Being happily soon-to-be-married, I’ve made an effort to stay above the fray of the ever-simmering gender war in the online discourse.
asserted
I → marry → discourse
It makes men hate women and women hate men, and it is generally poisonous to our society, which has enough ills as it is.
asserted
it → make → ills
Alas, I got sucked into the battle this weekend when I came across an X post about “Hatchet,” the iconic young adult fiction novel in which 13-year-old Brian survives a plane crash in the wilderness and has to survive for nearly two months until his rescue.
asserted
Brian → suck → rescue
Netflix is adapting “Hatchet” into a movie, and that’s apparently made some people mad.
asserted
people → adapt → movie
A reporter I’ve never heard of named Katie Campione, whom I genuinely feel bad for and thus won’t be mean to, went semi-viral with the following take: “It’s not about if boys want to read Hatchet.
asserted
boys → hear → Hatchet
First of all, school reading lists are dominated by male authors and protagonists.
asserted
lists → dominate → authors
Second of all, it’s the presenting books in a gendered binary that is the problem.
asserted
that → ’ → binary
Maybe your son could stand to read some romantasy idk!!!!”
uncertain
son → stand → idk
I responded to Katie and got some traction of my own by pointing out that this is an exclusively white, liberal, and, critically, female phenomenon: No man, even the most liberal, effeminate, or even “queer,” has ever lamented that young girls don’t read enough military history or train books (or in my case, military train history books).
asserted
girls → respond → case
It’s only women who seem to want to bend young boys into the opposite gender, and I believe it’s because those particular women have a pathological hatred of men.
asserted
women → ’ → men
Luke Winkie won the husband of the year award by sharing that his wife thinks “Hatchet” is a “way to reach the hearts and minds of would-be incels” via a “story about a kid finding self-actualization with a weapon.”
asserted
kid → win → weapon
The reality is that the publishing industry has followed in the footsteps of the education system and become almost entirely feminized.
asserted
industry → follow → system
Schools cater to girls, and so do the books kids read in them.
asserted
kids → cater → them
The very same professional elites who complain about a crisis of illiteracy, particularly among men, are making it happen.
asserted
it → complain → men
I decided to examine Katie’s claim about school reading lists being dominated by male authors and protagonists.
uncertain
lists → decide → authors
In a shocking twist, it’s complete bull.
asserted
it → ’ → twist
The American Library Association’s 2026 Summer Reading List for grades 6-8, prime “Hatchet” years, contains 20 titles.
asserted
List → contain → titles
One of those four male protagonists is transgender-identifying, so make it three, in reality.
asserted
it → identify → reality
There are two transgender-identifying female authors and a “non-binary” one, and the remaining two are nonwhite.
asserted
two → be → ?
And believe it or not, these non-men aren’t writing books that sound particularly appealing to boys: “Scarlet Morning” is a pirate fantasy novel.
asserted
Morning → believe → boys
The protagonist of “A World Worth Saving” identifies as transgender.
asserted
protagonist → save → World
“Speak Up, Santiago!” is about a young boy feeling out of touch with the “Latine” community in New York because his Spanish isn’t good enough.
asserted
Spanish → speak → York
Orphaned siblings navigate the perilous landscape of neutral Iran as Axis and Allied forces converge there in 1941 in this poetic and gentle World War II story.”
asserted
forces → navigate → story
Too many of the people teaching our young boys, and deciding what gets written for them, are women who hate men.
asserted
who → teach → men
Surely there are plenty of women who don’t hate men who could do it instead.
uncertain
who → be → it
Even better, maybe there are some men out there who could help out.
uncertain
who → be → ?
Until then, let the young fellas read “Hatchet.”
asserted
fellas → let → Hatchet
It’s about the only thing they have left.
asserted
they → ’ → ?