Secret votes, coloured ballot papers, straw polls and backroom efforts to force a consensus — with the threat of powerful vetoes hanging over it all.
asserted
threat → force → it
These could be the contours of how boards of mubil-billion dollar corporations decide on contentious issues.
uncertain
boards → decide → issues
It’s also the way the United Nations picks its secretary-general, the person at the apex of a vast and sprawling machinery tasked with upholding fast-fraying international laws and practices.
asserted
Nations → ’ → laws
Why has Africa’s Security Council reform push remained unresolved?
asserted
push → remain → ?
UN chief Antonio Guterres tests the limits of quiet diplomacy
asserted
Guterres → test → diplomacy
That process is now barrelling towards a tense climax, with the UN Security Council holding multiple straw polls in a bid to select its new secretary-general by December 31, when incumbent Antonio Guterres must step down.
asserted
Guterres → barrel → December
The UNSC recommends a candidate who gets nine votes without a veto from its five permanent members.
asserted
who → recommend → members
The process ends after the UN General Assembly (UNGA) gives its seal of approval to that candidate.
asserted
Assembly → end → candidate
Here’s what we know:
Who chooses the secretary-general?
asserted
Who → ’ → general
In effect, the 15-member UNSC chooses the UN chief.
asserted
UNSC → choose → chief
The council has five permanent members – China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom, and the United States – who hold veto power.
asserted
who → have → power
Ten elected non-permanent members also make up the council.
asserted
members → elect → council
Bahrain, Colombia, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Denmark, Greece, Latvia, Liberia, Pakistan, Panama, and Somalia are the current UNSC members — non permanent members are elected by rotation every two years.
asserted
members → elect → rotation
According to Article 97 of the UN Charter, the UNSC decides on a candidate and recommends them to the UNGA for a vote by all members.
uncertain
UNSC → accord → members
There has never been a time when the council has picked a candidate who was voted down by the assembly, meaning that while, in theory, everyone has a say, the assembly have never gone against the 15-member security council.
asserted
assembly → pick → council
And because the five permanent members wield a veto, the secretary-general in effect is chosen by them, once they’ve convinced the non-permanent members.
asserted
they → wield → members
However, one time, in 1950, the UNGA voted to extend the term of the then secretary-general without the UNSC’s recommendation after a deadlock in the council.
asserted
UNGA → vote → council
How does the Security Council make its choice?
asserted
Council → make → choice
The council holds informal, anonymous polls, also known as straw polls, on whether the members “encourage”, “discourage”, or “have no opinion” about a candidate.
asserted
members → hold → candidate
Although it is expected to be secret, the number of encourage, discourage, or no-opinion votes is often leaked.
asserted
number → expect → votes
In later rounds of voting, coloured paper ballots are used to distinguish between the UNSC’s permanent members and the 10 elected members, providing a clearer sense of where members are leaning.
Once a straw poll confirms that a candidate has at least nine “encourage” votes and no vetoes against them, the council holds a formal vote to recommend them to the UNGA, which is expected to endorse that nomination.
asserted
which → use → nomination
Jane Kinninmont, CEO of United Nations Association UK, an independent, non-governmental organisation, explained that the process to select a candidate has traditionally been “closed and secretive” but has become more open as a result of campaigning by civil society groups and member states.
“However, the Security Council continues to guard its secrecy tightly – part of a political culture that many other countries regard as outmoded,” Kinninmont told Al Jazeera.
“One of the stated reasons is that no country wants to have a situation where it votes for one candidate, but another candidate actually is appointed and resents them for not voting for them,” she said.
asserted
she → explain → them
Al Jazeera’s UN correspondent, Gabriel Elizondo, also explained that the secrecy behind the selection was just due to the way the system was set up.
asserted
system → explain → way
“Now, there have been some talks in recent years, including this year, about trying to make the process more transparent in the Security Council, but the five permanent members just want to keep it the way that it is,” he said.
asserted
he → include → it
Eight candidates are currently running to become secretary-general, after some dropped out earlier in the race.
asserted
some → run → race
Two leading candidates are IAEA chief Grossi from Argentina and Costa Rican Rebeca Grynspan, the UNCTAD head.
asserted
candidates → lead → Argentina
Grynspan, who, if successful, could become the first woman and first Jewish person to lead the UN, played a key role in brokering the Black Sea Grain Initiative between Russia and Ukraine in 2022.
uncertain
who → become → 2022
The deal allowed for millions of tonnes of food to be exported from war-torn Ukraine, much of which went to developing nations.
asserted
much → allow → nations
Grossi has headed the UN nuclear agency since 2019, and has been at the centre of the UN’s efforts to prevent nuclear escalations between Russia and Ukraine, amid their ongoing war.
asserted
Grossi → head → war
But Grossi has also faced criticism, especially from Iran, over perceptions that some of his reports critiquing Tehran’s nuclear programme helped serve as pretext that the US and Israel used to attack Iran.
asserted
US → face → Iran
The other candidates include:
- Maria Fernanda Espinosa Garces (Former UNGA chief, Ecuador)
- Lana Zaki Nusseibeh (UAE minister of state at the Foreign Ministry )
- Feridun Hadi Sinirlioglu (Organization for Security and Co-operation chief, Turkiye)
- Carolyn Rodrigues Birkett (Guyana’s ambassador to the UN)
- Ivonne A-Baki (Politician, Ecuador)
- Olara Otunnu (Politician, Uganda)
What’s happened in the 2026 straw polls so far?
Eight polls have been held so far, but no consensus has emerged on a candidate who has received no discouraging votes.
asserted
who → include → votes
According to the 1 for 8 Billion campaign, supported by organisations and individuals worldwide to call for a fair, open, and inclusive selection process for Guterres’s job, the eighth poll had Grynspan leading.
uncertain
Grynspan → accord → job
Last week’s poll saw Grynspan receive 12 encourage votes and three discourage votes.
asserted
Grynspan → see → votes
In second place, Grossi received nine encourage votes, four discourage votes, and two no-opinion votes.
asserted
Grossi → receive → votes
He was followed by Birkett, who received eight encourage votes, five discourage votes, and two no-opinion votes.
asserted
who → follow → votes
While it is unclear how the permanent members voted and whether any had used a veto, candidates need zero discourage votes from them to secure the nomination.
uncertain
candidates → vote → nomination
According to Kinninmont, there is “growing resentment” about the five permanent members of the council using their vetoes that have often led to a paralysed council.
uncertain
that → accord → council
“The appointment of the SG is a different issue from any single conflict, but ultimately this person is supposed to be the world’s leading defender of the UN Charter and a spokesperson for the peoples of the world, in whose name the charter is written,” she said.
asserted
she → suppose → world
“Thus, it seems hard to defend the idea that any single power should be able to veto a candidate even if that candidate has the support of the majority of other countries on the Security Council and indeed a majority of the countries in the world.”
asserted
candidate → seem → world
On more powers for the General Assembly in the selection process, Elizondo said that while there is talk of reforming the system, it would mean the permanent members would have to give up some of their power.
asserted
members → say → power
…and 11 more, not listed.