When you are a guy who is a teacher, there is one topic that comes up over and over again, especially when you’re working at an elementary school.
asserted
you → be → school
Kyle Joseph, a 23-year-old now in his second year teaching Grade 6 at a school in Calgary, wishes this topic was civics, because he loves the subject and wants his students to feel as inspired and excited by it as he is.
asserted
he → teach → it
But that’s not the theme that keeps following him around.
asserted
that → ’ → him
When you are a guy who is a teacher, all anybody wants to talk about is the fact that you’re a guy who is a teacher.
asserted
who → want → ?
It came up all the time as Mr. Joseph was pursuing his degree in education at Calgary’s Mount Royal University.
asserted
Joseph → come → University
Considering the demographics of the program, this was inevitable – he was one of only six male students in a graduating class of nearly 90.
asserted
he → consider → 90
He was close with three of the other guys, and they talked about it “all the time,” Mr. Joseph said.
asserted
Joseph → talk → it
“Growing up, none of us really had male elementary teachers, so we kind of bonded over that.
asserted
we → grow → that
There are only three other male teachers out of about 24 at the school he works at now, most of them older guys, and they also bring up this disparity, he said.
asserted
he → be → disparity
Many things drew him to the profession, Mr. Joseph said.
asserted
Joseph → draw → profession
His Grade 6 social studies teacher, a man who inspired his love of civics and made him want to spark that curiosity in other kids.
asserted
him → inspire → kids
“I teach in a predominantly white neighbourhood, so to have a male person of colour for a lot of these young boys, who unfortunately don’t have that male person of colour role model in their lives and don’t really see themselves in positions of leadership, I think is important,” he said.
asserted
he → teach → leadership
And society still views male teachers as outliers – in part because they are.
asserted
they → view → part
Women make up 84 per cent of kindergarten and elementary school teachers across both public and private institutions in Canada, according to the latest census data.
uncertain
Women → make → data
Male teachers are constantly talking amongst themselves about what’s behind those numbers – about why so few men enter the profession, and what that might mean for boys.
uncertain
that → talk → boys
It is increasingly important to have that conversation in public.
asserted
It → have → public
With jobs in many traditionally male-dominated industries disappearing and artificial intelligence throwing the future of so many other careers into uncertainty, teaching holds out the promise of a rewarding job less affected by those destabilizing forces.
asserted
teaching → dominate → forces
Recruiting more men to the field is one way of addressing that problem.
asserted
Recruiting → recruit → problem
Plus, statistics show many boys are struggling academically and socially.
asserted
boys → show → ?
They might just be in need of the sort of role models the best male teachers pride themselves on being.
uncertain
teachers → pride → themselves
The gender divide
There is an elephant in the room when it comes to investigating why more men aren’t going into teaching.
asserted
men → be → teaching
When I began contacting people to ask them why declining numbers of men are entering the field, and what that might mean for students, a discomfort slowly became apparent.
uncertain
discomfort → begin → students
Many men in education seemed averse to speaking publicly.
asserted
men → seem → education
Deans of education departments, men pursuing education degrees, teachers and even representatives from teachers’ organizations declined to speak on the record.
asserted
Deans → pursue → record
Most of the people who did agree to speak with me wanted to make it absolutely clear that saying it might be good for more young men to become teachers, and that it could benefit boys in classrooms, did not mean they weren’t also concerned about girls and women.
uncertain
they → agree → girls
They stressed that they weren’t saying female teachers aren’t great teachers, and they weren’t saying we should take focus away from doing more to break down barriers for women in male-dominated fields.
asserted
we → stress → fields
But they suggested, gently and with many caveats, that if representation matters in boardrooms and engineering firms and police forces and the skilled trades and so many other professional settings, then surely it matters in classrooms, too.
uncertain
it → suggest → classrooms
“It’s about having that equitable representation so that in any school community, every child can be known and seen and feel like they belong, and feel like they have an adult, whether it’s a male or female, Black or Asian or whoever it might be, that they can look at and say, ‘Hey, that person is what I need right now in my life,” said Blair Pike, associate director of education programs at Tyndale University in Toronto.
uncertain
Pike → ’ → Toronto
He added that this is especially true for the youngest kids in the system.
asserted
this → add → system
Ultan Peters, a 53-year-old in Edmonton, has gotten plenty of dismissiveness from friends and strangers alike over the years when they learn he is an elementary school teacher.
asserted
he → get → years
“It’s almost like they don’t think it’s honest work,” he said.
asserted
he → think → ?
“The investment and training versus the payoff and prestige is number one,” Mr. Peters added.
asserted
Peters → add → payoff
He has three degrees, including a master’s.
asserted
He → have → master
“If I were to put that across with any one of my friends with the same qualifications and same education, they’re making way more money.
asserted
they → put → money
But there’s another belief that underpins many people’s ideas of teaching – that, as a so-called pink-collar profession, it is a woman’s job.
asserted
it → ’ → profession
The stigma goes even further: Men who want to work with children are sometimes seen as inherently suspicious.
asserted
who → go → children
Male teachers are given the advice early to never be alone with a child behind a closed door.
asserted
teachers → give → door
Institutions have pointed out how harmful the disparity can be.
asserted
disparity → point → ?
In 2004, the Ontario College of Teachers, along with a handful of education leaders in the province, produced a report called Narrowing the Gender Gap: Attracting Men to Teaching.
asserted
College → produce → Teaching
“The disparity between the proportions of male and female teachers has accelerated, to the point that it has become a professional and public concern,” the authors wrote.
asserted
authors → accelerate → point
…and 84 more, not listed.