As Jim Chalmers, the treasurer, comes under increasing pressure to fight inflation by slashing spending in the mid-year budget update, the drumbeat is loudest for cuts in one specific area: green energy subsidies for households.
asserted
drumbeat → come → households
Receiving the most focus is the cheaper home batteries program, which from July last year has offered a taxpayer-backed 30% rebate to households and businesses.
asserted
which → receive → households
The scheme has become a victim of its own success.
asserted
scheme → become → success
Treasury officials originally estimated it would lead to a million new batteries by 2030 at a cost of $2.3bn.
asserted
it → estimate → 2.3bn
Also in the crosshairs is the 2022 electric vehicle subsidy, which exempts workers from fringe benefits tax when they lease an EV through their employer and has proved more popular – and expensive – than predicted.
asserted
they → exempt → employer
Despite reports that Treasury is pushing for cuts to the home battery scheme, the argument has hardly been made.
asserted
argument → push → scheme
When budget experts are asked broader questions about the big pressures on the federal government’s finances, rarely do they cite handouts for home batteries or tax breaks for electric vehicles.
asserted
they → ask → vehicles
In a speech on Monday, Angus Taylor, the opposition leader, again promised to “abolish Labor’s ideological climate bureaucracy” as part of his promised $31bn of budget savings over four years.
asserted
Taylor → promise → years
Meanwhile, the Albanese government’s recent efforts to apply an income test to private healthcare rebates for over-65s was met with howls of protest from the Coalition.
asserted
efforts → apply → Coalition
As Stephen Bartos, an economics professor at the University of Canberra, says, in all this talk about cutting spending, “nobody is mentioning nuclear-powered submarines”.
asserted
nobody → say → submarines
Bartos, a former deputy secretary at the Department of Finance and New South Wales parliamentary budget officer, says if the challenge is to close the budget deficit, then green subsidies “shouldn’t be their first port of call”.
asserted
subsidies → say → call
“Partly because it’s small beer compared to the big-ticket items like health, NDIS and defence. But also because there is a rationale for green subsidies, if a declining one.”
asserted
it → ’ → subsidies
The national disability insurance scheme, for example, was expected to cost nearly $54bn in 2025–26, which has made reining in the cost of the scheme an existential question for the government’s fiscal plans.
asserted
reining → expect → plans
In 2023, the Parliamentary Budget Office estimated the total cost of acquiring nuclear-powered submarines under the Aukus agreement to be as much $368bn over the life of the program.
asserted
cost → estimate → program
The federal fuel tax credit scheme, which mainly helps major global mining companies, costs about $11bn a year and is rising fast.
asserted
which → help → 11bn
Bartos is critical of government tax breaks for electric vehicles, but says the case for public support for batteries is stronger.
asserted
case → say → batteries
“I would probably be looking at where the price signals encouraging adoption [of clean energy] are weakest, and that’s probably batteries.
asserted
that → look → energy
For EVs, people are shifting no matter what.
asserted
people → shift → EVs
The case for the cheaper batteries scheme has also been undermined by Treasury officials’ abject failure to predict how popular it would be.
asserted
it → undermine → failure
A month into the program and it was already obvious they had got it wrong, as the expected cost blew out towards $14bn.
asserted
cost → get → 14bn
Not only was our appetite for subsidised batteries way higher than official forecasts, the original design of the scheme made it more desirable to buy bigger, more expensive batteries.
asserted
it → make → batteries
There has since been a tweak to the design to account for that second issue, which is how Treasury now predicts – for what it’s worth – that the program will cost $7.2bn.
asserted
program → account → 7.2bn
These cost blowouts have amplified derision of the home batteries as “middle-class welfare” of the worst sort.
asserted
blowouts → amplify → sort
Alison Reeve, the director of the energy and climate change program at the Grattan Institute, understands the concerns, but says the evidence to back that claim “is pretty thin when you look at where the batteries are being installed”.
uncertain
batteries → understand → claim
Then there is the bigger-picture issue: that we risk sacrificing long-term clean energy goals in the name of short-term fiscal objectives.
asserted
we → be → objectives
“Batteries are going to be a big part of our energy future,” Reeve says.
asserted
Reeve → go → future
“We do need to do some stimulating of that industry until it can stand on its own two feet.”
asserted
it → need → feet
Slashing support for batteries would damage the burgeoning web of small businesses, suppliers and tradies who have invested in servicing the infant batteries industry.
asserted
who → slash → industry
That’s not to say there are ways to improve the cost and benefits trade-off in the home batteries program.
asserted
That → ’ → program
This could be by ensuring subsidised batteries deliver a community benefit by contributing to the power grid in times of need.
uncertain
batteries → ensure → need
“We need to make sure we are maximising the public benefit, rather than just the private benefit,” Reeve says.
asserted
Reeve → need → benefit
There are lessons in how Western Australia has designed its home batteries support scheme.
asserted
Australia → be → scheme
“If you look at the west coast, you couldn’t get the state subsidy unless you linked yourself up to a virtual power plan run by the network operator.
asserted
you → look → operator
That was in order to benefit the whole network,” she says.
asserted
she → benefit → network
“We also need a clear path out of the subsidy so it doesn’t grow uncontrollably.”
asserted
it → need → subsidy
The Aporia
