You’re reading The Weekly, a Saturday morning recap of the best Dispatch content of the week, with some additional commentary from Managing Editor Rachael Larimore.
asserted
You → read → Larimore
The only thing as sure as death and taxes is recrimination and upheaval for the losing party in the wake of a midterm loss.
asserted
thing → lose → loss
And we saw plenty of that this week.
asserted
we → see → that
On election night, as it became clear that the Democrats would take control of both the House and the Senate, President Donald Trump said he would not challenge the election results and even pledged to work with Democrats.
asserted
he → become → Democrats
In an interview recorded last Friday with Ross Douthat for 60 Minutes, he suggested he’d be open to an immigration deal.
uncertain
he → record → deal
But another move he made that same day called that into question.
asserted
he → make → question
Midterm losses typically give way to staffing shakeups, so it was unsurprising that White House chief of staff Susie Wiles resigned under pressure.
asserted
Wiles → give → pressure
But on Friday the president named deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller—the architect of Trump’s harsh immigration enforcement policy—to replace her.
asserted
Miller → name → her
What’s going on?
asserted
What → go → ?
Nick Catoggio tried to answer that question in Boiling Frogs, and the best he could come up with was that Trump may want to dangle immigration reform in front of the new Democratic majority in hopes of warding off investigations.
uncertain
Trump → try → investigations
But he’s also skeptical about that.
asserted
he → ’ → that
He writes:
The White House’s fash-y excesses will infuriate the left-wing base and make it impossible for likely Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Speaker Hakeem Jeffries to compromise with Republicans.
asserted
Schumer → write → Republicans
If there were even a small chance of the two parties avoiding all-out war over the next two years, Trump putting a “wartime consigliere” in charge of his operation presumably extinguished it.
asserted
putting → be → it
In Wanderland, Kevin Williamson dug into Miller’s reasoning for being so hostile to immigrants, suggesting that Miller’s sense of nostalgia for the postwar era reflects a certain kind of ignorance.
asserted
sense → dig → ignorance
He writes:
One of the things sentimental right-wingers have in common with sentimental progressives is an idiotically idealized view of the 1950s.
asserted
wingers → write → 1950s
Mr. Miller, poorly if expensively educated, may not be entirely familiar with what was actually going on in the United States in the halcyon 1950s and 1960s, but it is worth knowing that elite institutions such as Ivy League universities were still actively discriminating against Jews such as himself, for instance by limiting the enrollment of Jewish applicants to universities under the old numerus clausus system.
uncertain
institutions → educate → system
But Mr. Miller’s family was doing alright in those years, and maybe that is the point.
asserted
that → do → years
The Millers had advanced high enough up the ladder to start to think about pulling it up behind them.
asserted
Millers → advance → them
There weren’t any other major shakeups, but the fate of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth was up in the air early in the week.
asserted
fate → be → week
Reports emerged that Trump was consulting aides and advisers as to whether Hegseth should remain on the job given how much the Iran war had dragged down Republicans in the midterm, and given that the incoming Democratic majority might want to impeach the defense secretary.
uncertain
majority → emerge → secretary
But then it turned out that a potential impeachment wouldn’t wait for January.
asserted
impeachment → turn → January
Outgoing GOP Rep. Thomas Massie, who lost his primary back in May, had introduced articles of impeachment against Hegseth back in September, prompting Speaker Mike Johnson to declare a recess and send legislators home ahead of the midterms.
uncertain
who → lose → midterms
Massie reintroduced the articles on Monday.
asserted
Massie → reintroduce → Monday
Trump denounced the attempt that same day, and then on Tuesday gave Hegseth an “‘A’ PLUS, PLUS, PLUS” for giving a defiant press conference ahead of a vote.
asserted
Trump → denounce → vote
Later Tuesday, the House Republicans not named Massie banded together, voting to refer the impeachment articles to the Judiciary Committee, effectively tabling the effort.
asserted
Republicans → name → effort
Contributing writer Mike Nelson, a retired Army Special Forces officer, believes that Hegseth should be removed, but he took a few issues with the particulars of Massie’s case, which was based on violations of the War Powers Resolution of 1973 regarding the Iran war, Hegseth’s conduct in operations in Venezuela and Yemen, and his attempt to discipline Sen. Mark Kelly for telling military members that they should not follow illegal orders.
asserted
they → contribute → orders
Regarding Iran, Nelson noted, “it seems odd to target the person who may have conducted the illegal war rather than the person who ordered it—or at least without including him,” meaning Trump.
uncertain
who → regard → Trump
And he argued that the articles pertaining to Venezuela and Yemen amounted to policy differences between the administration and Massie, a longtime isolationist.
asserted
articles → argue → administration
He writes:
We should acknowledge that the soon-to-be-departing Massie is hardly a worthy vessel for the effort to hold Hegseth accountable.
asserted
Hegseth → write → effort
He is an isolationist who has tried to restrain the necessary use of American influence abroad, a conspiracy-monger who makes common cause with the craziest fever swamp dwellers, and a man who is far too willing to adopt antisemitic winks and nods.
asserted
who → try → winks
As Nebraska GOP Rep. Don Bacon pointed out, discussing his consideration of Massie’s resolution, there are myriad better complaints specific to Hegseth, including withholding approved aid and support to Ukraine and attempting to withdraw U.S. commitments to Europe without presidential knowledge.
asserted
Bacon → point → knowledge
But Massie no doubt wants more of that kind of withdrawal and hollowing of alliances.
asserted
Massie → want → alliances
Given Miller’s elevation, Hegseth’s survival, and the vote by the GOP House caucus to make combative Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan the House minority leader, Nick concluded the week was a giant “middle finger to the electorate.”
asserted
week → give → electorate
He wrote:
The White House is at war with Democrats—or, more precisely, with the historically lopsided popular majority that chose to put Democrats in charge of Congress last week.
asserted
that → write → Congress
As on Election Day 2020, so too on Election Day 2026: When Americans tell postliberals that they want their country to change course, postliberals’ reply is, and can only be, “f— you.”
asserted
reply → tell → course
By definition, an ideology that abhors accountability also abhors conciliation.
asserted
that → abhor → conciliation
With that, I’ll let you get to the rest of the highlights from the week.
asserted
you → let → week
Jonah Goldberg had a great G-File on Wednesday looking at the divisions between the Reaganites and the new right, Michael Warren looked at what might become of J.D. Vance’s 2028 aspirations, and we did not ignore the brewing scandal around now-former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang.
uncertain
we → have → Huang
All are featured below.
asserted
All → feature → ?
Thanks for reading and have a great weekend.
Every serious person understands that the main driver of the massacre was Donald Trump himself (which is not to say there are no unserious people who deny this obvious fact).
asserted
who → read → fact
…and 25 more, not listed.