli media is speculating Gadi Eisenkot could try to press ahead with forming a minority government, which would include all of the Jewish anti-Netanyahu parties:
- Yashar
- Together
- The Democrats
- Yisrael Beiteinu
That's a total of 48 seats out of the 120 on offer in the Knesset.
uncertain
That → speculate → Knesset
The only way that could work is if the two Arab-Israeli parties, the United Arab List and the Joint List, agreed to effectively green-light the government's agenda on the floor of the Knesset — promising not to block things like budget legislation.
uncertain
parties → work → legislation
There's an immediate problem with this approach — the leader of Yisrael Beiteinu, Avigdor Liberman wants a majority government.
asserted
leader → be → government
His opposition to working with the Arab-Israeli parties goes as far as relying on them working outside of a formal coalition.
asserted
them → work → coalition
As a result, he is reportedly looking at trying to entice the ultra-orthodox parties of UTJ and Shas to join forces with the rest of the "change" camp.
uncertain
he → look → camp
Mr Liberman could change his tune.
uncertain
Liberman → change → tune
But at this point, he seems to be digging his heels in.
asserted
he → seem → heels
Scenario two: Majority Jewish government
This would be a coalition of all of the Jewish parties that are critics of Benjamin Netanyahu, and the two ultra-Orthodox parties who've helped to prop up his right-wing government over the past four years:
- Yashar
- Together
- The Democrats
- Yisrael Beiteinu
- United Torah Judaism
- Shas
That's a total of 61 seats — the barest of majorities.
asserted
That → help → majorities
While this would effectively kill off the fierce and at times racist arguments being put forward about the Arab-Israeli vote, it brings its own problems.
asserted
it → kill → problems
Mr Eisenkot and other members of the so-called "change" camp have all campaigned on wanting to force men from the growing ultra-orthodox community, known as the Haredi, to complete compulsory military service.
asserted
Eisenkot → call → service
This has been one of the most controversial issues of the past three years, since Hamas's deadly attacks against Israel on October 7, 2023 — the pressure on the Israel Defense Forces as it fights on multiple fronts.
asserted
it → fight → fronts
In 2024, the Israeli Supreme Court tore up the sweeping exemptions from service afforded to Haredi men — effectively ending the principle that they should be given permission to avoid being drafted because they are students of the Jewish faith, and work to safeguard the future of the religion.
asserted
they → tear → religion
UTJ and Shas had been demanding the Netanyahu government reimpose the exemptions.
asserted
government → demand → exemptions
Even Avigdor Liberman, the man now reportedly talking to them, campaigned on ending "draft dodging".
uncertain
Liberman → talk → dodging
If this scenario were to become reality, it would demonstrate a commitment to the principle of ousting Mr Netanyahu over loyalty to pre-election policy platforms.
It could also be a calculation that anti-Arab sentiment in the Israeli community is more toxic than anti-Haredi views.
Scenario three:
uncertain
sentiment → become → Scenario
But the only way this would happen is if the strident opposition to the Arab-Israeli parties is parked in favour of toppling Mr Netanyahu.
asserted
opposition → happen → Netanyahu
It is also a government that would come under attack from the prime minister and right-wing forces in Israel given the ongoing allegations of foreign interference in the election prompting a surge in support for those parties.
asserted
that → come → parties
Scenario four: 'Unity' government
This is something Benjamin Netanyahu has started pushing more and more in the last week or so — encouraging Gadi Eisenkot to work across the aisle with him to form a broad, Jewish-Israeli coalition.
asserted
Netanyahu → start → coalition
It would look something like this:
- Likud
- Yashar
- Together
- The Democrats
- Yisrael Beiteinu
That gets total of 75 seats in the Knesset — a considerable majority.
asserted
That → look → Knesset
The problem here is that Mr Eisenkot and the other "change" camp parties have spent the past few years insisting Mr Netanyahu is the embodiment of everything wrong with the government and needs to go.
asserted
Netanyahu → spend → government
Mr Eisenkot has also ruled it out, even as Mr Netanyahu continues to insist it is the way forward.
This scenario also does not include the far-right Otzma Yehudit, led by national security minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, and Religious Zionism, led by finance minister Bezalel Smotrich.
asserted
scenario → rule → Smotrich
They are seen as even more problematic than Mr Netanyahu by members of the "change" camp.
asserted
They → see → camp
Scenario five: No deal and new elections
Gadi Eisenkot has at least 28 days to form a new coalition.
asserted
Eisenkot → form → coalition
President Isaac Herzog can extend that by another 14 days of he thinks there's a chance at a deal, and it just needs a bit more time.
asserted
it → extend → time
At the end of that process, he can ask another candidate to have a go.
But if that also fails, Israel would be on track for another election sometime early in the new year.
asserted
Israel → ask → year
Same too if one of the other scenarios play out, and the government collapses — a fresh vote could be ordered.
uncertain
vote → play → scenarios
The Aporia
