This month, IJ client Libby Souder asked the South Carolina Supreme Court to let her resume teaching private swim lessons in her backyard pool, which she'd done for years with city approval and without incident.
asserted
she → ask → incident
But after a nosy neighbor (whose life is in no way affected by the lessons) complained, officials reinterpreted an ambiguous provision of the zoning code to shut down Libby's business.
asserted
officials → affect → business
Baltimore police can use a "Hailstorm" device to stimulate your cell phone and figure out where you are.
asserted
you → use → phone
Do they need a warrant for that?
asserted
they → need → that
- President to Voice of America's head: You're fired!
asserted
You → fire → head
VOA head: Only the International Broadcasting Advisory Board can fire me.
asserted
Board → fire → me
The president can now sack members of the board at will, and that is enough to satisfy Article II, even if it may cause some delay while the president gets his preferred board members confirmed for them to then sack their subordinates.
uncertain
them → sack → subordinates
- In which the Second Circuit revives a challenge to New York City rules that prohibit people from, among other things, carrying more than one handgun at a time and registering more than two handguns.
asserted
that → revive → handguns
- In which the Second Circuit overrules precedent and holds that if your prosecution comes to an end in the form of an "adjournment in contemplation of dismissal," you can indeed pursue malicious-prosecution claims.
uncertain
you → overrule → claims
(This plaintiff's claim fails on other grounds, however.)
uncertain
claim → fail → grounds
- In investigating a leak of classified information to a news outlet, the feds seek orders compelling LinkedIn to turn over records of all the involved journalists' communications over an 18-month period (including with all confidential sources) and to keep it a secret.
asserted
feds → investigate → it
LinkedIn challenges the orders.
asserted
LinkedIn → challenge → orders
The gov't "is entitled to a disclosure order," "[b]ut it is not entitled to carte blanche."
asserted
it → entitle → blanche
Remand for district court to narrow the disclosures to communications actually relevant to the leak in question and to provide a little secrecy wiggle-room.
asserted
court → narrow → room
- Lowell, Mich. mom frequently denounces public school policies and personnel on social media.
asserted
mom → denounce → media
School officials do not interfere until she posts:
asserted
she → interfere → ?
"Christ said, 'Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened around his neck and drowned in the depth of the sea.'"
asserted
millstone → say → sea
After that, she's told to stop posting about school employees by name or face legal consequences.
asserted
she → tell → consequences
Sixth Circuit (2-1): Which might have violated her 1A rights; claim undismissed.
uncertain
Which → violate → rights
- The Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA) restricts prisoners from filing lawsuits in forma pauperis if they have three or more "strikes"—i.e., actions dismissed as frivolous, malicious, or failing to state a claim.
uncertain
they → restrict → claim
But that doesn't cover cases dismissed on the grounds of sovereign immunity or failure to prosecute.
asserted
that → cover → immunity
So this lawsuit can go forward.
asserted
lawsuit → go → ?
But Congress really should count those.
asserted
Congress → count → those
And until they do, here are some tips on how district courts can deal with prisoners who try to make their lawsuits "strike proof."
asserted
lawsuits → do → prisoners
- Do people living in an apartment complex near an ICE facility in Portland, Ore. have a substantive due process right to be free from tear gas seeping into their homes?
asserted
people → live → homes
That sure doesn't seem to appear in our nation's history or traditions.
asserted
That → seem → history
Plaintiffs need only show that the conduct shocks the conscience.
asserted
conduct → need → conscience
And since there's some evidence ICE deployed the tear gas to create content for social media, this should qualify.
asserted
this → be → media
- Okay, but do peaceful protestors and journalists in Portland have a First Amendment right not to be shot in the face with pepper balls by ICE agents in ambiguously marked uniforms?
asserted
protestors → have → uniforms
They do not.
asserted
They → do → ?
They should really only be doing that in situations where they would be allowed to use lethal force.
asserted
they → do → force
- Federal law exempts plaintiffs from mandatory arbitration if they allege a sexual-harassment claim, which means (according to two-thirds of this Ninth Circuit panel) that SpaceX employees who complained about Elon Musk's propensity for prurient tweets get to stay in federal court.
uncertain
who → exempt → court
- Ninth Circuit: Look, we're not necessarily saying a city violates the Americans with Disabilities Act by refusing to exempt a woman from its prohibition on sleeping in cars after she informs officials that her OCD sometimes requires her to sleep in her car.
asserted
OCD → look → car
But we're definitely saying her complaint states a viable ADA claim.
uncertain
complaint → say → claim
- California enacts two laws that require companies to disclose information about their greenhouse gas emissions and exposure to climate-related risks.
asserted
that → enact → risks
Business groups sue, alleging violations of the First Amendment.
asserted
groups → sue → Amendment
Applying intermediate scrutiny, we uphold two of the disclosure requirements, but enjoin the one requiring companies to report "indirect emissions," including those from its suppliers and customers.
asserted
we → apply → suppliers
We also enjoin the one about climate-related risks, which compels subjective, ideological speech.
asserted
which → enjoin → speech
Dissent: All of the requirements should get strict scrutiny, which they fail.
-
asserted
they → get → which
Arizona man is convicted for his role in 2015 shooting at Garland, Tex. "Draw Muhammad" event and sentenced to 30 years.
asserted
man → convict → years
…and 13 more, not listed.