- Published
Cheers erupted at Delhi's Jantar Mantar protest site in July as news broke that Gen-Z protests had forced federal education minister Dharmendra Pradhan to resign.
asserted
protests → publish → Pradhan
One protester turned to me, beaming: "This is the youth's victory."
asserted
This → turn → me
Just over three months later, the mood has shifted dramatically.
asserted
mood → shift → ?
Student protesters are now struggling even to assemble.
asserted
protesters → struggle → ?
Demonstrations by the Gen Z-led Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) last month over voting rights were met with sweeping restrictions and thousands of peaceful protesters were detained.
asserted
thousands → lead → protesters
The summer had seen a new wave of dissent in India, driven by deep frustration among the youth and fuelled by irreverent online satire.
asserted
summer → see → satire
The movement spread across the country, and Prime Minister Narendra Modi, a leader with a strongman image, unaccustomed to open criticism or mockery, struggled to contain it.
asserted
Modi → spread → it
But the government's increasingly forceful security response suggests it has learned from its rare concession to protesters, invoking public order to curb dissent.
uncertain
it → suggest → dissent
The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) national spokesperson Syed Zafar Islam rejected accusations of heavy-handedness and told the BBC: "The right to protest and freedom of expression is mandated by the constitution, but it has to be done within the law.
asserted
it → rule → law
It cannot override the rights of others, at the cost of public security".
asserted
It → override → security
This is by no means the first time the Modi government has faced large-scale protests.
asserted
government → face → protests
But the breadth of them pose a challenge for the BJP, according to Yamini Aiyar, former president of the Centre for Policy Research and visiting professor at Brown University.
uncertain
breadth → pose → University
"They are not defined by caste, gender or economic class," Aiyar said.
asserted
Aiyar → define → caste
"Even some of the core BJP base, the upwardly mobile, lower-income classes, were attracted by the movement.
asserted
some → attract → movement
The scale of the youth protests is also magnified by its online presence.
asserted
scale → magnify → presence
Protesters have broken a longstanding political taboo, openly mocking the prime minister online.
asserted
Protesters → break → minister
"It's more than just laughs," said Sakhi, a student protester who identifies as they/them and affiliated with one of Delhi University's left-wing student organisations.
asserted
who → say → organisations
"The fear of repercussions in other generations isn't felt as much in ours," they said.
asserted
they → feel → ours
"Comedy is a new language to challenge authority."
asserted
Comedy → challenge → authority
Previous protest movements posed serious challenges to Modi but were easier to dismiss as representing narrow sections of society or to label "anti-national", according to Aiyar.
uncertain
movements → pose → Aiyar
In 2020, farmers protesting against controversial agricultural reforms were blocked from entering Delhi, leading to months of demonstrations and, at times, clashes on the capital's borders.
asserted
farmers → protest → borders
After a year of protests, the government abandoned the reforms.
asserted
government → abandon → reforms
Protests against a contentious citizenship law in 2019 and 2020 are a stark reminder of the powers of the judiciary should anyone be deemed a national security threat.
asserted
anyone → deem → judiciary
Student activist Umar Khalid was arrested under anti-terror laws after violent clashes in Delhi that killed 53 people, mostly Muslims.
asserted
that → arrest → people
He was accused of being a "key conspirator".
asserted
He → accuse → ?
He has now spent more than six years in jail without his trial having begun.
asserted
trial → spend → jail
His partner Banojyotsna Lahiri told the BBC they have no regrets, but that the situation instilled "a kind of fear that has prevailed".
asserted
that → tell → fear
"We are just looking at a very dark mesh of empty space, because we don't know when the endpoint is," Lahiri said.
asserted
Lahiri → look → space
Khalid's latest appeal was lodged this month.
asserted
appeal → lodge → ?
Aiyar believes opponents are using a familiar "playbook" today to "de-legitimise" protests, but that it isn't resonating as convincingly.
Nevertheless, the youth protests have struggled to recapture this summer's momentum.
asserted
protests → believe → momentum
CJP leaders, including spokesperson Saurav Das, have faced repeated detentions and legal action.
asserted
leaders → include → detentions
Das and fellow leader Ashutosh Ranka spent a week in Delhi's Tihar jail after being accused of trespassing at Jantar Mantar.
asserted
Das → spend → Mantar
The site of their summer victory has since been struck off the list of authorised protest venues, a decision being challenged in court.
asserted
site → strike → court
Protesters from other groups, including the left-wing All India Students' Association (Aisa), have also faced police action over allegations of defying orders.
"
asserted
Protesters → include → orders
We were expecting some kind of crackdown," said Das.
asserted
Das → expect → crackdown
He added that "the government has learnt a lot" since the summer.
asserted
government → add → summer
Legal experts warn the proceedings themselves can have a chilling effect.
asserted
proceedings → warn → effect
"A lot of cases can lead to acquittals, but it can take years.
asserted
it → lead → years
The process is the punishment, and that can deter protesters," said Ali Khan, an assistant professor at Lloyd Law College.
asserted
Khan → deter → College
The restrictions on demonstrations have become excessive, according to constitutional lawyer Vrinda Grover, who is advising the CJP.
uncertain
who → become → CJP
…and 19 more, not listed.