What does Carney’s investment summit mean for clean energy?
asserted
summit → mean → energy
Climate tech and clean energy projects feature heavily in deal book, but so do fossil fuels
While
asserted
fuels → feature → book
fossil fuel projects got more attention at Prime Minister Mark Carney's investment summit in Toronto this week — from the $35 billion-plus West Coast oil pipeline to the $28.5 billion Ksi Lisims LNG terminal — there was a lot of climate tech on the agenda as well.
asserted
projects → get → agenda
Energy storage, upgrading the electricity grid, nuclear projects and renewables like wind and solar were all sprinkled throughout the summit's deal book.
asserted
storage → upgrade → book
It's a throwback to Carney's career before he became prime minister when he spent years making a business case for climate-friendly policies in the global financial world, and could be a nod to what international investors increasingly want.
uncertain
investors → become → what
"What we've seen is that clean energy investment is roughly double that of fossil investment globally," said David Pickup, director of the electricity program at the Pembina Institute, an energy transition think-tank.
asserted
Pickup → see → Institute
Industry watchers hope bringing large investors to Canada can help boost interest in Canadian renewables and raise the billions of dollars that will be needed.
asserted
that → hope → dollars
But where the money will land is still unclear.
uncertain
land → land → ?
Climate advocates critical of summit
Even before it started, the summit attracted massive criticism from some of the most prominent voices in the climate movement.
asserted
summit → start → movement
David Suzuki, the longtime environmentalist and journalist, blasted the summit in an interview with the CBC, saying a financial system that does not see the environment as the source of its wealth is doomed.
asserted
that → blast → wealth
"Yeah, we have a crisis right now," Suzuki told the CBC’s David Common, referring to the current trade conflict with the U.S. which is driving Carney to diversify investment into Canada.
asserted
which → have → Canada
"But I don't think the solution is to call these people together and say, 'Look, invest in Canada, and we will continue the destruction of the biosphere that supports us.'
asserted
that → think → us
"
The investment opportunities include dozens of clean energy and climate tech projects, such as wind and solar farms, carbon capture facilities, electricity grid upgrades and energy storage.
asserted
opportunities → include → farms
But the issue is what else is getting pitched.
asserted
what → pitch → ?
"The No. 1 problem with [the investment summit’s] deal book is the amount of oil and gas projects that are proposed," said Richard Brooks, climate finance director at advocacy group Stand.earth.
asserted
Brooks → propose → Stand.earth
"It features $100 billion of new oil and gas projects that Mark Carney is seeking investment in."
asserted
Carney → feature → investment
Pickup pointed out that the recently-announced West Coast oil pipeline could be up to 90 per cent funded by the federal and Alberta governments, which the Pembina Institute says is a signal that it's a risky investment that may not end up paying off for taxpayers.
uncertain
that → point → taxpayers
It also shows that private investors are not as interested in fossil fuel projects.
asserted
investors → show → projects
"The trends are pretty clear globally that clean is the thing that people want to invest in and in particular, clean is the thing that private investment really wants to bring forward," Pickup said.
asserted
Pickup → want → that
After Carney's rollbacks on key climate policies, such as electric vehicle mandates and the consumer carbon tax, Canada is now more than 20 years behind on its climate targets, according to the latest analysis by the Canadian Climate Institute.
uncertain
Canada → accord → Institute
On the current course, Canada's emissions in 2050 will be 460 megatonnes of carbon, rather than the goal of net-zero emissions by 2050, a commitment enshrined in law.
asserted
emissions → enshrine → law
Investors consider Canadian renewables
Vittoria Bellissimo, president of the Canadian Renewable Energy Association (CanREA), says interest is growing in the Canadian clean energy sector.
asserted
interest → consider → sector
Her association hosted a finance summit back in May that attracted hundreds of investors and developers, and Canadian utilities are busy procuring renewable power to expand electricity production.
uncertain
utilities → host → production
"I think at a very high level, the message that ... is being communicated through this investment summit is that Canada is open for business and Canadian infrastructure is an area that looks attractive and is a stable investment," she said.
asserted
she → think → business
CanREA estimates that there's 25 gigawatts of installed solar, wind and energy storage capacity in Canada right now, a more than 50 per cent increase since 2020.
asserted
CanREA → estimate → 2020
That's enough to power about 18 million homes.
asserted
That → power → homes
And they’re tracking another 24 gigawatts that provinces are looking to procure in the future.
asserted
provinces → track → future
Bellissimo said bringing investors to Canada is important to get more interest flowing into some of these projects.
asserted
interest → say → projects
"All in, it's a $200-billion opportunity, and investors are sitting up and taking notice," Bellissimo said, pointing to the newly established major projects office and federal efforts to make project approvals easier.
asserted
approvals → sit → office
That's important because the federal government has an ambitious electricity plan, Pickup said, which aims to double electricity generation throughout the country by 2050 by using clean sources.
asserted
which → have → sources
“We're talking a big amount of investment that needs to go into our electricity system.
asserted
that → talk → system
And the real question here that I have is, is this investment that we're bringing for today, does it align with that?”
asserted
it → have → that
Pickup pointed to certain solar and wind projects in the investment summit’s deal book as positive signs.
asserted
Pickup → point → signs
But investment alone won't be enough; the government also has to come through with strong policies that will lead to both future supply and demand for this electricity, he said.
asserted
he → have → electricity
That includes things like an electric vehicle strategy that would lead to more clean electricity use in the transportation sector rather than gasoline, and speeding up home and building retrofits that will get fossil fuels out of Canadian homes.
asserted
fuels → include → homes
“So the question really becomes, you know, are we moving towards this future economy that Carney and others in the federal government talk about?”
asserted
Carney → become → government
The Aporia
