Holyrood occasionally debates things other than independence, gender and Palestine, and last week it was broadcasting policy.
Sounds like a snoozefest, doesn’t it?
asserted
it → debate → snoozefest
Well, I wouldn’t recommend sleeping on this particular debate because it provided an insight into the SNP’s ambitions to snatch control of broadcast regulation.
asserted
it → recommend → regulation
MSPs voted 70 to 48 to demand Westminster comply with this plan.
asserted
Westminster → vote → plan
OK, imagine a future in which the power to regulate the BBC and other broadcasters in Scotland was in the hands of the SNP-dominated Scottish parliament.
asserted
power → imagine → parliament
The motion, tabled by Màiri McAllan (Nicola Sturgeon 2.0), supplied a taste of what they have in mind: ‘BBC television and radio must authentically reflect the lives of people in Scotland.’
asserted
television → table → Scotland
The current governance arrangements, set at UK level, seemingly produce an inauthentic version of Scotland but, with Holyrood in charge, we could look forward to the BBC being more authentically Scottish.
uncertain
BBC → set → charge
You don’t need a stint at Bletchley Park on your CV to decipher this particular code.
asserted
You → need → code
Holyrood wants the power to make broadcasting more to its liking.
asserted
broadcasting → want → liking
The motion echoes sentiments expressed by John Swinney, who said: ‘We need a thriving national broadcaster to represent our country, and it’s time for the powers to be devolved to a parliament that actually cares about it.’
asserted
that → echo → it
Holyrood cares about the troubles of Scottish broadcasting in the same way a shark cares about the crew of a sinking boat.
asserted
shark → care → boat
The pretext for the power grab, and it is nothing more than a pretext, is the announcement in October of ‘plans to close the linear BBC Scotland channel and move it to become an exclusively digital-first service’.
asserted
it → close → it
Màiri McAllan believes 'BBC television and radio must authentically reflect the lives of people in Scotland'
asserted
television → believe → Scotland
For anyone who took French in high school rather than Lanyardese, this means that you’ll no longer get BBC Scotland on your telly but it will still be available on the iPlayer.
asserted
it → take → iPlayer
In the main, everything else remains the same, though the evening news broadcast is being dropped and staff have been told to expect redundancies.
asserted
staff → remain → redundancies
Before I stick the boot into the SNP, a quick shoeing is in order for BBC management.
asserted
shoeing → stick → management
The notion that what public service broadcasting in Scotland really needs is less funding and fewer staff is the philosophy of the bean-counter and the logic of the vandal.
asserted
needs → need → vandal
Public service broadcasting does need to adapt to changing viewer habits – it’s already the case that more watch BBC Scotland on iPlayer than TV – but adaptation should not be used as an excuse to reduce the quality of programming.
asserted
adaptation → need → programming
The Corporation’s overpaid executive class would do well to remember what adds value to the Beeb, and it’s not those patter-merchants who drift from one meeting to another blathering soullessly about aligning synergies and integrating verticals.
asserted
who → do → verticals
It’s skilled and experienced professionals who produce news and current affairs, documentaries, original drama and comedy, and serious arts programming.
asserted
who → ’ → news
BBC Scotland needs more staff and resources in these areas.
asserted
Scotland → need → areas
What it doesn’t need is the SNP getting control over broadcasting policy.
asserted
SNP → need → policy
I have some experience of the SNP’s keen interest in broadcast journalism.
asserted
I → have → journalism
A decade ago, I was digital politics and comment editor at STV, overseeing online political coverage as well as writing commentary and commissioning the same from a wide range of contributors.
asserted
I → oversee → contributors
Both my punditry and the contributions I commissioned crossed political lines, commending or rebuking Holyrood and Westminster as required, and toed no line on either the independence referendum or the Brexit vote.
Yet when two SNP MPs expressed their disapproval of my journalism I was told I could no longer continue in my combined role as online editor and political commentator.
uncertain
I → commission → editor
The BBC Scotland channel is moving to become an exclusively digital-first service
My bosses at STV were willing to cave but I wasn’t, and my refusal to go along with their cowardly kowtowing meant my writing disappeared, without explanation, in the second half of 2016.
asserted
writing → move → 2016
When my absence was noticed I found myself the subject of news reports, radio discussions and op-eds, but still on STV’s staff I was unable to defend myself.
asserted
I → notice → myself
In the end, HMS Daily Mail appeared on the horizon and tossed me a cherished lifeline.
asserted
Mail → appear → lifeline
In preparing for this week’s column, I returned to my debut essay for this newspaper, recounting my experience.
asserted
I → prepare → experience
That was a very difficult time in my life, more difficult than I’ve ever spoken about or suspect I ever will.
asserted
I → speak → life
What stood out most in the essay, a decade on, were the paragraphs detailing how certain sections of the media and especially Civic Scotland responded.
asserted
sections → stand → media
All those part-time advocates of media freedom who either kept quiet or, in some cases, approved of my treatment.
asserted
who → keep → treatment
It speaks to just how profoundly the civic life of a nation can be poisoned by the venom of national identity politics, or any ideology that insists upon loyalty to a movement over fidelity to the civic principles that breed open, pluralistic and self-reflective nations.
asserted
that → speak → nations
This is why I fear the consequences of devolving broadcasting.
asserted
I → fear → broadcasting
A rottweiler government will not be kept in check by a lapdog parliament, nor by a civil society where too many behave like footsoldiers of the political order of the day.
asserted
many → keep → day
In this way, Scottish civil society differs from its UK equivalent, which has its own problems with ideologically captured organisations but which also enjoys a measure of viewpoint diversity and institutional independence.
asserted
which → differ → diversity
Wait a minute, you might say; regulation of print media is not reserved under the Scotland Act and Holyrood hasn’t stuck its oar in there.
uncertain
Holyrood → wait → oar
The difference is that newspapers have strong editorial voices and can use their front pages to clobber any government plotting to interfere with their autonomy.
asserted
newspapers → have → autonomy
Broadcasters are regulated differently and would have to maintain perfect neutrality while clueless civil servants, corporate chancers and axe-grinding ideologues earned fat pensions and consultancy fees reinventing a wheel that needs only to be funded properly.
asserted
that → regulate → wheel
Pressure was applied on STV over Stephen Daisley's political commentary
The risk is not one of crude propaganda or editorial decisions dictated by commissars in St Andrew’s House.
asserted
risk → apply → House
No one seriously believes Scottish broadcasting, regulated from Holyrood, would turn overnight into North Korean state television, complete with Martin Geissler in a pink chima jeogori blaming anti-revolutionary forces for undermining the Dear Leader’s third five-year referendum plan.
asserted
Geissler → believe → plan
…and 9 more, not listed.