It was August 2021, and the disastrous fall of Kabul was underway, with the Taliban marching on the Afghan capital after President Joe Biden's chaotic withdrawal of US troops.
asserted
Taliban → march → troops
Everyone was mobilizing to try and help Afghans who had worked with the US military to escape, and former US first ladies were leaping into action.
asserted
ladies → mobilize → action
They had historically supported female empowerment in the country, aware that standing up for the rights of Afghan women was a cause that few could quibble with.
uncertain
few → support → that
But even as rumors swirled that 'kills lists' of female Afghan activists were circulating, one emergency call at the White House allegedly had a different priority: how to shield First Lady Jill Biden from any political fallout.
uncertain
call → swirl → fallout
'Hillary Clinton and Laura Bush mobilized their usual networks to mount independent missions to evacuate Afghan women,' author Azadeh Moaveni writes in a new book.
asserted
Moaveni → mobilize → book
'But while Hillary and Laura were hard at work, Jill Biden appeared to have gone missing.'
The call is detailed in The East Wing: Power, Intrigue, and the Untold Story of America's First Ladies, in which Moaveni traces Jill's time in the position from its promising start to her alleged Lady Macbeth-esque role trying to keep her ailing husband in power when he was up for re-election.
asserted
he → appear → election
Less than a year before the Kabul incident, the omens had been good when Jill's husband won the 2020 election, inheriting a country with a population that was bruised, exhausted and economically depressed after the Covid-19 pandemic and a tumultuous Trump presidency.
asserted
that → win → pandemic
Schools and families were struggling to get back to normal, but 'Jill was one of the few messengers in the administration who resonated with mothers and teachers, who was a teacher herself,' Moaveni writes.
asserted
Moaveni → struggle → mothers
She was also politically seasoned, having been at the side of her husband during his career as a senator then serving as Second Lady when he was Vice President to Barack Obama.
asserted
he → serve → Obama
But there were early signs that her allegiances were not primarily to the American people, Moaveni claims, but to a husband she had married when she was 26 years old, and to a family which had gone through intense personal turmoil and tragedy.
uncertain
which → be → turmoil
A new book traces Jill's time as First Lady from its promising start to her alleged Lady Macbeth-esque role trying to keep her ailing husband in power
There were early signs that Jill's allegiances were not primarily to the American people, Moaveni claims, but to her husband
Jill was politically seasoned, having been at the side of her husband during his career as a senator then serving as Second Lady when he was Vice President to Barack Obama
During Joe Biden's campaign for the presidency, Jill had visited the squalid Matamoros migrant encampment in Mexico just over the US border and penned an emotional op-ed in the Wall Street Journal asking, 'is this what we have become?' in Trump's America.
But within months of Biden assuming office, with migration on the southern border proving unpopular with voters, she quietly abandoned her initiative to reunite migrant families, a pattern she would repeat throughout her husband's presidency, The East Wing claims.
uncertain
Wing → trace → presidency
But Jill was singular in the way she subsumed herself into Joe's presidency,' writes Moaveni.
asserted
Moaveni → subsume → presidency
'She supported only causes that made him look good and abandoned them the moment they didn't.
asserted
they → support → them
Any subject that proved awkward to the Biden administration she would generally avoid, even when it related directly to her brand as an educator and an advocate for women.
asserted
it → prove → women
Case in point, at the time of the aforementioned fall of Kabul, Jill was involved in an initiative called Joining Forces which supported military families, but in their hour of need, her team had other priorities, the book claims, which was to stop 'all activities that might expose the First Lady to public anger.
uncertain
that → involve → anger
'They had a huge fear of doing anything at bases, they were just petrified,' a former staffer told Moaveni. 'Even though this was when military communities needed support.'
Jill put out a statement mourning the loss of lives a day after a suicide bomb at Kabul airport killed 13 US Service members and more than 170 Afghan civilians, telling military families: 'My heart is with you as you navigate what comes next.'
She avoided any mention of the political ramifications of the withdrawal at the time, although she acknowledged in her recent biography, View From The East Wing, that the fall of Kabul was a 'turning point for Joe's administration.
asserted
fall → have → administration
Jill's unerring loyalty can be traced back, Moaveni writes, to the start.
asserted
Moaveni → trace → start
When she married Joe in 1977, she inherited a family marked by tragedy.
asserted
she → marry → tragedy
Biden's wife Neilia and their 13-month-old daughter Naomi were killed in a car accident five years earlier.
asserted
wife → kill → accident
Their sons Hunter and Beau survived, and Jill had the difficult task of becoming 'both stepmother and substitute mother, tending to their lives as Joe commuted to Washington to build his political career.
asserted
Joe → survive → career
In 1981, Jill and Joe's daughter, Ashley, was born, but personal upheaval and tragedy followed the three children into adulthood.
asserted
upheaval → bear → adulthood
Beau died of brain cancer in 2015.
asserted
Beau → die → 2015
Both Hunter and Ashley struggled with addiction, with Hunter's very public meltdowns triggering a string of crises for the Bidens.
asserted
meltdowns → struggle → Bidens
Jill was loyal from the start, Moaveni writes, when she became 'both stepmother and substitute mother,' to Hunter Biden and Beau Biden, who died in 2015
In 1981, Jill and Joe's daughter, Ashley, was born, but personal upheaval and tragedy followed her into adulthood
Both Hunter and Ashley struggled with addiction, with Hunter's very public meltdowns triggering a string of crises for the Bidens
asserted
meltdowns → write → Bidens
The book details how Joe and Jill initially refused to publicly acknowledge the existence of a little granddaughter called Navy Roberts, whom Hunter Biden had fathered between his marriages.
asserted
Biden → detail → marriages
It took a scathing New York Times article in 2023 for them to relent and speak about her.
asserted
them → take → her
The article by Maureen Dowd said the Bidens' reluctance to publicly embrace the child 'reveals is how dated and inauthentic the 80-year-old president's view of family is.
asserted
view → say → family
A few weeks later, Joe Biden put out a statement saying he and Jill wanted the best for all their grandchildren, 'including Navy,' but it was 'not a political issue, it's a family matter.'
asserted
it → put → Navy
Jill's recent biography is dedicated to her daughter and her granddaughters, but Navy is not listed among them.
asserted
Navy → dedicate → them
The controversy highlighted how tangled their family life had become.
asserted
life → highlight → ?
'Both Bidens were carrying out their roles while parenting adult children on the brink – of relapse into addiction, of legal and financial ruin,' writes Moaveni.
asserted
Moaveni → carry → ruin
This desire to protect the family's privacy led to a number of political decisions, including the appointment of Anthony Bernal as Jill's senior advisor, a powerful gatekeeper variously described as Jill's 'work husband,' and the Biden 'marriage counsellor.
asserted
desire → protect → husband
'He never stopped wanting to hold her purse,' one insider told Moaveni.
asserted
insider → stop → Moaveni
'I think he would crawl into the coffin with her.'
asserted
he → think → her
The book goes on: 'Jill's approach to being First Lady was to act as Joe's lead messenger, and this suited Bernal.
asserted
this → go → Bernal
Her activities never took him out of his comfort zone.
asserted
activities → take → zone
Instead, Bernal excelled as the guardian of the Bidens' privacy, and this made him indispensable and the sole staffer in the East Wing to hold real power.
asserted
him → excel → power
'
But by keeping a tight cabal of long-time loyalists and 'Biden people' around her rather than innovative thinkers, Jill was left with 'an aura of blandness,' the book observes: 'They were all respected hands but not the sort of brilliant policy minds, politicos and PR A-listers that Michelle Obama had brought in.'
asserted
Obama → keep → that
The result was an uninspiring tenure as First Lady in which projects including the migration initiative and funding for community colleges were championed then quietly dropped.
asserted
projects → include → colleges
'Jill's approach to being First Lady was to act as Joe's lead messenger,' writes Moaveni
Jill's desire to protect the family's privacy led to the number of political decisions, including the appointment of Anthony Bernal, as Jill's senior advisor, a powerful gatekeeper
'[Jill] supported only causes that made him look good and abandoned them the moment they didn't,' writes Moaveni
Jill's tenure as First Lady was uninspiring as she championed and then quietly dropped projects including the migration initiative and funding for community colleges
Her initiative to provide free community college education failed when it was dropped from a broader spending bill, and while Jill said at the time that she was 'disappointed,' one insider told Moaveni: 'I didn't get the sense that she was on fire about it.'
'Over the course of four years, her First Ladyship unfolded as exceedingly narrow, even conservative,' Moaveni writes.
asserted
writes → act → years
…and 25 more, not listed.