Why is Alberta ditching diversity, equity and inclusion in hiring practices?
asserted
Alberta → ditch → practices
CBC’s West of Centre podcast finds division on the issue
The Alberta government says eliminating diversity, equity and inclusion from public sector hiring will make sure employers are using a merit-based system.
But is it addressing a genuine problem that needs solving?
asserted
that → find → problem
Or is it, as the Opposition NDP argues, political posturing?
asserted
NDP → argue → ?
CBC’s West of Centre spoke to experts and politics watchers who are split on the answer.
asserted
who → speak → answer
In a news conference last month, Premier Danielle Smith and Justice Minister Mickey Amery said the government's merit-based hiring bill is going to make the process more fair while ensuring the best-qualified candidates are selected.
asserted
candidates → say → conference
NDP Leader Naheed Nenshi has called the move a doubling down on the “culture war” that doesn’t address the priorities of voters.
asserted
that → call → voters
But the premier’s executive director, Bruce McAllister, posted on social media to describe scenarios where candidates are chosen for their race or sexuality rather than experience.
asserted
candidates → post → experience
“It’s racist.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
It is discrimination against straight people, white people, Chinese people, Christians,” part of the post reads.
asserted
part → read → post
Diversity, equity and inclusion is a framework that aims to promote fair treatment and participation for people of all walks of life.
asserted
that → aim → life
It’s commonly referred to as DEI or EDI for short.
asserted
It → refer → short
The Alberta bill would target hiring policies like one that was well-documented at the University of Alberta.
asserted
that → target → Alberta
It said if two candidates were equally qualified for a position, the hiring panels should favour the person from a historically underrepresented group.
asserted
panels → say → group
The university changed the policy last spring after a provincial panel recommended post-secondary institutions adopt a culture of greater neutrality.
asserted
institutions → change → neutrality
The bill is in addition to the “Peterson law,” also introduced by Smith and Amery last year, which eliminated mandatory DEI training from regulated professions.
asserted
which → introduce → professions
It was inspired by the 2022 sanctioning of author and academic Jordan Peterson by the psychology regulator in Ontario.
asserted
It → inspire → Ontario
A large-scale walking back of DEI commitments made headlines in January 2025 when U.S. President Donald Trump signed sweeping executive orders against equity programs.
asserted
Trump → make → programs
A number of major private American companies followed suit with their own rollbacks.
asserted
number → follow → rollbacks
Two years later, says Calgary-based DEI consultant Hagir Sail, there is a MAGA effect of quiet rollbacks happening — but plenty of resistance to DEI is homegrown.
asserted
plenty → say → DEI
“People, when they feel that life has become more difficult or don't have the same opportunities they used to have, they start pointing at the other,” Sail said.
asserted
Sail → feel → other
Sail pushes back against the Albera government’s narrative that DEI means lower standards in hiring decisions.
asserted
DEI → push → decisions
“It's irresponsible to think that biases and systemic barriers don't play a role in keeping people at a lower place than they are.”
asserted
they → think → place
What do voters think?
But is scrapping DEI something that most Canadians support?
asserted
Canadians → think → that
It depends how you ask the question.
asserted
you → depend → question
A Leger poll in 2024 suggested support has softened for DEI hiring in Canada.
uncertain
support → suggest → Canada
When asked if companies should take cultural background into account when hiring, 57 per cent of Canadian respondents said no, 28 per cent said yes.
asserted
cent → ask → respondents
But then when you ask Canadians more generally if they think the policies have a net positive impact on society or if DEI at work is a good thing, over 50 per cent say yes.
asserted
cent → ask → work
That’s from 2025 polling from Abacus and the Environics Institute.
asserted
That → ’ → Abacus
The Alberta Union of Provincial Employees has said that DEI hiring practices were never used in a way that would be unfair or encourage bias.
asserted
that → say → bias
Leela Aheer, a former UCP deputy leader and cabinet minister, spoke to CBC West of Centre host Kathleen Petty.
asserted
Aheer → speak → Petty
Aheer says DEI helps recruit the best people and this legislation is out of touch with voters who want unity.
asserted
who → say → unity
Leela Aheer, a former deputy leader and cabinet minister in Jason Kenney's UCP government, said rather than addressing a problem worth solving, the bill sends a worrisome message to some Albertans.
asserted
bill → say → Albertans
“Now you're campaigning on the backs of vulnerable people,” Aheer said.
asserted
Aheer → campaign → people
“And when it lands right after the referendum that told immigrants that their place here was up for a vote, what does that do to us as a province?”
asserted
that → land → province
Erika Barootes, a former principal secretary to Danielle Smith, said DEI policies were introduced to solve a problem but have ended up becoming one.
asserted
policies → say → problem
“We had good intentions, but that pendulum swung so damn far that now it's about correcting it.”
asserted
it → have → it
“And a lot of people are just like, ‘Thank goodness, someone's doing it.’”
asserted
someone → thank → it
Beyond Alberta
Smith isn’t alone in challenging the policy — freshly elected premiers coast to coast are showing a similar resistance to DEI.
Quebec’s Paul St-Pierre Plamondon has been critical of ‘wokeism,’ calling it anti-democratic.
asserted
Plamondon → challenge → it
Lorne Doerkson’s platform promised to “restore merit-based hiring across the public sector.”
asserted
platform → promise → sector
The debate has also been playing out quietly at the federal level.
asserted
debate → play → level
…and 5 more, not listed.