Fires from lithium-ion batteries, which power ebikes and scooters, have become regular occurrences in New York, causing deaths and fear among residents, but the city has failed to build infrastructure that could reduce the threat.
uncertain
that → power → threat
New York has seen a dramatic uptick this year in fires from the batteries.
asserted
York → see → batteries
In late October, four members of a family, including an 11-year-old boy, died in a fire caused by a battery in an ebike that was in the pathway to an exit of an 11th floor apartment in a public housing building in the Bronx.
asserted
that → include → Bronx
Then recently in a fire at a home in Brooklyn, six people died and nine were injured, including three firefighters and two police officers.
asserted
nine → die → firefighters
Investigators discovered lithium-ion batteries at the scene but have not determined whether they caused the fire, the city council speaker, Julie Menin, said in a statement.
asserted
speaker → discover → statement
“The presence of lithium-ion batteries at the scene is a serious concern, and more must be done to encourage and mandate safe storage practices.
asserted
more → do → practices
Enough is enough,” Menin stated.
asserted
Menin → state → ?
London and Toronto have also recently seen a dramatic increase in lithium-ion battery fires, which are often caused by overcharging and defective or damaged batteries.
asserted
which → see → overcharging
Some of that trend is simply because ebikes, often used by food delivery workers and commuters, have become more popular.
asserted
ebikes → use → workers
But in New York, the city has not executed its plan to build outdoor charging stations which would prevent people from plugging in the batteries in their apartments, where an overheated or defective battery poses a greater risk, experts say.
asserted
experts → execute → risk
“There is a ton of red tape around this sort of new technology, and while it’s well intended to not let something new roll out too quickly, I think in this case, it is time to do something quickly,” said Laura Kavanagh, former commissioner of the FDNY.
asserted
Kavanagh → be → FDNY
In response to the increased usage and related increase in fires, the New York City department of transportation conducted a 2024 pilot in which it hired companies to offer battery-swapping cabinets where delivery workers could exchange exhausted batteries for charged ones.
uncertain
workers → increase → ones
The riders did more than 12,000 swaps over six months, and among participants, there was a 35% reduction in charging batteries at home, according to the city.
uncertain
riders → do → city
Following its success, the city announced that it would install 25 charging sites but not until 2027.
asserted
it → follow → 2027
The city first needed to “gather feedback on site selection, design and implementation”.
asserted
city → need → selection
In April, New York mayor Zohran Mamdani asked residents to provide feedback on where they would like the 25 cabinets.
asserted
they → ask → cabinets
The city planned to make them available in 2028, the announcement stated.
asserted
announcement → plan → 2028
In 2023, the city also announced that it received a $25m federal grant to build 173 electric-micromobility charging and storage stations at 53 public housing developments.
asserted
it → announce → developments
“This means that residents will no longer need to charge their ebikes in their apartments, what we find to be extremely dangerous,” Mayor Eric Adams said at the time.
asserted
Adams → mean → time
At the time, the deputy mayor, Meera Joshi, said residents would start “seeing evidence” of the stations in early 2024.
asserted
residents → say → 2024
Three years later, none have been built.
asserted
none → build → ?
Even though the Biden administration allocated the $25m for the infrastructure, the federal government has not actually provided the funds, according to the New York department of transportation.
uncertain
government → allocate → transportation
Asked why the process has moved slowly, a transportation department spokesperson stated in an email: “The city’s strategy to reduce the risk e-bike battery fires focuses on getting unsafe devices off our streets and providing safe and convenient e-bike charging options” and the “outdoor battery swapping cabinets will make charging safer and more accessible for the thousands of delivery workers who rely on these devices to serve New Yorkers.
asserted
who → ask → Yorkers
With the public feedback we gathered this summer, we’re finalizing locations for our public e-bike charging program before advancing to the design phase and remain on pace to launch the service in 2028”.
asserted
we → gather → 2028
Meanwhile, Popwheels, one of the companies in the successful pilot, has installed about 45 cabinets around the city, according to CEO Baruch Herzfeld.
uncertain
Popwheels → instal → Herzfeld
He wants to install hundreds more around the city but has been stymied by a permitting process that he describes as “ludicrous”.
asserted
he → want → that
He said it often takes six months for the city to approve one cabinet.
asserted
city → say → cabinet
“If I want to put a cabinet that they approve in a parking lot, I have to use an architect to do a drawing, and then they have to come and do an inspection of a drawing of an ebike battery cabinet in the parking lot,” Herzfeld said.
asserted
Herzfeld → want → lot
“This permitting process is why kids are dying.”
asserted
kids → die → ?
The city also often issues tickets to the owners of properties where Herzfeld has installed the cabinets, he said, for minor infractions like a fire extinguisher not having the proper tags or trash at the site.
asserted
extinguisher → issue → site
Amanda Farinacci, the FDNY deputy commissioner public information, stated in an email that the tickets were not for “minor infractions but instead significant concerns”.
asserted
tickets → state → infractions
“The FDNY has been very serious partners with the micro-mobility/charging cabinet industry, being very accessible and collaborative to achieve solutions,” Farinacci stated.
asserted
Farinacci → achieve → solutions
To conflate our regulatory responsibilities with causing people to charge their batteries indoors is entirely misplaced and inaccurate.”
asserted
people → conflate → batteries
Kavanagh, who spent a decade at FDNY before leaving in 2024, argued that the department is focusing on “too narrow of a concern”.
asserted
department → spend → concern
“I respect whatever concerns they have about the cabinet as real, but that is asking the wrong question,” said Kavanagh, who now works as a visiting urbanist at New York University.
asserted
who → respect → University
If “a battery failed in that cabinet outside, it is almost certain that would do no more than property damage.
asserted
that → fail → damage
You are comparing that to” 10 New Yorkers dying in fires in the last three weeks.
asserted
You → compare → weeks
“This is just appreciably worse, and so I think we need to frame it that way,” she added.
asserted
she → think → it
The latest fire may spur the city to expedite its approval process.
uncertain
fire → spur → process
On Friday, Menin announced that the city council would hold an emergency meeting on 20 November to conduct oversight to ensure the city is properly enforcing existing laws and that the public is educated on best fire safety practices and lithium-ion battery storage.
asserted
public → announce → practices
…and 2 more, not listed.