In short:
An investigation into former minister Madeleine Ogilvie related to an alleged conflict of interest over a election grant for her daughter's rowing club, parliament has heard.
asserted
parliament → relate → club
A parliamentary committee has been told the outcome of the Integrity Commission probe may never come to light.
uncertain
outcome → tell → light
Last week, the Supreme Court ruled the commission did not have the legal power to release investigations in parliament.
asserted
commission → rule → parliament
A lawyer who acted for former minister Madeleine Ogilvie in her Integrity Commission case has told a Tasmanian parliamentary committee that the public may never know the outcome of the investigation.
uncertain
public → act → investigation
Premier Jeremy Rockliff confirmed in parliament earlier this year that both Ms Ogilvie and former minister Jane Howlett are under investigation by the state's integrity watchdog.
asserted
Ogilvie → confirm → watchdog
Little is known about the two investigations, which date from 2022, and it is unclear when, or if, the reports will be made public.
uncertain
reports → know → 2022
At a parliamentary committee into the Integrity Commission on Monday, lawyer Chris Gunson SC said while some cases might need to be kept confidential, the principle was applied too broadly and could be onerous for all involved.
uncertain
principle → say → all
"One of the biggest difficulties that arises from Integrity Commission investigations, particularly of ministers, is how to deal with the knowledge that there is an investigation at all," he told the committee.
asserted
he → arise → committee
Using Ms Ogilvie's matter as an example, he said he did not believe the case required such secrecy.
asserted
case → use → secrecy
He told the committee that the main allegation related to a purported conflict of interest during the 2021 election campaign.
asserted
allegation → tell → campaign
"[She made] an election commitment to fund a pontoon at a rowing club," he told the committee.
"
asserted
he → make → committee
What was said to be the conflict of interest was [that] her daughter happened to be a member of the rowing club.
asserted
daughter → say → club
It was also said the conflict arose because Ms Ogilvie's husband, two years after the event, became a gym-only member of the same rowing club."
asserted
husband → say → club
Mr Gunson said the Supreme Court identified "very significant problems with that", such as "when can a conflict arise".
asserted
conflict → say → that
"There was no benefit that either Ms Ogilvie or her daughter would receive over and above what an ordinary member of the public or relevant member of the rowing club would attain," he said.
asserted
he → be → club
'The public should be able to know,' Ogilvie's lawyer says
It was confirmed earlier this year that Ms Ogilvie had initiated Supreme Court action involving the Integrity Commission.
asserted
Ogilvie → know → Commission
Mr Gunson told the committee that was because the Integrity Commission imposed very broad confidentiality requirements, and so, suppression orders regarding even the existence of the case were put in place.
asserted
orders → tell → place
"Not because the applicants involved wanted to hide what was going on, but rather because the Integrity Commission had imposed strict confidentiality requirements," he told the committee.
asserted
he → involve → committee
"Obviously the starting point with any litigation is the principle of open justice and the public should be able to know and observe what occurs in the courts."
asserted
what → know → courts
During the hearing, Greens MLC Cassy O'Connor asked for an update on Ms Ogilvie's investigation, known as Operation Olegas.
asserted
O'Connor → ask → Olegas
"It's now four-and-a-half years since the investigation began.
asserted
investigation → begin → ?
There is no information in the public domain, as I understand it.
asserted
I → be → it
Journalists can't even get copies of the suppression order,"she said.
asserted
Journalists → get → order,"she
Mr Gunson told the committee that last week the Supreme Court ruled that the Integrity Commission did not have the power to table investigations in parliament, which is how it makes them public.
asserted
them → tell → parliament
He said the result of that "may be that no-one ever knows what the outcome of that investigation was".
uncertain
outcome → say → investigation