A Kentucky man who hired an estate agent to sell his first house later bought a property owned by that same agent for $300,000.
asserted
who → hire → 300,000
He now says he was pressured to pay an extra $85,000.
asserted
he → say → 85,000
That fight has led to a partial win at the Kentucky Court of Appeals.
asserted
fight → lead → Appeals
In a decision released on November 13, the appeals court brought back most of Jason Wagner's legal claims against estate agent Rick Walters and Lenihan Real Estate.
uncertain
court → release → Walters
This allows the case to go back to a lower court.
asserted
case → allow → court
The case focuses on three key issues: whether Walters properly shared that he owned the second house, how the extra payment was set up, and whether his real estate company can be held responsible.
asserted
company → focus → house
How the two property deals began
asserted
deals → begin → ?
According to the Kentucky Court of Appeals' ruling, Wagner met Walters in January 2024 after a shared friend suggested the agent.
uncertain
friend → accord → agent
Wagner wanted to sell his house on Stable Springs Drive in Louisville.
asserted
Wagner → want → Louisville
He had never sold a home before.
asserted
He → sell → home
Walters worked for Lenihan Real Estate and also offered to help Wagner find a new place to live.
asserted
Wagner → work → place
On January 24, 2024, Wagner hired Walters to sell his current home.
asserted
Wagner → hire → home
That very same day, Wagner signed a contract to buy a house on Whipps Mill Road that Walters personally owned.
asserted
Walters → sign → that
Wagner later said he thought the house belonged to Walters' aunt, who had moved into an assisted living facility.
asserted
who → say → facility
He also stated that Walters told him fixing up the house could greatly raise its value.
uncertain
fixing → state → value
Wagner's first home was put on the market in February 2024 and sold just five days after being listed.
asserted
home → put → February
The sale wrapped up in March.
asserted
sale → wrap → March
According to court documents, the written contract for the Whipps Mill house listed the sale price as $300,000.
uncertain
contract → accord → 300,000
Wagner paid that full amount by personal cheque at the closing.
asserted
Wagner → pay → closing
He later claimed Walters asked for another $85,000, saying his wife was not happy with the first price.
asserted
wife → claim → price
Wagner said he was new to buying and selling houses and felt pushed into paying the extra money.
asserted
he → say → money
He thought it was just a normal part of buying a home.
asserted
it → think → home
Walters told a different story during his sworn testimony.
asserted
Walters → tell → testimony
He claimed Wagner had agreed to pay $385,000, but only had $300,000 ready at the start.
asserted
300,000 → claim → start
According to Walters, the extra $85,000 was covered by a written payment promise for his aunt's furniture and tools left inside the house.
uncertain
85,000 → accord → house
He said Wagner paid off that balance after his first home sold.
asserted
home → say → balance
The appeals court pointed out that the written house contract still listed the price as $300,000.
asserted
contract → point → 300,000
The contract also stated that any changes to the deal had to be put in writing.
asserted
changes → state → writing
The court found no written update showing the house price rose to $385,000, or explaining how the extra payment was split up.
asserted
payment → find → 385,000
Public property records also showed the sale price as $300,000.
asserted
records → show → 300,000
Walters personally took the extra $85,000 in March 2024, while Lenihan Real Estate got none of that cash.
asserted
Estate → take → cash
Wagner says he suffered a financial loss
Wagner later claimed he found out Walters personally owned the Whipps Mill house, not his aunt.
asserted
Walters → say → house
He also said Walters suggested the house could be worth $485,000 after repairs.
uncertain
house → say → repairs
Wagner stated he finished the updates, but ended up selling the home at a $35,000 loss instead of making the expected $100,000 profit.
asserted
he → state → profit
In January 2025, Wagner filed a lawsuit against Walters and Lenihan Real Estate.
asserted
Wagner → file → Walters
His claims included breaking a duty of trust, wrongfully taking money, working together to commit a wrong, and careless false statements.
uncertain
claims → include → wrong
He also asked the court to cancel the disputed sale.
asserted
He → ask → sale
Walters denied acting as Wagner's estate agent during the second house sale.
asserted
Walters → deny → sale
He claimed he sold his own home privately.
asserted
he → claim → home
Lenihan Real Estate also denied any blame.
asserted
Estate → deny → blame
…and 31 more, not listed.