Accessing IVF, abortion or voluntary assisted dying (VAD) can be difficult and complicated.
asserted
Accessing → access → IVF
It can be harder still in rural and regional areas, where specialist shortages, long delays, distance and conscientious objection already limit access.
asserted
shortages → limit → access
That is why a Catholic provider's decision to stop offering these services at Newcastle Private hospital in regional New South Wales has alarmed many clinicians and the community.
asserted
decision → stop → clinicians
A local issue has exposed the potential for national implications.
asserted
issue → expose → implications
Calvary, a Catholic not-for-profit, is poised to take over 14 private hospitals from Healthscope, effectively doubling its private hospital network across the country.
asserted
Calvary → poise → country
Catholic providers already run about 6 per cent of Australia's public and private hospitals.
asserted
providers → run → hospitals
If the latest Calvary deal clears regulators, that footprint will grow, and so will doctors' fears that access to legal healthcare will shrink.
asserted
access → clear → healthcare
These healthcare services have long attracted irreconcilable world views.
asserted
services → attract → views
The debate now has moved beyond what should be lawful, to who decides what care should be available.
asserted
care → move → ?
The catalyst for the Calvary controversy was a Teams meeting held Wednesday before last.
asserted
catalyst → hold → last
Obstetricians and gynaecologists at Newcastle Private met with their incoming Calvary leadership team.
asserted
Obstetricians → meet → team
Most were stunned when they were informed that IVF, abortion, VAD, gender affirming care, contraception, vasectomies and tubal ligation — to prevent fertility — would all be off the table within a few weeks.
asserted
IVF → stun → weeks
The doctors had assumed they'd have time to negotiate terms or find a solution to keeping these services on the hospital site.
asserted
they → assume → site
They would also have to sign a document pledging to practise in line with the Code of Ethical Standards for Catholic Health and Aged Care Services in Australia.
asserted
They → have → Australia
The code calls abortion "morally wrong" and says procedures that substitute for the "marital act" are "not morally permissible".
asserted
that → call → act
Calvary has acknowledged the "concerns and uncertainty within the community" and, late on Friday, more information was provided on its website.
"Where a requested intervention cannot be offered, we remain committed to treating every person with dignity, providing clear information and supporting access to appropriate ongoing care …
asserted
we → acknowledge → care
Where a service is not offered, we will work with the treating specialist to support appropriate pathways."
asserted
we → offer → pathways
The push to separate religion from healthcare
The Catholic church has been unwavering in its teachings for hundreds of years.
asserted
church → separate → years
Even as arguments on issues such as IVF and abortion have shifted, its stance has remained constant.
asserted
stance → shift → IVF
The code that guides decision-making in Catholic hospitals describes itself, in its preface, as "a crucial resource for the Church's mission in health care".
asserted
that → guide → care
In practice, that means the church expects that its core and fundamental beliefs on sanctity of life and medical intervention should be upheld in a hospital setting.
asserted
beliefs → mean → setting
But critics say that approach can create more barriers to clinical care.
asserted
approach → say → care
IVF Australia's Dr Veronica Knight calls Calvary's latest decision, "discrimination based on religious ethos".
asserted
Knight → call → ethos
The Royal Australia and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RANZCOG) is framing the issues as a matter of access, not ownership.
asserted
College → frame → access
"We have no objection to Catholic ownership of hospitals," RANZCOG President Dr Nisha Khot told the ABC.
asserted
Khot → have → ABC
"What we're saying is that the law of the land says that all this health care is legal, and it should be available in every hospital.
asserted
it → say → hospital
It should not be defined by the faith of the organisation that owns the hospital.
asserted
that → define → hospital
"
The competition regulator recently cleared Calvary's takeover of Hobart Private Hospital, where reproductive health, gender-affirming care and VAD were also due to be wound back.
asserted
health → clear → Hospital
Dr Khot warned of scenarios "where the local public hospital and the private hospital are both Catholic", leaving no hospital access for reproductive sexual health care or voluntary assisted dying.
asserted
hospital → warn → care
Newcastle already offers a preview of what happens when VAD care meets a Catholic operator.
asserted
care → offer → operator
The region's only public hospice sits within a hospital already run by Calvary as a public-private partnership.
asserted
hospice → sit → partnership
The hospital does not allow patients to have VAD drugs administered on-site, so patients who choose VAD must be moved to another bed — in another location — to die on their own terms.
asserted
who → allow → terms
Newcastle Private and Hunter Valley Private, the two hospitals Calvary is set to take over, have been making beds available where possible.
asserted
beds → set → ?
If — or when — they stop offering that option, the pressure on health workers to find alternative beds will increase.
asserted
pressure → stop → beds
One VAD doctor, who cannot be named because of their contract with NSW Health, says the result could be waits that "blow out by several days".
uncertain
that → name → days
"There have already been cases where patients have been waiting for a couple of hours to transfer to another facility, in the final hours of their lives — sometimes in significant pain," the doctor said.
asserted
doctor → wait → pain
"And the longer they must wait, the risk is that patient loses the capacity to consent to taking the medication."
asserted
patient → wait → medication
Calvary's decision to end services at Newcastle Private and Hunter Valley Private would leave patients to rely on workarounds.
asserted
decision → end → workarounds
Clinicians typically go to great lengths to make those succeed, and most Newcastle patients will likely still get care, but with more administration, delay and frustration.
asserted
patients → go → administration
Delay comes with risks.
asserted
Delay → come → risks
…and 16 more, not listed.