Democrats and Republicans in the new Congress will disagree about plenty in health policy.
asserted
Democrats → disagree → policy
However, they should agree that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) should be a scientific agency whose judgments hold steady no matter who occupies the White House.
asserted
who → agree → House
In January, Congress will have the chance to write that principle into law.
asserted
Congress → have → law
For decades, the scientific independence of America’s public health agencies rested on a bipartisan understanding.
asserted
independence → rest → understanding
Presidential administrations disagreed about health policy, sometimes profoundly, but their health secretaries generally respected the expertise and established processes of agencies like the CDC and the Food and Drug Administration.
asserted
secretaries → disagree → CDC
Earlier administrations of both parties—including those of Republican Secretary of Health and Human Services Alex Azar and Democratic Secretary Xavier Becerra—faced charges of political interference, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic, and some had merit.
asserted
some → include → merit
But I would argue that none have even approached the scale and scope of Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s interventions.
asserted
none → argue → interventions
The safeguards that existed were administrative policies, and a new secretary can discard them.
asserted
secretary → exist → them
In June 2025, Kennedy dismissed all 17 members of the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices and replaced them with his own appointees.
asserted
Kennedy → dismiss → appointees
No prior secretary had done this.
asserted
secretary → do → this
Congress had given U.S. Health and Human Services secretaries broad authority and relied on their restraint.
asserted
Congress → give → restraint
Restraint is a tradition, and the past year shows it can end.
asserted
it → show → ?
To address this, Congress should pursue four priorities.
asserted
Congress → address → priorities
First, write scientific independence into law
Elected leaders have a legitimate role in setting national health priorities and holding agencies accountable.
asserted
agencies → write → priorities
That role ends where scientific judgment begins, and Congress should draw the line in statute:
Codify the advisory committee on immunization with clear membership qualifications, a transparent appointment process, and removal only for cause.
asserted
Congress → end → cause
Require a secretary who departs from a formal recommendation to explain why in public, separating the scientific evidence from considerations like cost and implementation.
asserted
who → require → cost
These rules must bind every future secretary, including those appointed by the party that controls Congress today.
asserted
that → bind → Congress
A protection that works against only one party’s appointees will not last.
asserted
that → work → appointees
Rebuild the CDC’s workforce and expertise
The CDC has lost more than a quarter of its workforce since 2024.
asserted
CDC → rebuild → 2024
The losses include epidemiologists who investigate outbreaks, laboratory scientists who identify emerging pathogens, specialists who evaluate evidence, and professionals who work with state and local health departments.
asserted
who → include → departments
That expertise takes years to develop.
asserted
expertise → take → years
Congress should require an independent assessment of the CDC’s current capabilities and direct the agency to produce a public rebuilding plan with measurable targets for restoring essential functions.
asserted
Congress → require → functions
Personnel protections should support a professional scientific workforce that can serve administrations of either party.
asserted
that → support → party
Targets should follow the agency’s mission, whatever headcount that implies.
asserted
that → follow → headcount
Write the CDC’s core responsibilities into law, starting with data
COVID exposed confusion about the separate roles of the federal and state governments.
asserted
COVID → write → governments
The CDC could issue guidance, but implementation depended on state and local officials working under different laws, budgets, and political pressures.
uncertain
officials → issue → laws
Congress should specify what Americans can count on their national public health agency to do: investigate outbreaks when states request help, publish evidence-based guidance, and operate a national data system that state and local health departments can contribute to and draw from in near real time.
asserted
departments → specify → time
It should fund those partners to participate, because the CDC’s guidance reaches Americans through their local health departments.
asserted
guidance → fund → departments
Pair independence with accountability
Scientific independence invites scrutiny, and protecting the CDC from political interference makes meaningful accountability more important.
asserted
accountability → pair → interference
Congress should establish public measures of performance.
asserted
Congress → establish → performance
How effectively does the CDC identify and investigate emerging threats?
asserted
CDC → identify → threats
How quickly does it get reliable information to states?
asserted
it → get → states
How transparently does it evaluate evidence?
asserted
it → evaluate → evidence
How well does it communicate uncertainty and update recommendations as evidence changes?
asserted
evidence → communicate → recommendations
An independent body should evaluate these questions, accounting for outcomes that depend on state and local partners.
asserted
that → evaluate → partners
The purpose is to find weaknesses and improve performance.
asserted
purpose → find → performance
With a Republican president in the White House, sweeping legislation will require bipartisan support.
asserted
legislation → require → support
Congress can begin with oversight hearings, appropriations language, and independent investigations while it builds a coalition for lasting statutory protections.
asserted
it → begin → protections
And they can start by pursuing common-sense, common-ground policies.
asserted
they → start → policies
For eight decades, the CDC has protected Americans from infectious diseases and other health threats.
asserted
CDC → protect → diseases
…and 1 more, not listed.