An organ transplant controversy tests 'the dead donor rule'
asserted
controversy → test → rule
The U.S. organ transplant system has approved the first national policy for a controversial procedure used to remove organs from hospital patients.
asserted
system → approve → patients
The guidelines are designed to protect potential donors.
asserted
guidelines → design → donors
But critics say they do little to improve safety and fail to address deeply troubling ethical concerns.
asserted
they → say → concerns
The procedure is called normothermic regional perfusion, known as NRP.
asserted
procedure → call → NRP
It can be used after a family has decided to withdraw care because there's no hope of meaningful recovery for the person.
asserted
family → use → person
To perform NRP, doctors attach an external pump to a donor minutes after their circulation has ended and they've been declared dead.
asserted
they → perform → donor
The pump restores blood flow to their hearts, lungs, kidneys, liver and other organs to keep them from deteriorating.
asserted
pump → restore → them
"The hope with NRP is that it increases the supply of organs and it increases the quality of the organs," says Dr. Raymond Lynch, the director of transplantation at the Health Resources & Services Administration, the federal agency that oversees the organ transplant system.
asserted
that → increase → system
NRP could help solve the chronic organ shortage, Lynch says.
uncertain
Lynch → help → shortage
More than 109,000 Americans are waiting for an organ transplant, according to HRSA.
uncertain
Americans → wait → HRSA
About 12 die every day because of a chronic organ shortage.
asserted
12 → die → shortage
Critics, however, say NRP is unethical because it violates the Dead Donor Rule, which is the most important rule protecting potential donors.
asserted
which → say → donors
The rule says transplant surgeons can only take organs from patients after they are dead because of brain death or circulatory death.
asserted
they → say → death
But because NRP restarts circulation, critics say the procedure reverses the very condition upon which the person has just been declared dead.
asserted
person → restart → which
"In order to be dead by circulatory criteria it means we're not going to attempt to reestablish circulation.
asserted
we → mean → circulation
But that's exactly what they do in NRP," says Dr. Lainie Friedman Ross, a University of Rochester bioethicist.
asserted
Ross → do → Rochester
"So, yes, I have a real problem with NRP.
asserted
I → have → NRP
I think it violates the dead donor rule.
asserted
it → think → rule
It's taking organs from people who are no longer dead.
asserted
who → take → people
The other aspect of NRP that troubles critics is what surgeons do to try to make sure the donor is also brain dead, after circulation has been restarted by a mechanical pump.
asserted
circulation → trouble → pump
They clamp off blood vessels that supply the head.
asserted
that → clamp → head
But alarm bells started going off for organ retrieval teams when blood appeared to get restored – or "reperfused" – to the brain during some NRP cases.
asserted
blood → start → cases
"We have seen signs of life in NRP when the brain has been reperfused," says Dr. Claire Morgan, a transplant surgeon who serves on the transplant network's Patient Affairs Committee and was the first to report such cases to HRSA.
asserted
who → see → HRSA
Those cases prompted HRSA to instruct the Organ Procurement & Transplantation Network (OPTN), which runs the organ system, to investigate and develop a response.
asserted
which → prompt → response
On Nov. 6, the OPTN board of directors approved the first phase of the first uniform national guidelines for how to perform NRP.
asserted
board → approve → NRP
The new guidelines, which will go into effect Dec. 6, call for surgeons to do more than just clamp the blood vessels to the brain.
asserted
surgeons → go → brain
They should also cut holes in them, according to the new policy.
uncertain
They → cut → policy
"Clamping the blood vessels should stop blood flowing to the brain," says Lynch.
asserted
Lynch → clamp → brain
"Cutting or venting above the level of the clamping is a second safeguard to make sure that if the clamping is insufficient that it immediately drains out of the head and is not supplying warm oxygenated blood to the brain.
asserted
it → cut → brain
"
The new policy also includes other protections, including recommending against giving donors drugs that would paralyze them and mask any movements.
asserted
that → include → movements
But critics say the new safeguards are insufficient.
asserted
safeguards → say → ?
Most surgeons already both clamp and vent blood vessels to the brain, for example, they say.
asserted
they → clamp → example
"I honestly don't believe they have created a policy that creates much or any more protection than these donors already had," says Morgan, who also disagrees with the decision to implement the first phase of the new guidelines on an emergency basis before the public had a chance to weigh in.
asserted
public → believe → chance
Critics also say the new policy doesn't begin to address the bigger concerns that NRP donors are not technically dead when surgeons remove their organs.
asserted
surgeons → say → organs
They worry the adoption of the policy could speed the use of NRP before the troubling questions have been fully aired.
uncertain
questions → worry → NRP
"I really think the policy is the cart before the horse," says Dr. Matthew DeCamp, a University of Colorado bioethicist.
asserted
DeCamp → think → Colorado
"The fundamental issues around NRP still remain unresolved."
asserted
issues → remain → NRP
Lynch, however, argues the new guidelines will protect donors and that NRP is ethical.
asserted
NRP → argue → donors
"This is an important first step to make sure NRP care is available but that the safety of the family's loved one is always at the forefront," Lynch says.
asserted
Lynch → make → forefront
…and 2 more, not listed.