Between invitations to a Toronto Raptors game and a round of golf at one of Canada’s most exclusive courses, the lobbyist floated an idea to the Ford government staffer on a land development poised to reshape the Oakville skyline.
asserted
lobbyist → float → skyline
In a WhatsApp conversation in September 2022, John Mutton messaged the deputy chief of staff to Ontario’s housing minister about the province assigning a special designation to facilitate the development.
asserted
province → message → development
The private exchange took place more than a year and a half before the town was blindsided by the Ontario government’s decision to intervene on the project.
asserted
town → take → project
In designating the area as a Transit-Oriented Community (TOC), the province overrode Oakville’s vision for the land with a thicket of highrises that town staff have warned will provide “very little to no community benefit.”
asserted
staff → designate → benefit
Now, the revelation of the back-channel conversation has ignited the anger of local opponents to the controversial project who say the text exchange signals that the plans were on the government’s radar well before they were shared publicly.
asserted
they → ignite → radar
“We lost almost two years of time where the residents could have been vocal about it, instead of being surprised when the TOC was announced,” said Michael Reid, president of the Oakville Community Association.
uncertain
Reid → lose → Association
It has also renewed questions about why the province decided to champion a developer’s plan over the town’s.
asserted
province → renew → town
“It bothers me greatly,” said Oakville Councillor Janet Haslett-Theall.
asserted
Theall → bother → me
“Respect for the individuals that the public elected was not there.”
asserted
public → elect → that
Mutton is most recognizable by the moniker “Mr. X,” a pseudonym assigned to him in 2023 by the integrity commissioner for his role in the Greenbelt land swap scandal, in which Premier Doug Ford’s government was found to have given preferential treatment to certain developers with close ties to the Progressive Conservatives.
asserted
government → assign → Conservatives
The Oakville TOC, which has not yet broken ground, calls for 11 condo towers with a daycare and YMCA stuffed into an area roughly the size of the Rogers Centre.
asserted
which → break → Centre
The TOC designation allows for higher density near the Oakville GO train station, and the province deployed minister’s zoning orders (MZOs) to fast-track the project.
asserted
province → allow → project
The MZOs cannot be appealed.
asserted
MZOs → appeal → ?
The project has faced intense pushback from resident groups who allege it will benefit the developer, Distrikt Developments, at the public’s expense.
asserted
it → face → expense
Emil Toma, president of Distrikt, said the company made public zoning applications on the sites to the town “well in advance of the province advising its interest in selecting the area” for a TOC.
asserted
province → say → TOC
“While we have not been privy to all discussions between the Province and the Town, we do know the process was lengthy and thorough,” Toma said.
asserted
Toma → know → Province
Infrastructure Ontario (IO), the agency that manages the province’s TOC program, had no role in the Oakville GO TOC development prior to June 2023, a spokesperson told the Star.
asserted
spokesperson → manage → Star
“IO conducts TOC-related development discussions in accordance with conflict-of-interest policies and established oversight and approval processes,” said Brian Buchan, adding that the agency held public engagement sessions and solicited public feedback in its planning process.
asserted
agency → conduct → process
A transcript of the WhatsApp conversation between Mutton and Kirstin Jensen, then deputy chief of staff to the minister of municipal affairs and housing, is contained in a 2025 report by the integrity commissioner into Mutton’s unregistered lobbying on behalf of developers.
asserted
transcript → contain → developers
This version of the report was not publicly released.
asserted
version → release → report
The Star obtained a copy from Mutton, who said he wanted “truth to be told” about the Greenbelt land swap scandal, in which he says he was made a fall guy while major players weren’t held responsible.
asserted
players → obtain → which
The report was first reported by The Trillium.
asserted
report → report → Trillium
The integrity commissioner banned Mutton from lobbying the provincial government until April 2027 for his repeated and “serious” violations of lobbying rules.
asserted
commissioner → ban → rules
What the Mutton-Jensen texts reveal
asserted
reveal → reveal → What
In the 2022 WhatsApp exchange, Mutton invited Jensen to make use of his season’s tickets to the Raptors, telling her to “pick a game and you can come with me or take a friend.”
asserted
you → invite → friend
Mutton then pivoted to business.
asserted
Mutton → pivot → business
He explained that he was “PM ing” [project managing] for Distrikt in Oakville on matters of the parkland cash-in-lieu and transit-oriented communities, and wanted a “brief convo” about which direction “may be quickest.”
uncertain
direction → explain → convo
Jensen told Mutton that the Distrikt matter was “not going to be a quick solution” and “has to be a province wide solution.”
asserted
matter → tell → Mutton
Mutton told the Star that his conversation with Jensen about the Oakville land took place at the time when he was looking to project manage Distrikt’s land in Midtown Oakville with the goal to eventually work as a lobbyist for the project.
asserted
he → tell → project
Jensen, who is currently working at the Ontario Home Builders’ Association, did not respond to the Star’s questions.
asserted
who → work → questions
Mutton also provided copies of emails to the Star that showed Distrikt approached another client of Mutton’s who owned land in the same neighbourhood, in an attempt to band together to “preserve development land value” and “intensification potential.”
asserted
who → provide → value
Developer Emil Toma says his company Distrikt Developments is qualified to help build the transit-oriented community.
asserted
company → say → community
Developer Emil Toma says his company Distrikt Developments is qualified to help build the transit-oriented community.
asserted
company → say → community
Emails in August 2022 show Distrikt invited Mutton’s client to join them in lobbying the province to “immediately give attention to designating Midtown GO Node as a TOC” by way of an MZO.
asserted
Distrikt → show → MZO
Distrikt was also planning to meet with Metrolinx to discuss the plan and “align on objectives supporting intensification.”
asserted
Distrikt → plan → intensification
A Metrolinx spokesperson said the agency’s engagement with Distrikt “has been limited to standard adjacent development and safety related reviews and engagement as part of Town-led Midtown Oakville meetings.”
asserted
engagement → say → meetings
Metrolinx took part in no subsequent meetings with Distrikt related to the TOC.
asserted
Metrolinx → take → TOC
Mutton told the Star that shortly after he chatted with Jensen about the TOC status, he parted ways with Distrikt over “competing objectives” with his other client.
asserted
he → tell → client
He was never paid or formally retained by Distrikt, he added.
asserted
he → pay → Distrikt
Toma told the Star that Distrikt was introduced to Mutton by another landowner in the area, and his company never had any relationship with him.
asserted
company → tell → him
…and 17 more, not listed.