Supreme Court OKs border wall construction in Big Bend area of Texas
asserted
Court → ok → Texas
-
- Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented alone and without an explanation.
asserted
Jackson → dissent → explanation
- U.S. Customs and Border Protection said it does not plan to build a border wall in Big Bend National Park, but would add new patrol roads and vehicle barriers.
asserted
it → say → roads
Congress said immigration officials may waive environmental laws to build a border wall.
uncertain
officials → say → wall
The Supreme Court has cleared the way for the Trump administration to build a border wall through the scenic and rugged Big Bend sector of west Texas.
asserted
administration → clear → Texas
The justices on Monday granted an emergency appeal from Trump’s lawyers and set aside a judge’s order that had paused further construction along a 517-mile section of the Rio Grande.
asserted
that → grant → Grande
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented alone and without an explanation.
asserted
Jackson → dissent → explanation
In an unsigned opinion, the court said federal courts did not have the authority to stand in the way and block efforts along the border.
asserted
courts → say → border
“The balance of the equities also favors the government,” the court said.
asserted
court → favor → government
“Construction in the Big Bend Sector will diminish the [plaintiffs’] ability to use and enjoy the area.
asserted
Construction → diminish → area
But Congress’s enactment of [the special law] — which permits the Secretary to waive the requirements of environmental protection and other conservation laws — reflects a clear preference for expeditious border construction over the very harms” cited by the opponents.
asserted
which → permit → opponents
Customs and Border Protection Commissioner Rodney Scott argues that the $46-billion wall project was justified despite a bipartisan coalition of landowners, local businesses and environmentalists who view it as a waste of taxpayer money.
asserted
who → argue → money
A broad coalition of environmentalists, cattle ranchers, farmers, river boat guides, outdoor activists and church leaders had gone to court in El Paso seeking to stop the construction.
asserted
coalition → go → construction
The Trump administration seeks a “green light to bulldoze one of America’s wildest, most extraordinary landscapes,” said Zeynep Graves, an attorney for the Center for Biological Diversity.
asserted
Graves → seek → Diversity
“Once Big Bend’s canyons, cultural treasures and wild ecosystems are destroyed, they’ll be lost forever.”
asserted
they → destroy → ?
But Trump’s lawyers pointed to unusual measures adopted by Congress that gave the Department of Homeland Security broad authority to construct border barriers “to deter illegal crossings in areas of high illegal entry.”
asserted
that → point → entry
One provision authorized the department’s secretary to “waive all legal requirements” that stood in the way, including environmental protection measures.
asserted
that → authorize → measures
U.S. Customs and Border Protection said it does not plan to build a border wall in the Big Bend National Park, with its steep canyons, but said new patrol roads and vehicle barriers would be added.
asserted
roads → say → canyons
Customs and Border Protection is considering border project adjustments “that would reduce its scope and avoid or minimize potential impacts,” the government said.
asserted
government → consider → impacts
However, U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone, an appointee of President George W. Bush, issued a preliminary injunction on Oct. 2 to halt further work on the border barriers.
asserted
Cardone → issue → barriers
She said the government’s own evidence showed illegal entries and drug smuggling were much less common in the Big Bend sector.
asserted
entries → say → sector
“For ‘high illegal entry’ to impose any limit, it must at least mean, not ‘the lowest rate of illegal entry,’” she said.
asserted
she → impose → entry
“The Bend Sector has the lowest rate of illegal entry along the entire U.S.-Mexico border.”
asserted
Sector → have → border
Solicitor Gen. D. John Sauer filed a fast-track appeal at the Supreme Court and urged the justices to set aside her order and to rule on the underlying legal question.
asserted
Sauer → file → question
He cited evidence that over four years, there were 89,000 apprehensions of illegal migrants in the Big Bend sector which covers nearly one-fourth of the U.S.-Mexico border.
asserted
which → cite → border
“The Sinaloa and Juarez cartels operate south of this sector across the Mexico border and seek to exploit any vulnerabilities in United States border protection to traffic humans, drugs and weapons across the border and infiltrate the United States,” he told the court.
asserted
he → operate → court
“Leaving a 300-plus-mile gap in border defenses would act as a dangerous magnet for cartels and other bad actors to exploit as other routes close off.”
asserted
routes → leave → magnet
The Aporia
