The world’s biggest climate conference kicked off today in Antalya, Turkey, a country known for growing political repression.
asserted
conference → kick → repression
Under an unusual compromise, Turkey is hosting, but Australia’s government will preside over negotiations among more than 190 nations seeking to address the climate crisis.
asserted
government → host → crisis
And for the third year in a row, one problem underscores all the others: Why can’t anyone say “fossil fuels”?
asserted
anyone → underscore → fuels
For the next two weeks, delegates from all over the world—except, notably, the United States—will discuss their progress under the Paris Agreement, the international treaty they signed in 2015 (which Donald Trump has twice withdrawn the US from).
asserted
Trump → discuss → US
Under that deal, countries committed to limiting global warming to well below 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels, and ideally to 1.5 degrees, by setting their own targets for cutting greenhouse gas emissions.
asserted
countries → commit → emissions
We’re in the middle of an El Niño season that has already smashed global temperature records and caused catastrophic flooding in Nepal.
asserted
that → ’re → Nepal
And last month, the United Nations warned that we’re on track to overshoot 1.5 degrees entirely.
asserted
we → warn → degrees
“UN climate summits have become all but synonymous with low expectations, long on rhetoric, short on action,” Covering Climate Now (CCN) reported, even though “an overwhelming majority of the world’s people, 80 to 89 percent of them, want their governments to ‘do more’ about the climate crisis.”
asserted
governments → become → crisis
The annual Conference of the Parties, as COP is officially known, has been the backdrop to my entire life.
asserted
COP → know → life
I have vague middle-school memories of the 2009 Copenhagen summit, which ended in a weak, non-binding accord that left many observers deflated.
asserted
that → have → observers
As a college student in 2015, I remember the surge of possibility I felt when negotiators in Paris emerged with a deal described as “the best possible shot to save the one planet we’ve got.”
asserted
we → remember → planet
As an adult, I joined the National Security Archive, where I interviewed dozens of former government officials, scientists, and advocates about all the ways we’ve gotten it wrong—and right—in our quest to save the planet.
asserted
it → join → planet
Perhaps the most absurd part of this history is that for nearly 30 years—my entire life—international climate negotiations largely avoided naming the primary driver of the climate crisis: fossil fuels.
asserted
negotiations → avoid → crisis
It wasn’t until COP28 in Dubai in 2023 that a final agreement explicitly called for transitioning away from fossil fuels in energy systems, a step UN climate chief Simon Stiell called the “beginning of the end” of the fossil fuel era.
asserted
Stiell → call → era
But the deal crucially neglected to say how or when a phaseout would happen.
asserted
phaseout → neglect → ?
Last year was supposed to be different.
asserted
year → suppose → ?
Brazil hosted, which was a hopeful sign: In 1992, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change was adopted at the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, an inflection point that ushered in a new era of international cooperation on climate change.
asserted
that → host → change
For the three years before that, the conference had been held in countries whose economies rely heavily on fossil fuels: Egypt, the United Arab Emirates, and Azerbaijan.
asserted
economies → hold → fuels
But at COP30 in the Amazon city of Belém, delegates failed to make any new commitments on how they’d permanently ditch oil, gas, and coal.
asserted
they → fail → oil
It’s difficult to assess the long-term significance of any individual COP in its immediate aftermath.
asserted
It → ’ → aftermath
Copenhagen was considered a failure because negotiators failed to produce a global treaty to replace the 1997 Kyoto Protocol.
asserted
negotiators → consider → Protocol
But years later, observers credited it with having “killed off the top-down treaty-based approach” to climate change, as Joshua Busby, a public affairs professor and researcher at the Center for Climate & Security, pointed out in 2015.
asserted
Busby → credit → 2015
In its place came the system of national pledges at the heart of the Paris Agreement.
asserted
system → come → Agreement
Those pledges, non-binding though they are, have had real impact.
asserted
they → have → impact
Renewable energy projects boomed.
asserted
projects → boom → ?
Energy demand growth slowed.
asserted
growth → slow → ?
Projected warming by the end of the century has dropped from about 3.6 degrees Celsius to 2.6 degrees.
asserted
warming → project → degrees
Of course, 2.6 degrees Celsius is hardly a victory, and a gargantuan amount of work remains to avoid the most catastrophic climate scenarios, assuming all nations meaningfully pitch in.
asserted
nations → remain → scenarios
When President Trump refused to send a delegation to last year’s conference, former Secretary of State and Special Climate Envoy John Kerry told PBS that the absence of of leaders from the world’s second-biggest greenhouse gas emitter “defeats the fundamental purpose of these meetings” because “no one country can solve this problem by itself.”
asserted
country → refuse → itself
Despite a handful of Democratic members of Congress attending this year’s summit, COP31 will be the second year in a row with a US delegation–sized hole in it.
asserted
COP31 → attend → it
But plenty of other countries have woken up to the idea that we have to break up with fossil fuels, with over 60 nations coming together in April in Santa Marta, Colombia to discuss a fossil fuel phaseout outside formal COP negotiations.
asserted
nations → wake → negotiations
A conference that fails to deliver the right language can still build momentum that changes what’s politically possible at the next one.
asserted
what → fail → one
“We are a majority power that therefore can have confidence that we have a collective global community that really wants this to succeed, and that it isn’t too late,” Johan Rockström, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, said at the close of an October webinar.
asserted
Rockström → have → webinar
“The window is still open, but rapidly shutting.”
asserted
window → shut → ?
The Aporia
