Solomon Islands opposition accuses Australia of 'chequebook diplomacy' over grants to government MPs
In short:
The Solomon Islands opposition has accused Australia of "chequebook diplomacy" after Prime Minister Matthew Wale funnelled budget support from Canberra.
asserted
Wale → accuse → Canberra
Documents seen by the ABC show that multiple parliamentarians received "discretionary grants".
asserted
parliamentarians → see → grants
A federal government spokesperson has denied any wrongdoing, saying "all of Australia's development assistance is based on the priorities of partner countries".
asserted
all → deny → countries
The Solomon Islands opposition has accused Australia of "chequebook diplomacy" after Prime Minister Matthew Wale funnelled budget support from Canberra into constituency funds for government MPs as the two countries wrapped up negotiations on a high-profile treaty due to be signed next week.
asserted
countries → accuse → treaty
Government documents seen by the ABC show that multiple parliamentarians in Mr Wale's 31-strong GREAT Coalition received "discretionary grants" of up to $SBD1 million (about $180,000) per MP in their constituency accounts in October and November.
asserted
parliamentarians → see → October
The payments were made from a bank account labelled AusAID — the name previously used by the Australian government's aid agency before it was wrapped into DFAT in 2013 — which initially drew accusations of direct foreign interference from the opposition.
asserted
which → make → opposition
But the ABC has established that the bank account is not an Australian government one and belongs to the Solomon Islands government instead.
asserted
account → establish → government
The money seems to have been drawn from a larger $SBD200 million ($35 million) package of budget support announced by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in June this year when Mr Wale visited Canberra.
asserted
Wale → seem → Canberra
At the time, Mr Wale's government said the money would "assist Solomon Islands in responding to Tropical Cyclone Maila and addressing the impacts of global energy shocks".
asserted
money → say → shocks
The use of constituency development funds (CDFs) has long drawn scrutiny and controversy in the Pacific Island nation, and Mr Wale's actions are not unprecedented.
asserted
actions → draw → nation
Politics in Solomon Islands is fluid and transactional, and previous Solomon Islands governments have also funnelled money from donors — including from both Taiwan and China — into CDFs for MPs, helping them to shore up their sometimes-wobbly coalitions in parliament.
But
asserted
them → funnel → parliament
Opposition Leader and former prime minister Manasseh Sogavare, who has a vexed history with Australia, has taken aim at Mr Wale, while accusing the federal government of meddling and hypocrisy.
asserted
who → have → meddling
"If Australia is channelling money to members of parliament through the Prime Minister's Office while it negotiates a 'comprehensive treaty', that is chequebook diplomacy,"he said.
"
asserted
that → channel → treaty
It puts Australian aid at the centre of our domestic politics.
asserted
It → put → politics
Australia has rightly criticised other countries for doing exactly this in the Pacific.
asserted
Australia → criticise → Pacific
It should hold itself to the same standard."
asserted
It → hold → standard
Mr Sogavare also said money from Australian taxpayers was being used to "reward political loyalty", unfairly excluding the opposition.
asserted
money → say → opposition
"The people who lose are not opposition MPs.
asserted
who → lose → ?
They are the villages, schools and clinics in the constituencies left out," he said.
asserted
he → leave → constituencies
"Aid should go to people according to need, not according to how their member votes."
uncertain
member → go → need
Mr Wale's office declined to comment on the documents.
asserted
office → decline → documents
A federal government spokespesron denied any wrongdoing, saying "all of Australia's development assistance is based on the priorities of partner countries, subject to robust accountability and transparency guidelines, and complies with the OECD development guidelines."
Australia has never paid money directly to Solomon Islands MPs, and the money from budget support was provided to the Ministry of Finance and Treasury in Honiara.
asserted
money → deny → Honiara
One federal government source also emphasised that Mr Wale and his ministers, and not the Australian government, ultimately made the decisions about how to spend budget support.
asserted
Wale → emphasise → support
But the opposition's accusation is still politically dangerous, as it comes just nine days before Mr Wale is expected to visit Canberra to sign a sweeping new "comprehensive" treaty between the two nations, less than six months since negotiations began.
asserted
negotiations → come → nations
In September, the ABC revealed that Australia was planning to substantially ramp up contributions to constituency development funds under that treaty, although none of that funding has yet been provided.
asserted
none → reveal → funding
In a leaked text message, the Australian High Commissioner Jeff Roach laid out new commitments totalling more than $980 million under the agreement, while emphasising that both governments were hoping to lock in the pact before the end of this year.
asserted
governments → leak → year
In his statement, Mr Sogavare again criticised the timing of that text message, saying it was sent just before Mr Wale was due to face a looming no-confidence vote in parliament, and suggesting Australia was trying to prop up the prime minister's leadership to secure the treaty.
"The motion was withdrawn days later.
asserted
motion → criticise → treaty
are entitled to ask whether that is a coincidence," he said.
asserted
he → entitle → ?
"Both governments should answer openly.
asserted
governments → answer → ?
But his accusations are likely to rankle with Canberra, given Mr Sogavare was himself accused of using CDFs to bolster his political position when facing parliamentary challenges as prime minister.
asserted
Sogavare → rankle → minister
For example, in 2021 Mr Wale — then in opposition — complained when Mr Sogavare channelled money from China into CDFs for 39 government and crossbench MPs, saying the prime minister had deliberately excluded his political enemies.
asserted
minister → complain → enemies
Kerryn Baker from the Australian National University's Department of Pacific Affairs said while the optics of Mr Wale's payments were not ideal, it was "definitely not the first time that opposition MPs have complained their access to funds is blocked or restricted".
asserted
access → say → funds
"There are always problems with fairness, even if funds are going equally to every MP, because the size of constituencies in Solomon Islands varies wildly — you have some with a few thousand voters and some with tens of thousands,"she said.
asserted
size → be → thousands,"she
"So the system isn't perfect, even before you get into political games."
asserted
you → get → games
There has long been a debate around the effectiveness of constituency development funds, with some development experts warning they are a vector for corruption and that they encourage patronage politics.
asserted
they → warn → politics
But Dr Baker said while there was a "risk" in contributing to CDFs, it was "probably a risk worth taking", and that the funding mechanism was "definitely more than a slush fund".
"CDFs are hugely important for development.
asserted
CDFs → say → development
It's a way to ensure funds reach the grassroots and can be spent on what communities need," she said.
asserted
she → ensure → what
"It's definitely not the ideal system, but Australia has poured in a huge amount of money in the past trying to strengthen central government institutions, and that hasn't been super successful.
asserted
that → pour → institutions
"So trying things a different way, to try to make sure money for development reaches the people that need it, isn't necessarily a bad thing."
asserted
that → try → it
The Wale government has also tried to tighten up the way that some of the payments have been made to local constituencies through CDFs.
asserted
some → try → CDFs
…and 4 more, not listed.