Even in these divided times, some ideas are so bad that both major political parties support them.
asserted
parties → support → them
That's certainly the case with proposals to let the government put a cap on the interest rates charged by credit card companies.
asserted
government → let → companies
It's a scheme that seems considerate to those who run up debt but would instead deny riskier borrowers access to legitimate credit, and it could drive many people to lenders—some underground—who charge more.
uncertain
who → seem → more
That is, it's a plan stupid enough to draw backing from Democrats and Republicans alike.
asserted
it → draw → Democrats
You are reading The Rattler from J.D. Tuccille and Reason.
asserted
You → read → Tuccille
"President Trump himself said that he wants to reduce interest rates on credit cards to 10 percent," Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D–Mass.) told CBS's Margaret Brennan on Sunday.
asserted
Warren → say → Sunday
"I got the bill, I'm ready to go.
asserted
I → get → bill
Sure enough, back in January, President Donald Trump posted on Truth Social, "Please be informed that we will no longer let the American Public be 'ripped off' by Credit Card Companies that are charging Interest Rates of 20 to 30%, and even more….Effective January 20, 2026, I, as President of the United States, am calling for a one year cap on Credit Card Interest Rates of 10%."
asserted
I → post → %
The two nominally hostile politicians discussed cooperation on the issue earlier this year, though nothing concrete has come of it so far.
asserted
nothing → discuss → it
It's enough to make you wonder if the issue is enough to bridge political divides for these two as they flirt over their shared interest in idiotic economic populism.
asserted
they → make → populism
And the idea of capping credit card interest rates really is idiotic, unless you're trying to deny options to higher-risk borrowers and drive them to more expensive alternatives like payday lenders and loan sharks.
asserted
you → cap → lenders
We don't have to speculate on the impact of such caps; there's plenty of evidence that trying to forcibly lower borrowing costs for consumers cuts them off from legitimate credit.
asserted
trying → have → credit
In 2021, the Federal Reserve Board published a paper by Gregory Elliehausen, Simona M. Hannon, and Thomas W. Miller Jr., examining the impact of a 17 percent interest rate cap in Arkansas.
asserted
Board → publish → Arkansas
They found that "consumer finance companies, traditionally a source of credit for nonprime consumers, do not have offices in Arkansas because, being subject to the usury ceiling, they cannot profitably lend to risky consumers."
asserted
they → find → consumers
Because of its impact on riskier borrowers, the cap was loosened for banks to "allow consumers to escape restrictive effects of the low Arkansas rate ceiling."
asserted
consumers → loosen → ceiling
Even so, "results of our analysis suggest that nonprime consumers in Arkansas were rationed" in terms of access to credit.
asserted
consumers → suggest → credit
Notably, the paper described the 17 percent cap as "very restrictive."
asserted
paper → describe → cap
The 10 percent cap currently contemplated by politicians of both major parties would be that much tighter and could be anticipated to further restrict access to credit.
uncertain
cap → contemplate → credit
'An Interest Rate Cap Does Not Make Loans Less Expensive; It Makes Loans Less Available'
"A federal-government-imposed cap on credit card annual percentage rates (APRs) as severe as 10 percent would likely upend the credit card industry's current business model," American Enterprise Institute senior fellow Paul H. Kupiec warned in a report published earlier this year that delved into precisely that proposal.
asserted
that → make → proposal
"Issuers would cancel most existing near-prime and subprime accounts.
asserted
Issuers → cancel → accounts
While some issuers might offer current cardholders new account terms with high fees and collateral requirements, many issuers would just outright cancel accounts with weak credit scores.
uncertain
issuers → offer → scores
Or as Miller, a finance professor at Mississippi State University, told the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs in 2021, "an interest rate cap does not make loans less expensive; it makes loans less available."
Some advocates of interest rate caps argue that this isn't a bad outcome.
asserted
this → tell → caps
They insist that the poor borrow themselves into worse circumstances and that making credit less available will save people from their own bad instincts.
asserted
credit → insist → instincts
But that's not how the world works.
asserted
world → work → ?
If people want to borrow money for reasons of necessity or desire, they'll navigate barriers of convenience and legality to get what they want.
asserted
they → want → what
If they find a lender—and they often do—they usually end up paying more for their trouble.
asserted
they → find → trouble
Driving High-Risk Borrowers to Expensive and Sometimes Illegal Lenders
"Consider the tough, life-impacting decisions affected consumers must make if they do not have access to credit," Miller added.
asserted
Miller → drive → credit
"Perhaps people will delay going to the doctor, or the dentist, or a taking a pet to the veterinarian.
asserted
people → delay → veterinarian
Perhaps they will not buy needed school supplies for their children.
asserted
they → buy → children
Perhaps they will defer necessary maintenance or repairs to their home or vehicle, or they might bounce a check to pay a utility bill.
uncertain
they → defer → bill
They might even seek the much-needed credit from illegal loan sharks."
uncertain
They → seek → sharks
Writing in March of this year for the International Center for Law and Economics, senior scholar Julian Morris pointed out that "after Japan tightened rate caps under the 2006 revision of the Money Lending Business Act, consumer-finance balances fell sharply, while illegal lending expanded.
asserted
lending → write → Act
Some illegal lenders reportedly charged rates as high as 10% per week—equivalent to an APR of 14,104%.
uncertain
lenders → charge → %
"
The experience from South Korea is similar, he continued.
asserted
he → continue → Korea
"After progressively lowering its statutory maximum rate to 20% by 2021, one study estimates that a single 2018 rate reduction pushed roughly 659,000 borrowers into informal or illegal credit channels.
asserted
reduction → lower → channels
That's not to say that higher-risk borrowers all end up going to loan sharks.
asserted
borrowers → say → sharks
Markets are responsive, and alternatives to credit cards already exist.
asserted
alternatives → exist → cards
These include installment loans, payday lenders, and buy now, pay later (BNPL) arrangements.
asserted
These → include → loans
BNPL is the least expensive option for those who qualify, since they're often financed by retailers.
asserted
they → qualify → retailers
But they're very limited in application and best for small purchases.
asserted
they → limit → purchases
…and 6 more, not listed.