Claims extracted
20
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
5%
1 of 20 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
withheld
no quote in the article backed the model's score
Publisher signals
67/100
Reason's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments this week in a case that asks whether property owners whose land was taken for an interstate natural gas pipeline should be able to vindicate their right to just compensation for the taken property under state law, which offers more protections in this instance than federal law does.
asserted
law → hear → instance
Unfortunately for the property owners, a majority of the justices seemed ready to doom their cause.
asserted
majority → seem → cause
You’re reading Injustice System from Damon Root and Reason.
asserted
You → read → Root
Representing the property owners at the lectern on Monday was Robert J. McNamara, deputy litigation director at the Institute for Justice, a national public-interest law firm.
asserted
McNamara → represent → Justice
"The Natural Gas Act authorizes private companies to ask courts to order the forced sale of private property, but it says nothing about the substantive law those courts should use to determine what that property is worth," he observed.
asserted
he → authorize → what
"That silence matters because, on its own, authorizing companies to file condemnations does nothing to preempt state laws defining the measure of compensation."
asserted
authorizing → matter → compensation
McNamara acknowledged that state law "wouldn't apply to the United States if it took land in its own name."
asserted
it → acknowledge → name
But in this case the land was taken by a private company acting under delegated federal authority, and "nothing in the statute extends the United States' sovereign immunity to private companies, and that means they don't have it
asserted
they → take → it
But that argument was swiftly questioned by Justice Clarence Thomas, who is normally more receptive towards property rights arguments.
asserted
who → question → arguments
"If the U.S. delegates its power, its authority to—of eminent domain, you're saying that it brings with it state law trappings of just compensation?"
asserted
it → delegate → compensation
Chief Justice John Roberts soon added his voice to the chorus of disapproval.
asserted
Roberts → add → disapproval
"I don't understand why this isn't an easy case," Roberts told McNamara.
asserted
Roberts → understand → McNamara
If the federal government has the power to take the land without facing the additional compensation rules imposed by state law, why shouldn't the government's private-sector partner enjoy the same sort of federal privileges?
asserted
partner → have → privileges
"It doesn't take much to avoid your position," Roberts asserted, "and it seems to me it's just a more efficient process to have a private developer get the land under the same terms as the federal government without having to pay the attorneys' fees that the state wants to insist on.
asserted
state → take → that
I must say that I find McNamara's argument to be much stronger than Roberts or Thomas seemed to find it.
asserted
Roberts → say → it
If we're supposed to view a private company acting with delegated federal authority as a total proxy for the federal government, is it really too much to ask that federal law make this grant of proxy power clear and unambiguous?
asserted
grant → suppose → power
Why should any textual absence or uncertainty around this delegation of federal authority cut in favor of the private company rather than in favor of the affected property owners?
asserted
absence → cut → owners
The point of the Just Compensation Clause is to cabin the government's eminent domain power, not to loosen it.
asserted
point → cabin → it
But that seemed to be a minority view at SCOTUS this week.
asserted
that → seem → SCOTUS
Judging by the oral arguments, the property owners may be headed for defeat.
uncertain
owners → judge → defeat