A long-awaited pact between the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and China for a “code of conduct” in the disputed South China Sea is unlikely to materialise during the regional bloc’s annual gathering of leaders in Manila this week, analysts and officials say.
asserted
analysts → await → Manila
The agreement would aim to manage tensions and prevent conflict at sea.
asserted
agreement → aim → sea
But talks have dragged on for more than 20 years.
asserted
talks → drag → years
In 2023, foreign ministers agreed to work towards finalising the accord within three years.
asserted
ministers → agree → years
That deadline fell on 2026 – the year the Philippines took its turn as chair of ASEAN.
asserted
Philippines → fall → ASEAN
Under its leadership, the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) said negotiators have met at least once a month.
asserted
negotiators → say → Affairs
But they have fallen short of arriving at a consensus ahead of the summit.
asserted
they → fall → summit
“I just want to say that at this point in time, 80 percent of the document itself is finished,” DFA Secretary Maria Theresa Lazaro said on Saturday, adding that there are some ‘salient’ points that still need to be ironed out.
She has previously said that geographical scope is one of the contentious issues.
asserted
scope → want → issues
Beijing insists it has jurisdiction over nearly the entire South China Sea despite a 2016 international ruling invalidating that claim.
uncertain
it → insist → claim
The Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and Indonesia also have overlapping territorial claims.
uncertain
Philippines → have → claims
The Philippines would also like the accord to respect the rights of countries outside the region, according to DFA spokesman Dominic Xavier Imperial.
uncertain
accord → like → Imperial
Half of the world’s merchant ships pass through the South China Sea.
asserted
Half → pass → Sea
But the country may be caught between a rock and a hard place.
uncertain
country → catch → rock
“You can’t win it because if you get a good document, you’ll be accused of railroading or it would come across as self-serving.
asserted
it → win → railroading
But if it’s a bad document, the Marcos Jr administration will be seen as a weak government,” Aries Arugay, a political scientist at the University of the Philippines, said.
asserted
Arugay → ’ → Philippines
China has consistently accused the United States and its allies, who regularly conduct freedom of navigation operations with the Philippines, of interference.
asserted
who → accuse → interference
Tensions between Manila and Beijing have escalated since Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr took office in 2022.
asserted
Jr → escalate → 2022
The China Coast Guard has repeatedly deployed water cannon against Philippine vessels and maritime confrontations have resulted in collisions and, on one occasion, a Filipino soldier losing a finger.
asserted
confrontations → deploy → finger
In recent weeks, the two countries have been engaged in a war of words.
asserted
countries → engage → words
In September, Philippine Defence Secretary Gilberto Teodoro’s public response to a handwritten note rejecting the 2016 South China Sea ruling – reportedly from Beijing’s military attache in Seoul – went viral.
uncertain
response → reject → Seoul
“Perhaps basic decency and behaviour is what China needs to do,” Teodoro, who has been barred from entering China, said.
asserted
who → need → China
A month later, Beijing’s ambassador to Manila, Jing Quan, told reporters that if China wanted to use force, “we may easily win.
uncertain
we → tell → force
But no, we will not choose force.
asserted
we → choose → force
We love peace”.
asserted
We → love → peace
The statement was made in response to a question about Teodoro calling China a “troublemaker”, but which Marcos said “sounded like a threat”.
asserted
Marcos → make → threat
What followed was a barrage of social media posts by Philippine officials criticising Jing, with the Chinese embassy replying in kind.
asserted
embassy → follow → kind
Senators called for the expulsion of the Chinese envoy.
asserted
Senators → call → envoy
And, in late October, China accused Teodoro of a late invitation to the ASEAN defence ministers’ meeting in Cebu.
asserted
China → accuse → Cebu
Without ample time to prepare, it said it could only send its Manila-based defence attache.
uncertain
it → prepare → attache
“When that happened, I think the concern, especially on the part of the DFA, was, ‘We don’t want China not sending their premier.
asserted
China → happen → premier
It would not look good on us as a host country,’” Lucio Pitlo, past president of the Philippine Association for Chinese Studies, said.
asserted
Pitlo → look → Studies
With just days before world leaders were due to arrive in Manila, diplomats from both sides stepped in.
asserted
diplomats → arrive → sides
In a phone call, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi told Lazaro, his Philippine counterpart, to rein in politicians.
asserted
Yi → tell → politicians
“The Philippines should strengthen restraint over the relevant individuals and send a rational and unified voice on its policy toward China,” Wang said in a statement released by the Chinese embassy in Manila.
asserted
Wang → strengthen → Manila
Lazaro described the conversation as having been “frank and constructive”.
asserted
Lazaro → describe → conversation
However, the DFA followed up with a statement saying it found public commentary by certain government officials “regrettable”.
asserted
commentary → follow → officials
“Whatever personal convictions public officials may hold, their public platforms carry institutional responsibilities,” it said.
uncertain
it → hold → responsibilities
“They may not pursue preferred approaches toward China, or any other international partner, without regard for the consequences on the government’s overall policy.”
uncertain
They → pursue → policy
‘Airing dirty laundry’
Some analysts say the spat has further exposed division within the Marcos administration.
asserted
spat → air → administration
“They’re airing dirty laundry out there.
asserted
They → air → laundry
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
