HMRC is set to receive sweeping new tax powers to seize cash from bereaved families, scour the AI chatbot history of taxpayers and slap huge fines on those who made inadvertent errors in documents, under changes quietly pushed through after the Budget.
asserted
who → set → Budget
Following John Healey’s maiden Autumn Budget a raft of new proposals were added the Finance Bill, dubbed ‘Budget Resolutions’, which survived the first reading on 3 November.
asserted
which → follow → November
While some resolutions centre on tax hikes discussed by Healey at the despatch box, including the hike to savings, property and income tax, others dramatically beef up the powers of the tax authority.
asserted
others → centre → authority
The shake-up to the system comes as HMRC aims to close the UK’s staggering tax gap.
asserted
HMRC → come → gap
According to the latest estimates from the government body, the shortfall cost the Treasury nearly £60bn in lost tax receipts during the 2024/25 financial year.
uncertain
shortfall → accord → year
Healey has pledged to close the gap, but as Labour’s manifesto prevents hikes to income tax, VAT and employee national insurance, the government is leaning on compliance and greater enforcement powers for HMRC to raise revenue.
asserted
government → pledge → revenue
Healey said restoring fiscal discipline was his “first commitment as Chancellor”, including “raising revenue from those who can afford to pay”.
asserted
who → say → those
Punishing tax mistakes
HMRC will introduce a statutory ‘Duty to Correct’ regime from April 2028, which will legally require taxpayers to rectify mistakes on old tax returns upon becoming aware of them.
asserted
which → punish → them
Currently, a mistake discovered after filing is treated by the authority as “careless” which carries a lower penalty of up to 30 per cent of the unpaid tax over six years.
asserted
which → discover → years
But the new regime will see an inaccuracy – even if unintentional – branded as “deliberate”, the term used by HMRC when it believes it is intentionally fed false figures or withheld information in order to pay less tax.
asserted
it → see → tax
It is the highest penalty tier for the authority, carrying a fine which can be up to 100 per cent and a scrutiny period of 20 years.
asserted
which → carry → years
The changes have raised concerns among tax barristers, who have called out the lack of minimum threshold on tax errors as well as the two-decade long window, as it clashes with statutory record-keeping rules for the self-employed.
asserted
it → raise → employed
They are only legally required to keep records for up to five to six years, meaning those facing a 20 year audit may be unable to produce needed receipts and bank statements.
uncertain
those → require → receipts
Fiona Fernie, partner at Blick Rothenberg, said: “This legislation needs clearer safeguards and a finite time limit for making corrections.
asserted
legislation → say → corrections
Otherwise, a measure intended to modernise compliance could undermine it.”
uncertain
measure → intend → it
An HMRC spokesperson said: “We know most of our customers act in good faith and want to get their tax right.
asserted
tax → say → faith
These changes make it quicker and easier for taxpayers to correct errors when we flag them.
asserted
we → make → them
“They won’t be penalised for innocent mistakes, and deliberate penalty charges only arise where taxpayers fail to take reasonable steps to correct an inaccuracy they were already aware of.
asserted
they → penalise → inaccuracy
Bereaved families hounded for longer
HMRC can currently demand information from the families of deceased taxpayers for up to four years after their death if they suspect they’ve paid the wrong amount of tax.
asserted
they → bereave → tax
This covers inheritance tax, capital gains tax and income tax.
asserted
This → cover → tax
Under Labour’s proposals, HMRC will be granted the right to demand information about the dead for an unlimited period, and the right to gather evidence for existing tax investigations that reach back up to 20 years.
asserted
that → grant → years
This could see families by the government years after an estate has been settled, which advisers have warned could lead to disputes among relatives or leave them buckled by tax bills they cannot afford to pay.
uncertain
they → see → bills
Draft legislation states HMRC will have to apply to a tax tribunal to send an information demand more than four years after death, but it will not be required to inform the executors of the estate, or the family, until after the tribunal has made a decision.
A government spokesperson said: “This does not mean new powers and will not affect the vast majority of taxpayers.
asserted
This → state → taxpayers
“The updates to HMRC’s existing information powers reflect how tax information is stored and processed digitally, and updates powers in line with the international standards of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.”
asserted
information → exist → operation
AI chatbot histories set to be snooped on
The tax authority will soon be able to view taxpayers’ messaging records with AI chatbots under new powers that will allow HMRC to probe digital records.
asserted
HMRC → set → records
HMRC currently has powers to request and obtain copies of digital “records” if it has a legitimate reason to do so to determine whether a taxpayer has paid the correct amount of tax.
asserted
taxpayer → have → tax
However, under the government’s newly proposed rules, the definition of digital information will be expanded to allow access to “relevant” digital records, which may include AI chatbots.
uncertain
which → propose → chatbots
The move will also require third parties, including software providers, to give HMRC people’s tax information if they hold it.
asserted
they → require → it
“Conversations between a taxpayer and their advisor are confidential and AI conversations should be treated in the same way, so without the right checks and balances HMRC’s new powers could cross the line between a legitimate investigation and overreach,” Praveen Gupta, head of tax at accountancy and advisory firm Azets, said.
uncertain
Gupta → treat → Azets
Gupta added it “cannot be one sided” and “robust safeguards around these powers will be critical”.
asserted
safeguards → add → powers
Doing so would allow people to “understand why they’re being investigated and that the information being requested is relevant and a reasonable request for HMRC to understand their tax affairs”.
asserted
HMRC → do → affairs
“Will individuals be able to request and be granted access to HMRC’s own internal notes and AI research into their tax affairs?
asserted
individuals → request → affairs
In the interests of fairness, they should be,” he said.
asserted
he → say → fairness
Matthew Greene, partner at Stewarts, said while HMRC accessing AI chat histories “could help uncover tax irregularities”, it “also risks dragging innocent taxpayers into unnecessary investigations.”
uncertain
it → say → investigations
“People may use AI to explore hypothetical tax arrangements without ever acting on them,” Greene said.
uncertain
Greene → use → them
“Human judgement is essential for distinguishing between honest mistakes and deliberate tax evasion, rather than treating AI conversations as proof of wrongdoing without considering the wider facts.”
asserted
judgement → distinguish → facts
“HMRC must stay within the law as requesting entire chat histories could expose sensitive personal or commercial details that have no bearing on someone’s tax affairs, opening the door to litigation over whether HMRC has exceeded its powers,” Greene added.
uncertain
Greene → stay → powers
An HMRC spokesperson said: “This is about updating our existing information powers to reflect how tax information is now stored and processed digitally.
asserted
information → say → powers
It is not about going through everyone’s use of large language models.
asserted
It → go → models
We can only request information where we already have a lawful basis to do so.”
asserted
we → request → basis
…and 14 more, not listed.