In short:
Following a long-running legal battle, the Federal Court has ruled Lorella Springs' tourism permit invalid.
asserted
permit → follow → battle
Native title holders are claiming a "hard fought win", despite the court rejecting a number of their key arguments.
What's next?
asserted
What → claim → arguments
The permit has been set aside, with the Pastoral Land Board ordered to reassess the application "according to law".
uncertain
Board → set → law
Northern Territory native title holders are claiming a "hard fought win" after a Federal Court judge ruled a tourism permit for Lorella Springs Wilderness Park is invalid, and ordered the Pastoral Land Board to reassess the application.
asserted
permit → claim → application
For about two decades, the owners of Lorella Springs, a 400,000-hectare outback cattle station located about 1,000 kilometres from Darwin, ran a significant tourism business with accommodation, a bar, fishing, swimming and helicopter tours.
asserted
owners → locate → accommodation
The station, about 2.5 times the size of London, is also home to protected sacred, burial and ceremony sites.
asserted
station → protect → sites
But the station has been closed to most tourists since January 2023.
asserted
station → close → January
Only a select number of guided tours have been allowed to visit, with the owners citing "bureaucracy" becoming "too much" to sustain operations.
asserted
bureaucracy → guide → operations
In 2022, owners Marie and Rhett Walker lodged an application for a "farm tourism operations" permit.
asserted
Walker → lodge → permit
Their application said Aboriginal sites would "be avoided from all tourism activity".
asserted
sites → say → activity
The owners also applied to extract water from Rosie Creek.
asserted
owners → apply → Creek
The Pastoral Land Board granted the permit and the water licence — but in 2025, the Northern Land Council (NLC), on behalf of Burdal Riley, Murrungun Wunubari and Mambali Walangara native title holders, challenged the NT government's decision to grant those.
asserted
Council → grant → those
Concerned that sacred sites in the area had been interfered with in the past, the native title holders argued the tourism activities involved the "observation of Aboriginal cultural works and activities".
asserted
activities → interfere → works
They also argued the government had been "unreasonable and irrational" in its decision-making process and failed to consider the presence of threatened species and other environmental issues.
asserted
government → argue → species
In handing down her lengthy judgement on Friday, Justice Natalie Charlesworth considered the native title holders' 12 arguments.
asserted
Charlesworth → hand → arguments
She found that when the Pastoral Land Board ultimately approved a permit covering about 60,000 hectares — an area far larger than what was applied for — it "exceeded its jurisdiction".
asserted
it → find → jurisdiction
"The circumstances in which that came about are not at all clear," she said.
asserted
she → come → which
She also found there had been no comprehensive environmental impact assessment done of the entire area and that the board "failed to comply with its obligation to afford procedural fairness" to native title holders.
asserted
board → find → holders
Justice Charlesworth declared the permit invalid largely on those points, and ordered the board to reassess the application "according to law", which means a new permit could be issued in future.
uncertain
permit → declare → future
Some arguments rejected
asserted
arguments → reject → ?
The native title holders also argued the permit did not qualify as "farm tourism" under section 24GB of the Native Title Act, as there was "no substantive connection to pastoral activities".
asserted
permit → argue → activities
Justice Charlesworth said she was informed the matter was the first time a court had been forced to consider the section — which allows certain activities like farm tourism or running cattle to go ahead on pastoral land without agreement from native title holders, but rules out other types of tourism involving observing Aboriginal activities or cultural works.
asserted
activities → say → activities
She noted there was "public interest in the resolution of the issue given the likelihood that it may arise again", with large swathes of the NT and South Australia covered by pastoral leases.
uncertain
swathes → note → leases
However, Justice Charlesworth rejected the argument, finding the activities on offer at Lorella Springs "all fall within the phrase 'farm tourism activities'."
asserted
activities → reject → phrase
The native title holders also argued the permit was invalid because it permitted "tourism activities that involved observing the activities or cultural works of Aboriginal people".
asserted
that → argue → people
Justice Charlesworth "unreservedly" accepted evidence about the "hurt and distress" felt by native title holders over how tourism at Lorella Springs could impact sacred sites, but ultimately dismissed that argument as well.
uncertain
tourism → accept → argument
"The focus of [section] 24GB is upon what has been authorised by the Board, not upon what may happen in the future by reason of feared unauthorised actions of the [owners] or tourists," she said.
uncertain
she → authorise → owners
Justice Charlesworth upheld the water licence, ruling she was not satisfied it would affect native title because there was no evidence the amount of water extracted would affect native title holders' ability to take water.
asserted
amount → uphold → water
NLC chair Matthew Ryan called the judgement a "hard fought win" for native title holders.
asserted
Ryan → call → holders
"Protecting sacred sites is protecting culture.
asserted
Protecting → protect → culture
It is always necessary to work with the caretakers of precious country to keep these sacred areas safe," he said.
asserted
he → work → areas
A spokesperson for the NT government did not respond to questions about whether Lorella Springs would re-open in the future but said it "will take the time to carefully consider the Federal Court's decision."
asserted
it → respond → decision