If there is one thing everyone seems to agree about when it comes to the latest case of cancel culture run amuck in the arts world, it’s that singer Ed Sheeran is a good guy.
asserted
Sheeran → be → world
I’ve known him for 13 years …
asserted
I → know → years
I consider him a brother,” the rapper Macklemore wrote after he was booted from Sheeran’s ongoing stadium tour.
asserted
he → consider → tour
The Irish singer-songwriter Aaron Rowe, one of four artists that left the tour after Macklemore was dropped, said, “Ed has been a friend to me and has changed my life, I could never thank him enough.”
uncertain
I → leave → him
Danish duo Lukas Graham, another of bands that pulled out, wrote that they “love Ed” and are “grateful for everything we’ve shared.”
asserted
we → pull → everything
Macklemore was ousted from Sheeran’s tour after his performance on Sept. 4 at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey, where he wore a keffiyeh and went on a long rant full of “Free Palestine” highlights during his set.
asserted
he → oust → set
That prompted Robert Kraft, the Jewish owner of the NFL’s New England Patriots and Gillette Stadium southwest of Boston, to let Sheeran’s camp know that Macklemore — and by extension Sheeran, if he kept Macklemore on as his opening act — was barred from playing there.
asserted
he → prompt → act
Kraft then apparently took it a step further, marshalling support from other stadium owners to bar Macklemore, calling the tour’s continued viability into question.
asserted
Kraft → take → question
And then the other acts bowed out in support of Macklemore.
asserted
acts → bow → Macklemore
The ball is now in Sheeran’s court: which pressure — the pro-Palestine crowd or the pro-Israel one — will he succumb to?
asserted
he → succumb → pressure
It is tempting to separate Macklemore from the other, significantly lesser-known artists who came to his defence.
asserted
who → separate → defence
Macklemore appeared in May 2014 at a U.S. concert dressed in a black suit, dark wig, fake beard and large prosthetic nose.
uncertain
Macklemore → appear → suit
His latest tour has featured imagery that appears to conflate Israel with the Nazis.
asserted
that → feature → Nazis
He rails against Israel on stage all the time.
asserted
He → rail → stage
By contrast, Rowe and Lukas Graham’s greatest sins against Jews and their allies are tiny: a couple of posts by niche artists in favour of free speech with a “Free Palestine” here and there aren’t going to hurt anyone.
Would it be better if Macklemore wasn’t a thing?
asserted
Macklemore → go → anyone
I wouldn’t miss him.
asserted
I → miss → him
But in reality, he gets an estimated 34-million monthly listeners on Spotify.
asserted
he → get → Spotify
It’s nowhere near Sheeran, at 81-million monthly listens, but any artist would kill for that kind of attention.
asserted
artist → ’ → attention
And now he has been shut out of a major touring spectacle because of being very anti-Israel and sometimes obviously antisemitic.
asserted
he → shut → spectacle
I’m sure he’ll learn the right lessons from this experience.
asserted
he → ’m → experience
Yes, you can argue that there’s nothing to see here — that freedom of speech doesn’t mean freedom from the consequences of speech, that Robert Kraft and his friends are perfectly within their rights to decide who does and doesn’t perform at their stadiums.
asserted
who → argue → stadiums
These are perfectly reasonable, maybe even heroic, acts for societal good made by smart people willing to stand up for what they believe is right.
asserted
they → make → people
Besides, the other side gets our people cancelled every chance they get.
asserted
they → get → ?
But I’m not especially comfortable cheering for Kraft or celebrating victory with the Jewish social media army, which has been reeling from the attempted cancellation of Boy George for his pro-Israel song.
asserted
which → ’m → song
In the end, this is no win for Jews or people who just want a sensible moral compass for life.
asserted
who → want → life
Rather, it is a victory for cancel culture, and that is never good for our social — let alone cultural — health.
asserted
that → cancel → health
I fail to understand how people who complain whenever someone they agree with is cancelled can suddenly start cheering when the cancelling happens to someone they find objectionable.
asserted
they → fail → someone
How does this make any sense?
asserted
this → make → sense
If you don’t want to hear Macklemore, just show up late to the Ed Sheeran concert.
asserted
you → want → concert
Or don’t go at all, if you’re that invested in the matter.
asserted
you → go → matter
Either way, it’s best not to crow on about Macklemore’s cancellation as a “victory” or a “taste of their own medicine.”
asserted
it → ’ → medicine
Because then you look like a hypocrite, and then people start saying that the Jews with their money really do get to silence whomever they want.
asserted
they → look → whomever
As for Sheeran, he has remained rather circumspect about where he stands on whether geopolitics belongs on stage.
asserted
geopolitics → remain → stage
“I am not complicit,” he responded to the controversy.
asserted
he → respond → controversy
“I have my personal views on this devastating conflict.
asserted
I → have → conflict
Just because I choose not to speak publicly, it doesn’t mean I don’t have them.”
asserted
I → choose → them
That is positively refreshing coming from an artist of any sort, let alone one as popular as Sheeran.
asserted
That → come → Sheeran
That is the mature ideal, not celebrating each time the good guys turn the tables on the enemy in a ridiculous game of one-upmanship that will not end well for anyone.
asserted
that → celebrate → anyone
The Aporia
