- Published
Mention Christmas markets these days and the conversation often turns to rising prices – from £8 bratwursts, £11 Yorkshire pudding wraps and even £5 for a few marshmallow sticks.
asserted
conversation → publish → sticks
But what do the people behind the stalls think?
asserted
people → think → stalls
Are they benefiting from the hikes or are their own profits being squeezed?
asserted
profits → benefit → hikes
Traders at Manchester's Christmas markets told the BBC they were feeling the pressure of increasing bills for staff, ingredients and energy, with some saying they were making less money despite charging more.
asserted
they → tell → more
One trader said it costs at least £4,000 a day to run each her four stalls, while another has cut prices to keep customers coming back.
asserted
customers → say → prices
Nils Borstel, 25, helps run Bratwurst King, a family business which has operated at the markets since 1999.
asserted
which → run → 1999
He said a sausage that previously cost £3.50 now sold for £8, with much of the increase taking place over the past five or six years.
asserted
much → say → years
"But we don't earn more money," he said.
asserted
he → earn → money
Borstel, whose family operates four stalls across the city centre, said rising costs for meat, electricity, staffing and accommodation had forced the business to increase prices.
asserted
costs → operate → prices
About 15 workers travel from Germany to help run the stalls, alongside staff recruited in the UK.
asserted
workers → travel → UK
He said that despite busy crowds and dry weather during the opening weekend, people appeared more cautious about spending than in previous years.
asserted
people → say → years
For example, some customers were now buying one portion of food to share, rather than purchasing one each, he said.
asserted
he → buy → one
Borstel said he had seen a change in spending habits since 2019, when customers were more willing to buy food and drinks without worrying about the cost.
asserted
customers → say → cost
He acknowledged that prices were high and did not want to increase them, but said the they were necessary to cover expenses.
asserted
they → acknowledge → expenses
Among those questioning the costs were Neve and Poppy, both 18.
asserted
Neve → question → costs
Neve, a student, said she had spent about £15 on one dish, while Poppy, who is taking a gap year, paid £11 for a Yorkshire pudding wrap.
"I think it was pricey for what it was," Neve said.
asserted
Neve → say → wrap
Poppy also felt she had not received much food for the money, although said it was tasty.
asserted
it → feel → money
Both said they enjoyed going into the city and looking around the markets, while Neve sympathised with traders, saying she thought the cost of renting space could force businesses to raise prices.
uncertain
cost → say → prices
Business pressures
Charlotte Whittle, director of CT Catering, has been trading at the markets for 10 years and now operates four stalls.
asserted
Whittle → trade → stalls
She said each stall cost at least £1,000 a day to run, bringing her total daily operating costs to at least £4,000.
asserted
stall → say → 4,000
Whittle, who employs a range of staff, said customers often underestimated the work and expense involved.
asserted
customers → employ → work
Before the markets opened, her business spent two weeks preparing its stalls, with another two weeks needed to dismantle them after Christmas.
asserted
weeks → open → Christmas
She said the costs included staff wages, accommodation, deliveries, storage, packaging and card payment fees.
asserted
costs → say → wages
Parking three vans in Manchester city centre could cost £100 a day alone, she said, with the vehicles needed to replenish stock throughout busy trading periods.
uncertain
vehicles → park → periods
"They think that you're just selling cookies," she said.
asserted
she → think → cookies
Whittle, who began her business selling homemade cakes at street food markets, said the cost of stock and packaging had increased significantly over the years.
Holding prices down
Although she had increased some prices, she said she had chosen to absorb part of those costs rather than risk putting customers off.
"We've had to take a massive cut on profits," she said.
asserted
she → begin → profits
She also argued that the standard of street food had improved and customers were receiving food comparable in quality to that served in restaurants.
asserted
customers → argue → restaurants
But not every trader has responded to rising costs by putting up prices.
asserted
trader → respond → prices
Clark Murphy, whose family has traded at the markets for 22 years, runs Mr Crimble Crumble, which sells fruit crumbles from two stalls.
asserted
which → trade → stalls
He said the business had kept most prices unchanged for three years and had reduced the cost of its largest portion by £2.
asserted
business → say → 2
Murphy said cooking oil and biodegradable packaging had become more expensive, but the business wanted to retain customers who returned each Christmas.
"We haven't increased our prices for three years now," he said.
asserted
he → say → years
He said the business remained profitable, although margins were under pressure and card payments added to operating costs.
asserted
payments → say → costs
At another food stall, a notice offered customers £1 off each drink or dish when paying cash.
asserted
notice → offer → cash
"Card fees are crazy – help us keep it simple," it said.
asserted
it → help → it
Meanwhile, a gift trader calling himself Ernie the Elf, who sells handmade Christmas decorations in Albert Square, said visitors could still find affordable products.
uncertain
visitors → call → products
His decorations cost £4 each or three for £10, while metal signs were priced at £9.
asserted
signs → cost → 9
Ernie, who is in his second year at the Manchester markets, said traders faced substantial expenses, including accommodation and parking.
asserted
traders → say → accommodation
But he believed the markets offered good value, pointing out that people could enjoy the festive atmosphere without having to spend money.
uncertain
people → believe → money
More than food
Tyler, from Australia, and Rebecca, from Hong Kong, were enjoying their first Christmas in England with their daughter.
asserted
Tyler → enjoy → daughter
Rebecca bought four brownies for £10, while Tyler paid £6 for a meat pie, which he said was not unreasonable compared with some other prices.
asserted
he → buy → prices
…and 5 more, not listed.