Two years ago, residents of Oakland, California, woke up to a shocking scene: their mayor’s home was being raided by the FBI.
asserted
home → wake → FBI
Agents were seen carrying dozens of boxes from the hilltop home of Sheng Thao, the city’s 38-year-old leader, as part of an investigation constituents would later learn alleged her participation in a pay-to-play scheme with the city’s recycling contractor.
asserted
constituents → see → contractor
It was a stunning moment for Thao, who was elected to lead the Bay Area city in 2022 and was once seen as a promising young mayor in a city that has long grappled with economic inequality and a reputation for violent crime.
asserted
that → elect → crime
Her story of growing up in a refugee family and overcoming domestic violence and homelessness to become the first person of Hmong descent to run a major US city resonated with readers confronting questions about equity and representation that came to the fore during the Covid-19 pandemic, and made her the subject of glowing media profiles.
asserted
her → grow → profiles
As mayor, Thao revived the city’s Ceasefire violence-reduction strategy and brought in a much-needed infusion of revenue through the sale of the Oakland Coliseum sports complex.
asserted
Thao → revive → complex
At the time of the raid she was already facing a heated recall campaign grounded in her perceived failure to address the city’s mounting public safety and homelessness crises – one that would see her ousted from office in November 2024.
asserted
her → face → November
Two months later, Thao was indicted on federal corruption charges, and eventually replaced by longtime progressive congresswoman Barbara Lee in a special election.
asserted
Thao → indict → election
Now, Oakland is anxiously watching the final chapter in this political drama unfold as Thao and three co-defendents stand trial over the alleged bribery scheme.
asserted
Thao → watch → scheme
Having just concluded its fifth week of hearings, the case is rich with soap-opera-esque plot points, from an alleged beating at a recycling company’s headquarters to text threads in which co-defendants celebrated the plot that would make them “$100 million dollars richer” and touted that “money buys everything”.
asserted
money → conclude → everything
Proceedings are expected to conclude later this month, with Thao facing six federal counts in total.
asserted
Thao → expect → total
If found guilty, she could face up to 20 years in prison.
uncertain
she → find → prison
To the frustration of other witnesses, Thao, who has a constitutional right not to testify, has yet to take the stand.
asserted
who → have → stand
The saga has left residents disappointed and reopened longstanding frustrations about a city that has everything it needs to thrive – a prime location on the bay, a diverse population, a burgeoning arts and culture scene, and a growing economy – but a government that struggles to deliver basic services or answer for its shortcomings.
“When the news [of the FBI raids] broke, there was a wide range of feelings from the community,” said Stephanie Tran, president of the Oakland Chinatown chamber of commerce, of the fall from grace of a mayor who offered representation to Oakland’s sizeable Asian-American community.
asserted
who → leave → community
“Many were, quite honestly, just disappointed, even sad,” she said, that an Asian woman in such a high position of power was now associated with this controversy.
asserted
woman → say → controversy
‘People moved on’
asserted
People → move → ?
The bribery, conspiracy and fraud charges against Thao rest on claims that during her 2022 campaign, David and Andy Duong – a father and son whose family runs California Waste Solutions, the company that provides Oakland’s recycling services – paid for negative mailers attacking her rivals and promised her romantic partner, Andre Jones, a $300,000 no-show job.
uncertain
that → rest → job
In exchange, prosecutors allege, Thao promised to extend the company’s multi-million-dollar city contract, appoint the Duongs’ preferred people to important municipal positions, and buy shipping containers converted into homes for unhoused people from a company the Duongs ran with a business partner.
asserted
Duongs → allege → partner
All four defendants have pleaded not guilty, with their lawyers denying the existence of any bribery scheme.
asserted
lawyers → plead → scheme
Thao’s legal team did not respond to the Guardian’s request for comment.
asserted
team → respond → comment
Darwin BondGraham, news editor at local non-profit media outlet The Oaklandside, said the courthouse has been frequented by members of Oakland’s political class.
asserted
courthouse → say → class
But when it comes to everyday Oaklanders, many just want the mess behind them.
asserted
many → come → them
“The trial is accounting for things that happened when Oakland bottomed out during the first few years of the pandemic,” BondGraham said.
asserted
BondGraham → account → pandemic
“I think people moved on.”
asserted
people → think → ?
What many want is simple: a City Hall that fixes the potholes, answers 911 calls and acts with accountability.
asserted
that → want → accountability
But in Oakland – which has faced recurring budget deficits for decades, leading to substantial staffing shortages and hundreds of millions in deferred maintenance – these basic services are not a given.
asserted
services → face → maintenance
Those are the sorts of core concerns that pushed Emily Wasserman, a mother of two living in the city’s Laurel neighborhood, toward local advocacy.
asserted
that → push → advocacy
Thao had been her councilperson for several years, and Wasserman found her ineffective.
asserted
her → find → years
So she started volunteering with a voter education group, Empower Oakland, founded by Thao’s main rival in the 2022 election, Loren Taylor.
asserted
she → start → election
Part of the alleged bribery scheme involves the co-conspirators sending out campaign mailers critical of Taylor in exchange for favors from Thao.
asserted
conspirators → allege → Thao
While Oakland’s problems didn’t start with Thao, the failures of successive governments to address them came to a head during her post-Covid leadership.
asserted
failures → start → leadership
A recent report found that illegal dumping cost the city $10m more than it did a decade ago.
asserted
it → find → more
Police responses to the most urgent calls averaged 23 minutes in 2022 and at times stretched past an hour in 2023, yet a city audit last year found Oakland has no targets for how quickly officers should respond.
asserted
officers → average → targets
To Wasserman, the city’s shortcomings – and the allegations against Thao – speak to structural problems with how Oakland is governed.
asserted
Oakland → speak → problems
“One of the things that bothers me the most in our government is that there is not a lot of accountability to the general public,” she said.
asserted
she → bother → public
It isn’t for a lack of ideas, said Lakisha Young, founder and CEO of education non-profit The Oakland Reach.
asserted
Young → say → Reach
“Our city is inundated with initiatives,” she said, pointing to the many literacy, violence prevention, and affordable housing programs Oakland has approved in recent years – but that lack any formal infrastructure for tracking results
asserted
that → inundate → results
“It makes you feel like things are happening, but there is never any follow-through.”
asserted
things → make → ?
She says that if the city is serious about tackling some of its most intractable problems, like public school testing scores and children’s literacy rates, it needs to ensure that earmarked funds are used meaningfully and with oversight.
asserted
funds → say → oversight
“Every year our kids are behind in the same way they were behind when we had 60% less resources because we are not building an ecosystem that is accountable to measuring its results,” Young said.
asserted
Young → have → results
“When people are held accountable, different things happen.”
asserted
things → hold → ?
…and 17 more, not listed.