Labour’s deputy leader, Lucy Powell, has criticised the “depressing” nature of the cross-examination of Russell Brand’s victims during his trial for rape and sexual assault, saying she believed the courts had “long gone past that sort of culture”.
asserted
courts → criticise → culture
Powell, now the education secretary, also said she regretted the meeting that the former party leader Ed Miliband had with Brand in 2015, when she was Labour’s campaign chief.
asserted
she → say → 2015
Brand was jailed for 10 and a half years on Monday for raping a woman and sexually assaulting three others, including at their workplaces.
asserted
Brand → jail → workplaces
Powell was asked on LBC radio about Brand’s defence in court, during which his barrister, Ian Winter KC, suggested Brand must be innocent because none of his victims had “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave”.
uncertain
none → ask → victims
Winter also said the anal rape of a 21-year-old woman by Brand was a “short and momentary failure” where “he did not respect her consent”.
asserted
he → say → consent
Asked if that was reminiscent of the attitude of the 1950s, Powell said she had been “shocked” at some of what took place in the courtroom, while praising the judge’s words.
asserted
what → ask → words
“I found reading some of that incredibly sort of depressing.
asserted
I → find → that
I thought we’d long gone past that sort of culture and that phase of things.
asserted
we → think → things
“And the judge’s remarks were also incredibly powerful in sentencing: that it doesn’t matter what you wear, how you behaved, how drunk you are
asserted
you → matter → what
, you know, you have the right to give your consent or not give your consent.
asserted
you → know → consent
And if it’s not given, then that is rape and that is a sexual offence, pure and simple.”
asserted
that → give → ?
Powell said the government had taken steps in guidance to challenge myths around rape and victim-blaming.
asserted
government → say → rape
“But clearly, a lot more needs to be done because I think many of us were really shocked that that could still take place in a courtroom today,” she said.
uncertain
she → need → courtroom
At sentencing, the judge, Mr Justice Bennathan, criticised Brand, saying the women had been subjected to additional suffering because of the conduct in court “on your instructions”.
asserted
women → criticise → instructions
“Whatever women wear, wherever they go, whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and demand justice in the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Mr Brand, act without their consent,” he said.
asserted
he → wear → consent
Powell said she and Miliband regretted that he had done an interview with Brand in 2015 during the hype around Revolution, Brand’s book on politics.
asserted
he → say → politics
At the time the interview took place, Brand had resigned his BBC Radio 2 show for leaving a series of lewd messages on actor Andrew Sachs’ answerphone about his granddaughter.
asserted
Brand → take → granddaughter
“It was a long time ago, obviously, and had I or Ed Miliband or anybody at the time had any sense at all that this was someone who was a sexual predator, who was involved in these sorts of crimes,” she told Sky News, anyone who was involved in promoting him would “look back and really regret that, knowing today what we now know”.
asserted
we → have → what
Asked about her role in setting up the interview, Powell said she had not understood the full extent of his sexual conduct that was already in the public domain – such as in his autobiography.
asserted
that → ask → autobiography
“If there was any suggestion at all we were dealing with someone who was a known sexual predator at the time then, of course, no one would have done that.
asserted
one → be → that
“But as I say, he was a well-known public figure.
asserted
he → say → ?
Lots of people, from Hollywood to the BBC to many others, gave this person a very, very powerful platform.”
asserted
Lots → give → platform
The Aporia
.jpeg?trim=60,0,60,0&auto=webp&quality=75&width=1200)
