Photo via The Sydney Morning Herald

‘Not acting in good faith’: The empty block becoming a thorn in a booming suburb’s side

Read the original at The Sydney Morning Herald ↗
Cite

Morgan, C. (2026, November 16). ‘Not acting in good faith’: The empty block becoming a thorn in a booming suburb’s side. The Sydney Morning Herald. https://www.smh.com.au/national/victoria/not-acting-in-good-faith-the-empty-block-becoming-a-thorn-in-a-booming-suburb-s-side-20261116-p61e9f.html?ref=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_source=rss_feed

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

The Sydney Morning Herald · collected 2026-11-16 · by Cassandra Morgan

Quick Summary

In West Footscray, a bustling suburb known for its vibrant cafes and community events, an empty brick shopfront and a large razed block owned by the Uniting Church stand out as unused spaces. The shopfront, vacant for about a decade, was recently rejected for use by the local writers festival due to its unfit state. Local businesses and community members feel the church's inaction is detrimental to the area's development and accuse it of land banking, which they view as irresponsible. The church has announced plans to develop a modern community space on the site, but these plans have not yet been made public, frustrating locals who see the delays as a missed opportunity for community growth.
Written by AI on 2026-11-16, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).

AI analysis

Story summary

In West Footscray, a 1580-square-metre empty block owned by The Uniting Church has become a contentious issue, dividing the otherwise thriving community. The empty land and unused shopfront on Barkly Street stand out in contrast to the bustling local businesses and community events like the annual Footscray West Writers Fest. When festival co-founder Jess Lilley approached the church in 2024 to use the vacant shopfront, she was turned down due to the space not having toilets and not being in a "fit state" to lease. Despite this, the neighborhood continues to face a shortage of community spaces, making the empty property a source of frustration for locals who see it as wasted potential.

Written for “Empty Block Dispute In Suburb” on 2026-11-17, grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.

Compared with similar articles

Nothing to compare against. No article is close enough to this one for the pipeline to have linked or judged the pair.

Story

Empty Block Dispute In Suburb
Politics · 1 article(s) covering the same event.
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
32
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
6%
2 of 32 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
withheld
no quote in the article backed the model's score
Publisher signals
61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-11-16 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

The Sydney Morning Herald · 7402 article(s) · 15 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 15 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Cassandra Morgan
12 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
The land comprising some 1580 square metres might be akin to a pin on a map in the Uniting Church’s property portfolio, but in West Footscray, it’s a glaring physical divider on Barkly Street, Lilley said.
“The Lighthouse Cafe has outgrown this space and will be relocating to a larger premises,” reads the glossy A4.
“Because a major data centre cluster exists in and around Truganina, having direct fibre run through to Werribee and East Werribee would eliminate long-distance routing,” the alliance of local public and private sector leaders said. “Local businesses would experience sub-millisecond round-trip response times – making local processing feel instantaneous compared to standard connections.
“It’s a decision that says this is so important that we’re willing to blow $70 million,” Miller told The Age’s Melbourne Assembly civic forum on Wednesday.
The coffee is good, but Federation Square needs to be fixed – those are the first takeaways from former New York mayor Bill de Blasio and world-leading city planner Carlos Moreno after hitting Melbourne’s sunny pavements.
The former VicRoads headquarters will make way for up to 630 homes in towers as tall as 16 storeys under a contentious plan by the state government that has been rebuked by the local council.
That’s all my money will buy me?”
“I would have tried a dozen places before, because Alexandra Gardens said ‘no’ to me for months,” says Sloan, elbows resting on a leather armchair in a Melbourne hotel lobby.
Workers were promised no frontline roles would be affected – but the definition of frontline was unclear, sparking concerns for jobs across administration, conservation and education.
Gender and urban design expert Nicole Kalms says that, as temperatures rise with climate change, cities including Melbourne will shift their work, commerce and recreation to the nighttime economy.
Also by Cassandra Morgan
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 12 articles by Cassandra Morgan →

Topics

A Makers Market Footscray West Writers Fest The Uniting Church’s Uniting Church West Footscray

Subjects

Lilley PERSON · 5× Uniting Church ORG · 4× The Uniting Church’s ORG · 2× West Footscray GPE · 2× A Makers Market ORG · 1× Footscray GPE · 1× Jess Lilley PERSON · 1× Migrant Coffee ORG · 1× Writers fest ORG · 1× the Uniting Church ORG · 1×

Narrative

“Like all projects of this size there are many pre-planning issues to resolve, including a design within the flood overlay, engineering suitable to ground conditions, fire safety aspects in building to a boundary and traffic management in developing the land suitable to the surrounding environment,” a Uniting Church spokeswoman said.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-11-16
The land comprising some 1580 square metres might be akin to a pin on a map in the Uniting Church’s property portfolio, but in West Footscray, it’s a glaring physical divider on Barkly Street, Lilley said.
2026-11-16 · The Sydney Morning Herald
‘Not acting in good faith’: The empty block becoming a thorn in a booming suburb’s side · assertive framing

Claims (32 extracted, 2 hedged)

The West Footscray village is the kind of place locals greet their baristas by name. asserted
locals → greet → name
On a relaxed Sunday morning, tables are lined up outside Barkly Street cafes filled with people leaning back on wooden chairs, chatting happily with their kids and dogs in tow. asserted
tables → line → tow
A Makers Market put on by the traders association opened on Saturday in a vacant shopfront, and a yoga studio, wine bar and pizza joint are among local businesses who give up their space for the annual Footscray West Writers Fest. asserted
who → put → Fest
But some feel there’s an outlier on the strip. asserted
some → feel → strip
The Uniting Church’s brick shopfront and large neighbouring razed block are off-limits and empty – the shopfront, vacant for about a decade. asserted
shopfront → raze → decade
Writers fest co-founder and artistic director Jess Lilley approached the charity about using the shopfront for the event back in 2024, and was told the space (a brick and concrete box) did not have toilets and was not in “a fit state” to lease. asserted
space → approach → state
When Lilley offered to organise toilets, and asked if six months was enough time to get the shop in better shape, the answer was still no. asserted
answer → offer → shape
While the Uniting Church lets the shop and land sit unusable and empty, the neighbourhood is contending with a deficit of community space, Lilley said. asserted
Lilley → let → space
“It just sucks because the community is exploding around here. asserted
community → suck → ?
It’s a really active and engaged community, and it feels like there should be some momentum, but this village just never takes off,” Lilley said. asserted
Lilley → ’ → ?
“It feels like they’re not acting in good faith.” asserted
they → feel → faith
Lilley and backers argue the church’s behaviour amounts to land banking, which she says is “reprehensible” for an organisation meant to support the community. asserted
she → argue → community
The issue – which is symptomatic of a more complex problem, whereby high construction costs, elevated taxes and charges, expensive finance and subdued apartment values are deterring landowners from developing projects – is widespread in Footscray. asserted
costs → deter → Footscray
The land comprising some 1580 square metres might be akin to a pin on a map in the Uniting Church’s property portfolio, but in West Footscray, it’s a glaring physical divider on Barkly Street, Lilley said. uncertain
Lilley → comprise → Street
She suggested the church should invest in making the space usable, even temporarily. uncertain
space → suggest → ?
Migrant Coffee co-owner Andrew Ly said business owners on the strip tried to work together to make it more vibrant. asserted
it → say → strip
“When you have a party who is not willing to contribute to that … it’s such a shame,” Ly said. asserted
Ly → have → that
“When you have an empty part [of the strip], what that means is there’s nothing going on there. asserted
means → have → what
There’s no reason for people to go there.” asserted
people → ’ → ?
Uniting Church confirmed it plans to develop a modern worship and community space on the site, comprising gathering and meeting spaces, dual kitchens, an “indoor enchanted garden” and a carpark. asserted
it → confirm → spaces
However, the plans – initially intended to be put to council in mid-2026 – are yet to publicly materialise. asserted
plans → intend → mid-2026
“Like all projects of this size there are many pre-planning issues to resolve, including a design within the flood overlay, engineering suitable to ground conditions, fire safety aspects in building to a boundary and traffic management in developing the land suitable to the surrounding environment,” a Uniting Church spokeswoman said. asserted
spokeswoman → be → environment
“We have been focused on developing a proposal that satisfies the needs of a widely varied worshipping community at Footscray while providing a modern facility that meets the needs of today. asserted
that → focus → today
This takes time and it is important to get it right. asserted
it → take → time
The church that previously stood on the vacant 1053 square metre grass block at 557a Barkly Street was declared unsafe due to its age and wear and tear, before it was bulldozed in 2021, the Uniting Church spokeswoman confirmed. asserted
spokeswoman → stand → 2021
She cited “vandalism and rubbish dumping” as additional factors behind its demolition, and said remaining structures “do not satisfy the legal requirements for leasing”. asserted
structures → cite → leasing
“The remaining minor structures will be demolished with the forthcoming project,” the Uniting spokeswoman said. asserted
spokeswoman → remain → project
At the Makers Market on Barkly Street on Sunday, families wandered in to get a start on their Christmas shopping, marvelling at local artists’ work in what was a vacant shop just days ago. asserted
what → wander → work
The West 3012 Business Association is waiting to hear whether they’ll be able to renew their short lease on the space, which they secured through a council grant, association president Reem Sweid said. asserted
Sweid → wait → grant
Sweid, who co-founded West Footscray Arts with Lilley, believes the church has a different obligation to the community than private landowners. asserted
church → co → landowners
She said more than 90 people applied to stock their work at the market. asserted
people → say → market
Before they find out about the lease, though, the women are just happy to see a vacant shopfront put to good use. asserted
shopfront → find → use
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support