A Missouri Court of Appeals has upheld most of a jury’s decision against a licensed therapist who became sexually involved with a woman during her counseling sessions, but it has removed $1 million in punitive damages from the judgment.
asserted
it → uphold → judgment
The case, Anita Karase v. Craig Politte, was decided on November 10, 2026, and centres on allegations that Craig Politte exploited the therapeutic relationship with Anita Karase, a woman he had initially counselled alongside her husband, as mentioned on Justia U.S Law's website.
asserted
he → decide → website
The appeals court affirmed the jury’s findings on medical negligence, battery, and a violation of the Missouri Merchandising Practices Act.
asserted
court → affirm → Act
It reversed only the negligence per se claim, which had carried the $1 million punitive award, because it found that Missouri’s counselor ethics regulations do not create a separate private cause of action for that type of claim.
uncertain
regulations → reverse → claim
How the relationship began
According to the court record, Politte began counselling Karase’s husband in 2018 through his private practice, Life Counseling Centers.
uncertain
Politte → begin → practice
He later provided couples therapy to Karase and her husband, then began seeing Karase individually.
asserted
He → provide → Karase
The court found that Politte did not discuss the potential conflict created by simultaneously providing couples and individual counseling to the same couple.
asserted
Politte → find → couple
Karase also did not sign an informed consent form before beginning therapy.
asserted
Karase → sign → therapy
After several individual sessions, Karase told Politte she was attracted to him.
asserted
she → tell → him
Physical contact between them intensified during sessions and eventually led to sexual acts, including intercourse.
asserted
contact → intensify → intercourse
What the court found
The jury found in Karase’s favour on all four counts.
asserted
jury → find → counts
It awarded her $1,135,120 in compensatory damages and $1 million in punitive damages, for a total judgment of more than $2.1 million, as per the record.
asserted
It → award → record
The jury assigned 99 percent fault to Politte and 1 percent fault to Karase on the medical negligence claim.
uncertain
jury → assign → claim
On the negligence per se claim, it assigned 100 percent fault to Politte.
uncertain
it → assign → Politte
Karase’s expert witness, licensed psychologist Dr. Catherine Hassler, testified that Politte breached the standard of care by treating both Karase and her husband and by failing to refer Karase to another counselor when she disclosed feelings for him.
asserted
she → testify → him
The court record notes that Politte admitted his conduct fell below the standard of care and that the sexual acts were intentional and harmful.
asserted
acts → note → care
Representative image from Canva
Why the punitive damages were removed
The appeals court’s decision to strike the $1 million punitive award came down to a legal distinction.
asserted
decision → remove → distinction
The jury had found Politte liable for negligence per se, a claim based on the argument that he violated specific professional regulations.
uncertain
he → find → regulations
But the appeals court held that Missouri’s counselor ethics regulations do not create a private cause of action that can support a negligence per se claim.
uncertain
that → hold → claim
In other words, while the regulations may justify professional discipline, they do not automatically give a client the right to sue for damages under that particular legal theory.
uncertain
they → justify → theory
Because the punitive damages were tied to that count, the court reversed that portion of the judgment and remanded the case for further proceedings.
asserted
court → tie → proceedings
The rest of the jury’s verdict, including the compensatory damages, was affirmed.
asserted
rest → include → damages
It involves a woman who sought therapy during a difficult period in her life and later said she felt exploited by the person she trusted to help her.
asserted
she → involve → her
Karase told the court that she sought therapy with three other providers after the relationship ended, paying between $125 and $250 per session.
asserted
relationship → tell → session
She said she will need long-term mental health care because of the harm she experienced.
asserted
she → say → harm
The court also noted that Karase and her husband were in divorce proceedings by the time the relationship came to light.
asserted
relationship → note → light
Karase initially resisted identifying Politte to her husband, hoping to protect him, before eventually disclosing what had happened.
asserted
what → resist → him
Representative image from Canva
What happens next
asserted
What → happen → Canva
The appeals court’s ruling narrows the financial outcome but does not erase the jury’s finding that Politte was responsible for the harm Karase suffered.
asserted
Karase → narrow → harm
The compensatory damages remain in place, and the case will return to the lower court for further proceedings on the reversed count.
asserted
case → remain → count
The decision also clarifies an important legal boundary in Missouri.
asserted
decision → clarify → Missouri
Professional ethics rules can lead to license discipline, but they do not necessarily create an independent path for a negligence per se lawsuit unless the legislature has clearly intended that result.
asserted
legislature → lead → result
For patients, the case is a reminder that the therapeutic relationship carries a duty of care.
asserted
relationship → carry → care
For counselors, it underscores that crossing professional boundaries can have consequences that extend beyond licensing boards and into the civil courts.
asserted
that → underscore → courts