Downing Street is considering whether plans to replace key disability benefits with work and training for people under-25 should be expanded to older age groups, the Guardian has learned, in a move that risks reigniting Labour tensions over welfare changes.
asserted
that → consider → changes
Andy Burnham and other cabinet ministers are looking at applying the idea of “participation first” to all people of working age, meaning spending billions more on support to enter the workplace while cutting or removing some disability benefits.
asserted
Burnham → look → benefits
The move would be politically risky given the difficulties that Keir Starmer faced in getting changes to health and disability benefits past the Labour parliamentary party last year, with a rebellion leading to a major U-turn.
asserted
rebellion → give → turn
The government is preparing to accept recommendations from its adviser, Alan Milburn, next week on overhauling the benefits system for young people.
asserted
government → prepare → people
In his report, Milburn will propose that under-25s should get training and support instead of the universal credit health element.
asserted
under-25s → propose → training
Under the plans, young people with disabilities will also lose their personal independence payment (Pip) but will be able to apply to a local fund for specific short-term expenses and equipment, rather than an ongoing payment.
asserted
people → lose → expenses
Those with the most extreme needs who cannot work will have their entitlements protected.
asserted
entitlements → work → needs
This week, cabinet ministers looked at whether the arguments could be applied more broadly to over-25s, and were considering an intervention from the prime minister or Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, to make the case that the principles should apply to all.
uncertain
principles → look → all
This could happen within weeks of both the Milburn review and the Stephen Timms review into disability benefits being published.
uncertain
review → happen → benefits
Some government sources said they believed the idea of expanding the welfare changes to over-25s would ultimately not survive given the probable backlash from some parts of Labour.
asserted
idea → say → Labour
Others said they believed Milburn had successfully made the case that the system needed to change and that the public were behind his efforts.
asserted
public → say → efforts
Burnham has repeatedly said the changes would not be “crude cuts”, but some backbenchers have said they are sceptical and worried about the impact on young disabled people.
asserted
they → say → people
If the changes were expanded to the over-25s, it could yield more savings as the cohort is much larger than the under-25s and the level of support needed to get people back into employment would probably be lower.
uncertain
level → expand → employment
Ministers have said they believe any system for the over-25s would need to reflect the different circumstances of older people, many of whom had families or caring responsibilities, and more complex health needs.
asserted
many → say → families
However, there was a belief that many of the core problems, including detachment from the workplace and a need to encourage greater participation, were the same for under- and over-25s.
asserted
many → be → under-
A government source said: “The support offer and benefit changes Alan has set out were devised for young people and the specific circumstances they face.
asserted
they → say → people
But the Timms review has set out that Pip is no longer fit for purpose, and the government will respond to that review when it reports.”
asserted
it → set → review
Milburn, a cabinet minister under Tony Blair, has promised his report is about giving billions more in support to young people to help them into work.
asserted
report → promise → work
The Guardian has learned there has been consternation within some government departments – including the Department of Health and the Department for Education – that the upfront funding for Milburn’s extra support will come from within their budgets.
asserted
funding → learn → budgets
Some estimates have put the cost of the support being proposed by Milburn at about £6bn.
asserted
estimates → put → 6bn
However, it is understood the government will not put that level of spending on support that will be provided to young people instead of benefits – although there will be some numbers provided about different elements of funding required and a trajectory to savings.
asserted
that → understand → savings
Milburn told the Guardian this week that the support for young people outlined in his report would create 440,000 employment and education opportunities by 2036 and raise the net incomes of young people by more than £2bn.
asserted
support → tell → 2bn
He said the main finding of the review was not a lack of ambition from young people but a lack of opportunities.
asserted
finding → say → opportunities
“I have not met a single young person who wanted to be Neet [not in education, employment or training].
asserted
who → meet → education
They want independence, they want to earn their own money and they want someone to give them a chance,” he said.
asserted
he → want → chance
The Guardian revealed last month that ministers were working up sweeping plans for welfare changes, including scrapping key disability benefits for under-25s and replacing it with a multibillion-pound package of support to get into work.
asserted
ministers → reveal → work
Charities are nervous about how the proposals will affect young people.
asserted
proposals → affect → people
The Joseph Rowntree Foundation said the proposals could significantly weaken the safety net for hundreds of thousands of young people with a disability or health condition, leaving many of those on universal credit living on a basic rate of support of about £80 a week.
uncertain
proposals → say → 80
“Cutting someone’s income when they’re already struggling to afford food or the bus to college makes it harder for them to stay in education or find work,” said Iain Porter, the charity’s senior policy adviser.
asserted
Porter → cut → work
More than 40 of the UK’s leading charities have warned ministers against imposing tougher benefit sanctions or cuts on disabled young people.
asserted
40 → lead → people
In their joint letter to Milburn and McFadden, they said cutting support or bringing in sanctions risked pushing thousands of vulnerable youngsters deeper into poverty and further away from employment.
asserted
cutting → say → employment
Polling suggests that while the public favours cutting the welfare bill overall, they believe that tackling the root causes of joblessness instead of cutting benefits is the best way to do it.
uncertain
tackling → suggest → it
Welfare spending has reached £333bn this year, with pensioners receiving roughly 55% of the budget, and young people, including Neets but not children, about 2.5%.
asserted
pensioners → reach → Neets
A government spokesperson said: “The Milburn and Timms reviews are due to be published shortly, and we will respond to their recommendations in full.
asserted
we → say → recommendations
“We will always ensure there is a safety net for the most vulnerable and those who are unable to work.
asserted
who → ensure → vulnerable
But the prime minister has been clear that we need a wholesale change in the way we support young people to grow up in this country, where we invest in their success rather than paying for failure.”
asserted
we → need → failure
The Aporia
